For a crude example, pick health history. The leading cause of bankruptcy in the US is medical bills due to a health crisis. This of course spills over into mortgage foreclosure. But someone might have excellent credit, and a high cancer risk. They get cancer, byebye loan. Are you accounting for that?
Someone has excellent credit, but works in a dying industry and has no skills to move to an equal-paying job in another industry. Their job goes away in five years, byebye mortgage. I can go on with these. But my point is, I don't know if you realize just what a difficult point you're making with your simple answer.
I think the problem with using money lending as a tool for social justice and equality was laid bare during the crisis. The downsides - lack of mobility for workers, pushing the risk from wealthy people (investors) to poorer people and the fact to function the system needs loans to be paid back at some percentage approaching 100 - all conspire to make this a really poor tool for change.
I think that something like the Australian approach - with enforced retirement savings set at 9% of income (where you earn $50K, and your employer pays $4.5K into super) - is a saner approach to wealth creation for the poorer groups than lumbering them with mortgages.
That’s not what happened. It wasn’t poor people who caused most of the defaults - it was investors working with mortgage brokers, real estate agents, and appraisers who were all part of the take. Poor people weren’t doing most of the no doc/negative interest or other types of “non conforming mortgages”. The investors walked away, did strategic defaults, and were free and clear within 3 years - ask me how I know....
There's a big difference between a community bank using community ties as a source of superior intelligence, and a big company acting as a mortgage mill trying to maximize throughput "countrywide" until the bubble bursts. Before the community banks existed, Asian community groups would arrange private lending within the community.
I think that something like the Australian approach - with enforced retirement savings set at 9% of income (where you earn $50K, and your employer pays $4.5K into super) - is a saner approach to wealth creation for the poorer groups than lumbering them with mortgages.
It sounds good on the surface. I'd let people opt-in on that, though.
That is itself the tightest of feedback loops, because the best estimator is either current wealth, or past performance of loans. It is massively exclusionary so I don't think your point is very well made.
if you're worried about feedback loops, maybe don't lend based on any criteria other than the best possible estimate of ability to pay the loan back.
if you loan somebody money for a house that they can't pay back, they're going to 1) end up with even worse credit and 2) lose the house, which they made other emotional and financial investments in.