Re:How I gained commit access to Homebrew in 30 minutes
by bburky on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @07:44PM
(#17711955)
Technically `git push --signed` also exists which could fix the issue of rolling back commits. It would verify that the person doing the push also holds the GPG key at least. But as far as I can tell you have to manually do something with it in the post-receive hook and GitHub doesn't support it at all.
If I push a pull-request to master that wasn't approved to be on master (e.g., a maintainer did a build of "disable signature validation to narrow down why tests are failing", and signed that commit and pushed it to a PR with the intention of rejecting the PR), then I also have a valid and completely signed "history", and it probably isn't even a force-push to get it onto master.
Git commit signatures authenticate exactly one thing: that at some point, the holder of this PGP key committed this commit. They say nothing about the suitability or future suitability of that commit to be used for any purpose. They don't solve the problem Homebrew had here, and they cause other problems (like breaking rebases).
Git tag signatures are significantly more useful, since they include the name of the tag. So you're not vulnerable to the second attack, and you're mostly not vulnerable to the first since a client wouldn't intentionally request tag 1.0 after getting tag 1.5. But you still have the problem of the client knowing which tag is current, and frequent tagging isn't a great replacement for a workflow where you want people to follow master.