News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by dandare on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @04:43AM (#17714129)
I have long argued that any act of positive discrimination results in an equal amount of negative discrimination. Be it sex, race, social background, income or any other attribute. Some argue that positive discrimination is the most efficient way to right past wrongs or that it has a net positive effect on a society but that does not negate the effect of the negative discrimination on the affected individuals. What does HN think?
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by didibus on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:41AM (#17714372)
I think the idea of positive discrimination is related to countering inherent bias.

You might think A isn't as qualified as B. But it is known that inherent bias against A is very likely. So you might decide, even though I believe B to be more qualified, I will go with A, knowing that my judgement might be wrong, because of the likelihood of inherent bias.

In a way, yes, the known biases, can create a new bias. I bias against my known biases. This does mean that at an individual level, I favored someone else, when I initially wouldn't have. But does it result in better outcomes? I think this is where it matters. Let me explain.

If one is chosen and given opportunity over another. That choice is always going to be judgemental and opinionated. You're trying to predict who will make better use of the opportunity and contribute back the most for being given it.

But predictions, like in machine learning, show that a biased data set often perform poorly. So I think part of positive discrimination is to say, diversity could actually yield better results. Yet, because we don't have diverse data, we don't know for sure. But its still okay for the person who chooses to be of the opinion that it would. I find that no different then saying, well I felt they were more knowledgeable. All of it are intractable metrics in an attempt to predict outcome.

Edit: Some more thoughts related to fairness. Is it fair to give opportunity only to those who would maximise it? What if it was true, that there was a genetic quality, sex, or race, or a more specific one, like height, IQ, EQ, etc., which was the key variable to maximize the opportunity? Is it fair to say only they shall be given such opportunity, always? Or should we pick at random? Would that be more fair? Are there other scheme? What does it even mean to be fair? Your genetics aren't fair, should society be fairer then them? Clearly in the modern western world, we seem to define fairness as, whoever can maximize the opportunity the most, shall be given it. Aka, meritocracy. Is this best for our society though? If so, are we doing a good job at it? What if we try to do that, but instead have been giving opportunity to those who most resemble us? Not to those who can most maximise it? What then? Is that unfair?

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by belorn on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @10:42AM (#17716348)
I am strongly against affirmative action and similar techniques since they are almost never applied universal based on anything measurable, but rather political.

For example we had here in Sweden for a short time a program which gave bonus points for university student applications if the student would end being a minority in their class based on gender. The problem was that rather then seeing more women entering male dominated fields, it was more men who applied for seats in female dominated fields and thus ended up gaining the benefit of this program. It was then challenged by feminist groups as being discriminative which they won which then resulted in the program being scraped. A major issue is that on average the higher education here in Sweden in female dominated so any positive discrimination that is intended to countering inherent bias would primarily benefit men, unless those actions are applied explicitly to the minority of programs which is male dominated such as abstract math, IT, engineering and a few more. As such modern affirmative actions programs are much more selective in where it get applied.

Same issue applies to using affirmative action to counter gender segregation in the work sector. Both men and women have the same employment rate here in Sweden, and about 90% of men and women work in a profession which is gender segregated. Neither gender is more likely or less likely to be a minority or majority, which means that affirmative action in the hiring process would apply equally to both men and women. The only way to break the symmetry is to only apply affirmative action in places which the intended group is the minority and thus get the benefit, such as two current political initiative to get more women into sport management and management boards. By limit to only gender segregation in those areas they can be sure that only women will benefit from the initiative and political this seems to be a major success.

If we use data sets and machine learning to counter bias then it would likely work but it would also benefit both men and women. Political this is not acceptable. People claim that positive discrimination is to be used to countering inherent bias but the way it is actually used is all about political power and who can benefit from it.

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by apatters on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:18AM (#17714575)
What if positive discrimination triggers retaliatory bias? Have you really done more good than harm?

Positive discrimination is like bombing a village known to harbor terrorists. Sure, you may kill some terrorists and drive the rest underground. You'll also radicalize a bunch of villagers. Suddenly ideas that used to be relegated to the lunatic fringe are going mainstream.

Sound anything like the US political situation in 2018?

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by intended on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @07:13AM (#17714856)
Nope.

Evidence and facts dont support the retaliatory bias position - retaliatory bias is currently too insignificant a force in comparison to previous systemic or societal biases.

