It's also a case of different concerns cropping off: with paper ballots, there's a risk of miscounting, or disagreement on what constitutes a mark (remember the 2000 election, where the outcome of the election depends on the standards of how much of a mark you need for it to be indicated as a recordable vote). With computer ballots, the concern is over people hacking the tabulating machines or other computerized machinery. You're comparing vastly different risk profiles, and I suspect that most people don't have sufficiently-grounded knowledge to adequately compare them.
https://www.npr.org/2016/10/26/499450796/some-machines-are-f...
I believe that if this site enumerated all the ways that you can maliciously use computerized vs. paper voting systems, we would show a hell of a lot more benefits to a manipulator than a voter.
I think if you bring up Occam's Razor you also need:
1. Somebody gets to make money selling crap to the government
2. Somebody in government thinks it'll mean cost-savings
Given that the current party with federal power is the Republican party, I would argue there is no better time for them to pass as many vote-restriction laws as possible. Vote restrictions typically target the poor and minorities, who typically are Democrat party voters. The wikipedia article I linked is actually a remarkably good overview of the recent history of this issue in the USA.
[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2018/03/28/how-m...
[1] https://www.brennancenter.org/new-voting-restrictions-americ...
[2] https://www.npr.org/2017/03/09/519500312/state-republicans-p...
[3] https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/how-the-...
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_suppression_in_the_Unite...
What do you mean "No"? The ubiquity of cell phones alone makes it self-evident. What YOU mean is not described by your assertion.
> Worse; even if the election was tallied faithfully by a computerized system, a demagogic candidate can whip up fervour and call the election into question.
That's not worse. That's part of the path to acceptance.
> The paper ballot industry doesn't exist.
Tell that to the Lottery machine makers and ticket manufacturers. It's a much stronger lobby than the "e-voting" block (if you can even cobble together such an alliance).
I've ran a paper election for a federal race here in Canada. Anyone with the ability to form a complete sentence could understand the security of our election. We're talking 2 standard deviations below median or worse here.
The number of people that can understand the security of an electronic voting system is vanishingly small. The only security mechanisms that make the election trustable are the ones that are analogous to paper elections:
On premise ballot counts by humans with public observers and physical artifacts retained by receiving officers and other poll workers.
Come tell me how a machine with a touch screen is as understandable to someone that can't even explain how electricity works, much less hashing algorithms or compilers.
> That's not worse. That's part of the path to acceptance.
It is worse that a fair election is distrusted than it is for us to be unsure of the veracity of an election yet proceed as if it were honest despite misgivings. The subversion of truth is an anathema to our democratic process. Our social fabric depends on collective reasoning operating on shared understanding. Minds operate by cohering senses into understanding and understanding into action. Discordancy is doubt's inferior. Under stress it trades quiet, humble investigation for paroxysmal rage.
> Tell that to the Lottery machine makers and ticket manufacturers.
These are not the people that manufactured our paper ballots and they never were.
> if you can even cobble together such an alliance
A lobbyist requires incentive, not alliance.
Having a cellphone != understanding the technology and how it works. People don't get this stuff, and something as fundamental as your civil liberties should not be predicated on a black box no one person can understand.
Re: ballot lobby:
If there's any paper ballot lobby it's HP - when I've voted it was on ballots printed by a traditional office printer/Xerox.
You don't need bizarre forms and crank levers to make a ballot, just a piece of paper and a marking device.
That wasn't the assertion made, nor related directly to the assertion I responded to. Having an understanding of "how it works" is a weak way of couching a ton of assumptions without explaining what you mean. There's no point in trying to argue about what's in your head.
The statement I take issue with is:
> Are computerized elections understandable to laypersons?
Yes. How they work at a cursory level of practical operation and effect, is less sophisticated than any cellphone since flip-phones.
The part that gets me is that there is no organic, grassroots push from the people who actually vote to implement electronic voting.
Usually when someone, or many people, advocate for a cause, they have something to gain from it.
Who is advocating for electronic voting and what do they stand to gain?
The push was rejected since (a) the body responsible for running the elections believes it would be less secure and (b) it would still take two weeks to finalise since postal votes can come in up to two weeks after the election as long as they're postmarked before the election.
But people are interested in fast results. And they're lazy.
> Online voting is a good way to engage with younger voters, busy workers, and even Estonians living abroad, Mr Koitmae says.
Electronic systems have the nominal advantage of handling disabilities and different languages more easily.
