News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by replicatorblog on Friday October 08, 2010 @12:29AM (#1770618)
I didn't find the reasoning in this article very sound and the heated "high school angst" quotes hurt its credibility. e.g.

"These products feed and profit from our bovine adoration of mindless time-wasting."

That said, to address her point, I don't understand why tech start ups would be the answer to everything, especially a complex problem like homelessness. Homelessness isn't going to be solved by some RoR hacker creating a website that matches the homeless with available space. Rather it is the challenge for social workers, mental health practitioners, etc.

The same with education, the problem with inner city education isn't technical, its that vast swaths of the population do not respect education. My wife taught in an inner city, had amazing technical resources thanks to grants and well meaning donors, but had parents who were totally checked out.

Furthermore, because some people use tech in a frivolous way doesn't mean there aren't noble uses. e.g.

Foursquare - Learn about resources in my town and places I visit I wouldn't have otherwise. Lets me provide info about areas I know well to those who don't. Makes my consumption choices visible and potentially incites me to make better decisions for the community and my health.

Groupon - Helps support local merchants who have difficult challenges marketing against national chains. Reduces risks for customers to try new things.

Twitter - connects me to people and bodies of knowledge that would otherwise be hard to tap. Lets me connect job seekers with job holders.

Zynga games - Creates a meeting place/activity for friends/family. Sure, at its worst it has "junkie" characteristics, but used sparingly it gives me a way to say hi to a friend and keep a little social bonding going.

Commerce isn't bad and tech isn't the solution to every problem.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by timr on Friday October 08, 2010 @12:56AM (#1770683)
"Homelessness isn't going to be solved by some RoR hacker creating a website that matches the homeless with available space. Rather it is the challenge for social workers, mental health practitioners, etc."

I think you're missing the larger point: when the best and the brightest technological minds are chasing the instant riches of social networks for dogs, they're not creating new antibiotics, energy efficient cars, cheap building materials, or any of a thousand other different things that people with big brains might be doing to better the world.

People who are smart enough to be writing social networks are more than smart enough to be doing pharmaceutical research or inventing solar cookers for the third world. There's just not much of an economic incentive to do it, when it's easier to sell to the vices of the first world.

That said, I realize that I'm a hypocrite on this point: I'm in this wacky social-network-hoo-hah business as much as anyone else. I just wish the economic forces were aligned differently.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by replicatorblog on Friday October 08, 2010 @07:21AM (#1771243)
I work in medical/pharma, an area that some consider "Socially Beneficial". The reality isn't much different than the consumer web. For instance, hundreds of millions of dollars are spent on making small improvements to diabetes monitoring tools. We are talking about chasing minor improvements e.g. reducing test times by 1s. All those resources could be spent researching a cure.

Pharma's actions are dictated by the same financial reporting as tech so even if smart people moved from consumer web to pharma, its not as if we'd end up with a better world. Maybe just one with thinker, more lustrous lashes...http://www.latisse.com/

I guess my take on the "bigger point" is that the market seems to work. We are much better off in almost every area of our lives now compared to 50 years ago. Walmarts goal of keeping their shelves stocked for the "bovine masses" has led to a revolution in logistics. People who invented cellular phones as yuppie status symbols have saved millions of lives through better communication. And a couple guys who made devices to get free calls on pay phones ignited a computing revolution that has reshaped the world in the most grand fashion since Gutenberg.

My larger point is that toys have a way of becoming seriously useful and that socially engineering people to go into "valuable" fields could lead to a glut of mismanaged resources that don't necessarily yield benefits.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by aamar on Friday October 08, 2010 @01:17PM (#1772398)
Great comment. There are probably many, great, socially beneficial things for technical-entrepreneurial people to do in healthcare (a field I worked in for a long time), education, and poverty. But "industry" is the wrong level of analysis for social benefit -- the analysis has to go to specific problems and impact.

Ten years ago, one would very frequently come across essays decrying the alienating nature of the internet, how it dehumanized us and isolated us. They would argue that online relationships are inveterately shallow but displace our fraying real-word relationships with friends and family. But: Twitter, Facebook, Reddit, etc. alongside broadband, wireless, cell-phone cameras, etc. seem to be doing something very meaningful to reverse the (real, though possibly exaggerated) problems those essays described. And by correcting these problems and strengthening the social fabric, we may be indirectly reducing problems in healthcare, education, and poverty.

