News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Xkcd: Airfoil - So what's the right explanation? by hristov on Friday October 08, 2010 @06:31AM (#1771165)
I have seen many examples of this incorrect explanation in textbooks and posters. It boggles the mind how it has survived for so long. I actually shockingly saw the same incorrect explanation in one episode of NOVA (yes it has gone downhill).

The biggest problem with this diagram is that the air leaving the wing is horizontal, which is (a) wrong and (b) really screws up a kid's understanding of Newton's laws. If the diagram correctly showed the air being forced down by the wing, then a kid could figure out that the wing creates a downward force on the air and the air creates an equal and opposite upward force on the wing.

Re:Xkcd: Airfoil - So what's the right explanation? by borism on Friday October 08, 2010 @08:11AM (#1771366)
It seems to me it's you who got things wrong. Explanation about wing forcing air down is very VERY wrong.
Re:Xkcd: Airfoil - So what's the right explanation? by hristov on Friday October 08, 2010 @01:44PM (#1772526)
How so? The wing has to exert a downward force on something if it wants to go up? If not air then what ?
Re:Xkcd: Airfoil - So what's the right explanation? by borism on Friday October 08, 2010 @02:34PM (#1772762)
the lift comes from pressure differential between "top" and "bottom" surface of the wing - that's the definition used by professionals in the field.

Here's why definition about deflection of the air is generally not accepted: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lift_(force)#Criticisms_of_defl...

Re:Xkcd: Airfoil - So what's the right explanation? by hristov on Friday October 08, 2010 @02:49PM (#1772843)
The link you provided does not support what you are saying. The link you provided actually agrees with me saying that the theory about air being deflected down is correct. It merely says that while correct, this explanation is not rigorous enough to do engineering. Which is totally right. But I was not trying to do any engineering, I was trying to provide a simple explanation about how a wing works and how that relates to Newton's third law of motion.
Re:Xkcd: Airfoil - So what's the right explanation? by borism on Friday October 08, 2010 @03:02PM (#1772900)
I'm glad that you found yourself vindicated and will refrain from interfering with your righteousness.
Re:Xkcd: Airfoil - So what's the right explanation? by ajuc on Friday October 08, 2010 @10:04AM (#1771667)
Then how is momentum preserved?