Not that I'm disagreeing with you, but why would you expect anything different? As a layperson, why would I treat computerized voting any differently than online shopping or ordering an Uber or something like that?
The software engineering community deserves more blame for this type of thing. It's unreasonable to expect laypeople to be experts on every technology they use, and this crappy voting system didn't exactly write itself.
One of the downsides of programming being easily accessible and easy to get a job in is that there is no required standards body to write code. There's no way to fix this. The best you can do is refuse to hire people that worked on these or similar systems, and I'm sure they will find jobs somewhere within the government-contractor software engineering space.
I guess that's what I was getting at. There never used to be a standards body for civil engineers, either, but after a while society got tired of bridges falling down and buildings collapsing. When will we get to that point with computer software?
It's kind of funny (or sad) that barbers and hair stylists need a license, but software engineers don't.
Since there's an unhealthy obsession with libertarian small government is software circles, it seems relatively unlikely this will happen any time soon. And we would rightly fear for our jobs if this happened, because I can't imagine the regulation applying to imported code.
It goes back to the "hanging chad" election. The losing side decried paper ballots as unreliable in every form and fashion, and the only way to have a fair election was to make it all electronic.
Thus, an industry was born.
Didn't this only happen because of an attempt to elctronic-ify the election and have machines tabulate the results?
FWIW, the place I voted during that election was straight up mechanical.
Two words: "hanging chad."
I.e. why do we need to have machines do something badly that humans can do well?
If you have half the number of elections on two days, you can count all the ballots with half the number of people and still get a result by the end of the night.
[1]: There's a few reasons for this. One is that a lot of people will say "okay, i'll give this person a chance" and even though they voted for the losing candidate, they decide to vote for the president's party in the legislature. Another is that if you ask people who they voted for, more people say the winner than actually voted for the winner. It seems there is some sort of problem of memory reliability here. Since more people believe they voted for the president than actually did, more people will happily support the presidents party than otherwise would have, had the election been synchronised.
We want machines because they are indifferent. We can develop machine based voting systems that have a voter-verifiable receipt. We can reduce the cost of our elections and reduce the number of trusted people that must be involved with them. It removes the most common sources of error from our current flawed implementation of our democratic ideals.
Expanding upon this, if we make voting cheap and easy enough, we may actually be able to expand our democracy for more direct participation at all levels of government and reduce our reliance on the currently flawed implementation of our representative system.
Why would we _not_ want this? The major problem, as I see it, is that states are not assembling expert panels to either purchase or work with other states to collaboratively build a good system directly. The government purchasing process certainly plays a factor here as well, and voting systems should be classified as critical infrastructure to allow a more rational approach to their procurement and/or development.
On top of that, they are opaque: it's very hard to verify that a machine does what it claims to do and nothing else.
If you like machines, I present you a perfect machine: it's a clear box into which you throw paper ballots. It even counts the ballots: invariably, the result is "akira2501 won" - that is written on the outside; it works instantaneously. Any party that finds it suspicious can challenge and recount the paper ballots inside, in presence of independent observers.
Since there's no better way to verify the work of a voting machine other than counting papers, this machine is as good as any machine you just described - and is definitely cheap.
As for the cost - citation needed that machines actually provide any savings here.
The driver is profit motive.
The push for touchscreens was because vendors wanted to juice their valuations (from 3x revenue for services to 7x for products).
The push for postal balloting, internet voting, etc is because now vendors are back to pitching themselves as services companies, the difference this time being the are now charging per registered voter (vs per ballot counted).
Reliability, security, appropriateness are not even part of the conversation.
Paper vote by mail, when the ballot is ready, the print and mail it to you, you have 3-4 weeks to fill it out and send it back. High voter turn out, easy access for people with difficult schedules, No need for transportation. keep the ballots until the election has been certified
But that's a disturbingly cynical outlook, and if the general attitude of the whole populace was as such, there must be something awful at play.
Why? Do we have a history of securing computers and keeping them secure over time? No.
Are computerized elections understandable to laypersons? No. Worse; even if the election was tallied faithfully by a computerized system, a demagogic candidate can whip up fervour and call the election into question.
And without bug bounties there is no legal way for whitehats to pentest these things. We're stuck with shitty scans and guessing at best. Even so, from what I've seen I fail to see why we should trust these votings systems.
But the public doesn't care. They don't understand that code is just data and it can alter itself. The voting machine industry has lobbyists. The paper ballot industry doesn't exist.