Again, the problem with the article is not really misprision of social networks, the problem is analyzing social impact at a level where Twitter = Zynga = LinkedIn.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by jeromec on Friday October 08, 2010 @01:37AM (#1770755)
But there are bright minds working on new antibiotics, energy efficient cars, cheaper building materials etc. Some of the best and brightest minds are also smashing atoms in particle accelerators, charting the cosmos, composing symphonies, educating new minds, and, yes, pushing the limits of computer connectedness to make many lives on this planet just that much nicer. There are different ways to contribute to the world. Some leave a more significant mark than others, and in different ways. People do what they are drawn to, and I think that allows them to reach their fullest potential.
Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by timr on Friday October 08, 2010 @02:25AM (#1770834)
"But there are bright minds working on new antibiotics, energy efficient cars, cheaper building materials etc. Some of the best and brightest minds are also smashing atoms in particle accelerators, charting the cosmos, composing symphonies, educating new minds, and, yes, pushing the limits of computer connectedness to make many lives on this planet just that much nicer."

Speaking as one of those people who took a nice little detour from the world of money to live on the edge of technology, let me assure you that it wasn't a smart financial choice. Most of the people who are smashing atoms and charting the cosmos are economic martyrs. Most of the ones who aren't martyrs come from places where an advanced degree at a US school will catapult them into higher social classes. That doesn't really happen in the US anymore -- people think it's more sensible to drop out of college to make websites, and I can't really argue with them.

Irrational or not, my opinion is that the world would be 1000% better if we could somehow create an economy that rewarded young people for doing research into antibiotics half as well as it rewards them for creating social-networking widgets.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by dingy on Friday October 08, 2010 @05:32AM (#1771098)
Most of the people who are smashing atoms and charting the cosmos are economic martyrs.

Baloney. Here in the Netherlands, scientists working at universities and research institutes get a pretty decent salary. Sure, they don't get filthy rich, but fortunately there are more than enough people who don't care about that. The thing is: if getting rich is your primary objective, you're not going to save the world anyway. People working on antibiotics just because it's the best paying job, will leave as soon as another job gets them more money. You can't solve that by fixing the system, because it's not the system that's broken.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by timr on Friday October 08, 2010 @05:48AM (#1771111)
"Baloney. Here in the Netherlands, scientists working at universities and research institutes get a pretty decent salary. Sure, they don't get filthy rich, but fortunately there are more than enough people who don't care about that."

Maybe it's baloney in the Netherlands, but it's not baloney in the states. I do happen to know what a post-doc makes in the Netherlands (I had a job offer there), and it wasn't anything to get excited about (it was about on par with the earning power of a post-doc in a mid-sized city in the US -- which isn't much). But you're right about one thing: nobody is in danger of getting rich.

That said, I believe you're overlooking one incredibly important difference between life in the US and life in the Netherlands: we don't have a robust social welfare system to support us in old age. Taking 10+ years to do a PhD and post-doc in the US eats into your prime earning years, and puts retirement at risk. From this perspective, the "system" is indeed broken; there's a much stronger financial incentive to start saving while you're young.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by dingy on Friday October 08, 2010 @07:33AM (#1771262)
[http://live.uuapplicaties.dwsuu01.dc01.je-itc.com/uuvacature...]

€ 2800 per month is definitely not a bad salary. You're right, I can't speak for the US, but here you can live a comfortable life with that (and if you keep rising through the ranks, you'll have a nice retirement when you're done). And I should probably mention that getting your PhD is a paid job here as well (at least the first four years, in which you're expected to obtain your PhD). Anyone who thinks that is economic martyrdom isn't going to solve poverty, no matter how the system works. You just don't get to be a businessman and a hero at the same time.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by wlievens on Friday October 08, 2010 @08:35AM (#1771423)
If that's a salary, it's a pre-tax number. I don't know the tax code in the Netherlands, but in Belgium that would amount to about EUR 1700 after taxes. That's enough to live a comfortable life, but don't even think about buying a house with that [alone].
Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by dingy on Friday October 08, 2010 @09:12AM (#1771509)
That's enough to live a comfortable life, but don't even think about buying a house with that [alone].

That's my point: it's not economic martyrdom. Sure, it's limiting, but it's not some huge sacrifice that you can't possibly expect people to make.

It just sounds as if TFA is saying "Woe me, I am smart and talented and I want to make the world better, but society expects me to do that for less than what I can make somehwere else." Well, boo hoo. How about you (the writer of TFA) be thankful for being "just" smart and talented and be satisfied with a decent salary? Or else, just quit claiming that you want to save the world.