Maybe if we lived in a highly equitable society in the first place, the position would make sense - the forces would be more relatively matched.

Currently, all things being equal - the systemic biases are far more significant and harmful to society as a whole.

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by dandare on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @07:33AM (#17714963)
You talk about a bias and judgment, that may apply to a job interview but how would it apply to written school admission exams?

Judging fairness by maximizing opportunity sounds a lot like the hypothetical counter-utilitarianism argument about harvesting YOU for organs thus saving more lives. Maximizing fairness to society instead of the individual is the basis of ideologies like communism and fascism.

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by p49k on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @08:12AM (#17715200)
> how would it apply to written school admission exams?

There are numerous examples of how written exams are often biased against minorities due to either using cultural references/vocabulary or to frame problems using metaphors that more apply to an average white person than an average non-white person, so there’s that.

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by dandare on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @09:21AM (#17715681)
Can you please link to one of such numerous examples?
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by p49k on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @09:44AM (#17715856)
I'd recommend reading "The Big Test: The Secret History of the American Meritocracy" - it covers the long history of this pervasive issue in the American education system in great detail.
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by hhjinks on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:15AM (#17714232)
University enrollment is a zero sum game, but not everything is. Positive discrimination in a zero sum game will indeed result in negative discrimination, but not by virtue of discrimination being subject to Newton's Third Law.
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by dandare on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @07:41AM (#17715001)
I didn't get the Newton's Third Law part.
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by Chris_Jay on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @07:47AM (#17715034)
There is a school of philosophy that newton's laws of motion apply to the political realm - "any action taken to benefit a minority group will result in an equal and opposite counter-reaction". I wouldn't be terribly far off if I described Sun Zu's "The Art of War" as Newton's laws of motion applied to game theory.
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by tomp on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:00AM (#17714481)
> effect of the negative discrimination on the affected individuals

It's worse than that.

What doctor would you go to, a white man, a black man, or a woman, if you knew that there's affirmative action for blacks/women, and you wanted (and could afford) the best doctor?

Mind you, picking white man isn't even racist, it's rational in the Bayesian framework (the white/male had to have better exam scores to be admitted to the school than blacks/women).

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by Fnoord on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @07:33AM (#17714964)
> What doctor would you go to, a white man, a black man, or a woman, if you knew that there's affirmative action for blacks/women, and you wanted (and could afford) the best doctor?

What is it with this obsession that every requires the best doctor? I don't want the best doctor, I want a good enough doctor who is close to my house location or I will stick to my current doctor because I had good experience with them. Once I stumble upon problems with that doctor I might reevaluate. Sometimes good is good enough, you don't always need the best of the best. My dentist is a woman, and not white. She's great. My doctor is a white male, he is also great. Skin or gender mean nothing to me in this context.

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by cloverich on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @10:14AM (#17716129)
(Not agreeing with OP's strategy whatsoever) -- because the wrong doctor can cost you time, health and your _life_. Particularly with surgeon's, the best surgeon's (and practice's) may have substantially lower complication rates. Its not a small difference.
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by gluelogic on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @09:07AM (#17715562)
> What is it with this obsession that every requires the best doctor?

Being only willing to settle for the absolute best doctor in the world is ridiculous, but it is perfectly rational to want to choose the best one out of a small group of candidates. I can't imagine approaching it any other way when my personal health is on the line.

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by PurpleBoxDragon on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @03:52PM (#17718875)
And most people will optimize for all those factors as well. We aren't saying that you have to pick the doctor with the absolute highest scores, only that there is another factor to rationally consider which shouldn't be there.
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by genericid on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @04:44PM (#17719304)
But how will you find a good enough doctor to begin with?
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by Fnoord on Thursday August 09, 2018 @03:28AM (#17722237)
Well generally, if they're employed they're not terrible else word of mouth (if not lawsuits) would've made them unemployed [1] (Don't have English source). I live in a small country where that works. Also, by talking to them during your intake. When I recently needed oral surgery, the specialist recommend I'd use oxazepam and reassured me it'd work (I have fear for needles). The 2 procedures went great (one was common, one was a tad more complex). You can have a second opinion as well, if you're in doubt. If I'd have cancer I'd go to Antoni van Leeuwenhoek hospital [2]. It has a good name.

[1] https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Medisch_tuchtcollege

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antoni_van_Leeuwenhoekziekenhu...

