News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by brobdingnagians on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:24AM (#17714270)
Currently a US citizen living in Spain, I hit these decently often looking up news articles that look interesting about things in the US, but stopped short by the notices about GDPR. I'd be curious if some of the newspapers eventually comply after several court cases defining some details on how it is treated-- seems disproportionately higher for newspapers; anyone know why? other than their audiences don't tend to be in Europe?
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by guitarbill on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:30AM (#17714300)
A lot of these sites are ostensibly local US news or media (e.g. WPTA - Fort Wayne, IN), and it's hard to see how they fall under the GDPR.

So either it's a political statement, or they somehow are subject to the GDPR, e.g. they are owned by a multi-national conglomerate, or sell data to them.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by dmortin on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:34AM (#17714329)
They don't want to devote resources to investigate what should they do to comply. It's a business decision. If only a fraction of their visitors come from the EU then it may not be worth it to deal with the GDPR.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by DanBC on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @08:30AM (#17715310)
> If only a fraction of their visitors come from the EU then it may not be worth it to deal with the GDPR.

If only a fraction of their users come from the EU they don't need to deal with GDPR, they're exempt from it.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by nicktelford on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:36AM (#17714340)
They'd be subject to the GDPR if someone visited from within the EU and they stored data about that visitor as far as I'm aware.

Edit: this is incorrect, see comment by guitarbill below.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by guitarbill on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:46AM (#17714400)
no, we've literally been over this a hundred times in other threads about the GDPR. if your business is outside the EU, and you don't target EU data subjects specifically, then how are you subject to the GDPR? there's no legal basis. even the GDPR legislation acknowledges this, for example in section 23:

> In order to determine whether such a controller or processor is offering goods or services to data subjects who are in the Union, it should be ascertained whether it is apparent that the controller or processor envisages offering services to data subjects in one or more Member States in the Union.

it's far more likely they aren't "local" news stations, but owned by a multi-national, or selling data to multi-national corporations subject to GDPR.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by adventured on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:16AM (#17714562)
You're getting downvoted despite being factually and legally correct.

You do not have to comply with GDPR if you are fully outside of the EU's jurisdiction and do no business in the EU.

Every site that gets created does not have to try to comply with every privacy law from every place on earth. At this point it's just belligerent propaganda to try to claim otherwise. It serves no good purpose to lie and pretend that every site on earth with EU visitors must comply with GDPR. That's a non-functioning future: all sites will not be able to comply with all privacy laws from all jurisdictions around the world. It's also legally unenforceable hogwash.

It goes even further however. As an EU citizen not only does GDPR not grant you any new protections in the US jurisdiction, you have very few privacy protections (none?) in the US. Sites with no business in the EU, those that aren't covered by the EU in any manner jurisdiction wise, can do nearly anything they want to with EU citizen data. Lawsuits can be filed against such sites, and they'll be promptly dismissed because the US isn't governed by EU law.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by jacobgreenleaf on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @07:58AM (#17715103)
The fact that it’s a “non functioning future” is exactly why people are concerned. It’s entirely possible to regulate a set of activities out of existence if you make the cost of compliance too high. In this case the per user margins are low (FB ARPU is about $25 before expenses).
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by repolfx on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:26AM (#17714615)
A website that serves people who connect from the EU can easily be argued to be "offering services to data subjects within the Union".

That paragraph really doesn't say what you think it says. But like all such EU legislation it's really so vague that people who support the EU's political aims will read something anodyne into it, and people who are more suspicious will read something more dangerous, and they can both be right depending on the whims of the commission and ECJ.

However I will note that the EU does have an established track record of making surprising and totally unintuitive judgements about laws that appear to be much clearer and more definitive than what you just cited. The wording of the law is really not as reliable as you might hope with the ECJ.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by nicktelford on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:17AM (#17714566)
I stand corrected! Not sure why you're being down-voted for it.

Another point is that the organisation would need some kind of legal presence in the EU, otherwise it would be impossible to prosecute them even if they did violate EU law.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by raverbashing on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:32AM (#17714311)
Yeah, they don't fall under GDPR it's mostly a knee-jerk reaction (or, as you mentioned, they are owned by a bigger conglomerate)
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by chrismeller on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:46AM (#17714395)
IP addresses are specifically considered to be personal data, so even accepting a page view from an EU citizen and writing the IP to an Apache log file could subject them to it. Same with cookies and any kind of analytics or advertising partners (which most local news sites seem oddly heavy on).

Even if they somehow figured out that they were already completely compliant (and ignoring the work involved in discovering that), there are policies and procedures you need to write to document who you share their data with and respond to requests from EU citizens about their data and the features to support answering those.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by josteink on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:50AM (#17714736)
> IP addresses are specifically considered to be personal data

Again. Knee jerk internet reactions divorced from reality.

Access logs are not illegal under the GDPR. Stop spreading FUD.

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by raverbashing on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @08:27AM (#17715293)
> so even accepting a page view from an EU citizen and writing the IP to an Apache log file could subject them to it.

You better inform yourself before making incorrect assertions

But it does get tiring, really

Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by guitarbill on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:36AM (#17714341)
well, the latter is quite insidious, and something they've likely tried to keep a secret. Weirdly, this could a win for transparency by the GDPR even outside of Europe.
Re:List of Websites not available in the EU because of GDPR by Mashimo on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:27AM (#17714287)
Maybe they relay more on selling data?