Re:Babbage's heart-warming message for the middle-aged
by zeteo on Friday October 08, 2010 @12:49PM
(#1772251)
Yes, a story can have a message, but "Babbage" is a person, not a story. "This story's message" has a different agent from "Jim's message". Jim is always the _author_ in the second meaning.
"Babbage's message" made the title shorter, but also misleading. A complete title of "Babbage's heart-warming" would have made it even shorter, but I hope you're not advocating in favor of that!
Re:Babbage's heart-warming message for the middle-aged
by r7000 on Friday October 08, 2010 @01:14PM
(#1772371)
Reflecting today I believe Jim's inspiring message to us is to live life to the fullest even if that requires participation in extreme sports.
Jim did not write a letter. He was the "author" of the sentiment (according to the speaker) by the way he lived his life.
Re:Babbage's heart-warming message for the middle-aged
by senthil_rajasek on Friday October 08, 2010 @11:44AM
(#1772022)
"Babbage's message..." and "A message from Babbage's Life...".
are not identical. The former is a personal article or note from Babbage.
I got down voted for exactly what zeteo said...
Re:Babbage's heart-warming message for the middle-aged
by r7000 on Friday October 08, 2010 @12:03PM
(#1772090)
"A message from Babbage's Life..." is too long. A title can trade ambiguity for elegance if the essay is clear.
Re:Babbage's heart-warming message for the middle-aged
by senthil_rajasek on Friday October 08, 2010 @12:28PM
(#1772193)
"Babbage's heart-warming message for the middle-aged"
and "A message from Babbage's life for the middle-aged"
to me both titles sound elegant but the former is misleading and the latter is correct.
The title is not trading ambiguity, it is just misleading.
A story or experience can have a "message" the same way it might have a "moral". In fact "moral" is often defined as: the message conveyed by a story.
"Example" would have been a poorer word in its place.