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by lucideer on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:46AM (#17714710)
> picking white man isn't even racist, it's rational in the Bayesian framework

Only if you assume no inherent counter-bias, which is of course ridiculous. Without affirmative action, blacks/women would have to have equal exam scores coupled with adverse conditions (statistically, on average) to the white/male candidate. By that logic, they would need to perform much better on aggregate.

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by dandare on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @07:40AM (#17714995)
Do you assume the adverse conditions that affect black women (BW) will disappear once they are admitted to the school? If not, then it is still more rational to choose a white man (WM), who performed better in the exams and is not affected by adverse conditions during his study.

Anyway, my original question was about fairness :).

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by lucideer on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @08:05AM (#17715159)
> Do you assume the adverse conditions that affect black women (BW) will disappear once they are admitted to the school?

I guess the hope is that increased participation will slowly reduce the severity of adversity, but whether that is effective I'm less sure of (I don't really believe it will ever disappear completely tbh).

As for it being more rational to choose the person who contends with adversity on the assumption that the adversity never disappears (and therefore continues to impair), this only works on the assumption that affirmative action is a complete, perfect remedy to adversity: otherwise those contending with adversity must still overachieve to a certain degree to get the same positions (and therefore represent a potentially better rational choice).

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by isostatic on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:49AM (#17714734)
I'd go for the black woman, as she had far more adversity to overcome to get into that position and is therefore better (harder working, less likely to have got in via the old boys network)

Of course I wouldn't really, I'm just using your logic.

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by islon on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:54AM (#17714756)
A research done in Brazil (where racial quotas for universities were implemented) showed that students that got in through quotas performed better, on average, than "normal" students. So I guess you are right.
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by gsaga on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @09:27AM (#17715728)
In india the opposite is true. A significant fraction of student admitted through race quota fail and drop out. Now they want to reduce the exam difficulty for them!
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by volkisch on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @07:40AM (#17714997)
Can you cite your sources? Br has been in the whole trend of positive discrimination for a long time and I doubt this study isn't biased as most of their society when it comes to everyone that isn't "white".
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by d0100 on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @05:57PM (#17719862)
Source?
Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by tomp on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @06:58AM (#17714781)
Yeah that's a good point. Nassim Taleb elaborates on a similar one here: https://medium.com/incerto/surgeons-should-notlook-like-surg...

Although technically that's a different effect. Affirmative action is, AFAIK, meant to counter negative bias before (i.e. positive discrimination at university entry is meant to counter worse education and poverty at a primary- and high-school level), whereas you're talking about overcoming biases after graduation ("old boys network" etc).

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by dandare on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @07:45AM (#17715018)
If she did not overcome the adversity after her admission there is no reason to choose her, her outcome as a doctor is still affected by the adversity. If she did overcome the adversity after admission, we must ask what prevented her from overcoming it before admission.

Just philosophizing.

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by lucideer on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @08:17AM (#17715236)
That's an oversimplification, as adversity is not a binary, and is highly qualitative.

However, to take the bait and make an attempt at analysing it:

- (race/gender-based) adversity in education usually has the effect of reducing your chances of succeeding in exams, admissions, etc.

- (race/gender-based) adversity in professional practice usually has the effect of reducing your chances of acquiring customers, partners, progression within an organisation.

So while she may still face after admission, that adversity should have a much more significant affect on her paycheck than on her medical performance.

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by dandare on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @09:20AM (#17715671)
> (race/gender-based) adversity in education usually has the effect of reducing your chances of succeeding in exams, admissions, etc.

How would that work? If we talked about oral exams or job interview then surely there can be a bias. But written exams? I can't imagine how it would be affected by your race.

What can be however affected is your access to quality education prior to the admission, which will affect your admission changes, which should not be an issue after the admission because now you are getting the same quality education as others.

While I can imagine that socio-economic issues (like being black=poor) may affect your access to quality education prior to the admission, I can not imagine how being a woman would affect your access to quality education. Maybe stereotypes in case of STEM?

Re:Tokyo medical school admits changing results to exclude w... by KSteffensen on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @02:33PM (#17718220)
I want to feel safe with my doctor and feeling safe is largely unrelated to grades as long as they are good enough.

Feeling safe is related to rapport with the person which is again related to ethnicity, gender, age, behavior, etc.