(Disclaimer: I have a master's degree, not a PhD, and I make considerably less than 2800 pre-tax with a job that requires that master's degree. This is not abnormal. And yes, I live a comfortable life)

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by gaius on Friday October 08, 2010 @06:29AM (#1771161)
It's not about "filthy rich" it's about living a normal, middle-class lifestyle. It takes as long to become a research scientist as it does to become a doctor, dentist, etc. And the pay is not even half.

Then again in the UK anything "technical" doesn't get a lot of respect. Engineers do a bit better than scientists, but nowhere near lawyers or accountants. Science and engineering are not even considered among "the professions". IT is one of the few niches where meritocracy at least prevails, not even there is it guaranteed tho'.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by jeromec on Friday October 08, 2010 @07:19AM (#1771242)
Irrational or not, my opinion is that the world would be 1000% better if we could somehow create an economy that rewarded young people for doing research into antibiotics half as well as it rewards them for creating social-networking widgets.

I agree. It's also a shame that a professional basketball player makes around 100 times more than a professional school teacher. That's just how it is.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by hdctambien on Friday October 08, 2010 @09:27AM (#1771553)
Professional athletes making too much money is not the cause of professional teachers making too little money.

Hundreds of thousands of people are willing to pay $25 - $1000 for a ticket to a basketball game to see those professional basketball players play, which earns them their 100xTeacher salary.

Even more people want to pay less taxes which go to the pay of professional (public) school teachers.

But wouldn't it also be a shame if professional basketball players were being paid $30,000 and the left over billions of dollars were split between the 30 owners of those teams? I'm willing to bet that the rich basketball players give back more dollars to their communities than the even richer basketball team owners do (or even would if they held back that extra money from the players).

People not getting paid for doing something that other people pay for them to do is a shame. Right now, people are not willing to pay for professional (public) teachers to teach. (Some people are able, and do, pay for professional private school teachers to teach.... if they aren't getting paid enough then they are in the same position that an NBA player would be in if their team owners were keeping all the money for themselves.)

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by gaius on Friday October 08, 2010 @09:52AM (#1771621)
Teachers have freely chosen their economic situation. The price of a job for life is that a good teacher's salary will be averaged with their colleagues who are utterly incompetent (who went into teaching knowing full well that once they got their foot in the door they would be untouchable).

If teachers want to improve their lot, they'll disband their unions. A pro athlete can lose his place on the team in a heartbeat...

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by hdctambien on Friday October 08, 2010 @10:56AM (#1771839)
When a specific pro athlete loses his place on a team, he is replaced by another pro athlete that will absorb the money.

While not being able to easily remove (or identify) bad teachers is a problem, the solution to that issue will not increase the pool of money available to pay the remaining good teachers (unless the solution involves removing but not replacing the bad teachers)

A teacher's salary is less "an average of the salary of their colleagues" as it is a division of the money allocated to education from taxes (and fundraisers).

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by maxawaytoolong on Friday October 08, 2010 @07:40AM (#1771278)
People who are smart enough to be writing social networks are more than smart enough to be doing pharmaceutical research or inventing solar cookers for the third world.

This is the lament of the unhappy programmer. If only I didn't have to work my soul-less yuppie job tuning database queries for youface.com I could be curing cancer. It might be therapeutic to think this but it's mostly just a strange form of depressive narcissism. After years in this business I've come to exactly the opposite conclusion. All the people working here are doing exactly what they were meant to do. It's good society has Yahoos and Facebooks in which to employ all these self styled geniuses, because otherwise they'd be fucking up someone else's pharmaceutical research. If only I would have made Facebook I wouldn't have to sit at the crappy desk next to the fume hood.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by timr on Friday October 08, 2010 @11:51AM (#1772051)
"This is the lament of the unhappy programmer. If only I didn't have to work my soul-less yuppie job tuning database queries for youface.com I could be curing cancer. It might be therapeutic to think this but it's mostly just a strange form of depressive narcissism....All the people working here are doing exactly what they were meant to do."

Ah, yes...the world is so much simpler when it's in black and white, isn't it?

Aside from the fact that it's entirely possible to enjoy a career and still see its deficiencies, you're just making assertions and pretending they're factual.

Unless you believe that all of the people who are coding social networks today were absolutely miserable with their careers a decade ago, your typical smart person could be happy doing many different things. Just because they're writing flash games today doesn't mean that's automatically the optimal job for their happiness and the well-being of the world. Capitalism doesn't optimize for what you seem to think it does.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by maxawaytoolong on Friday October 08, 2010 @12:03PM (#1772087)
I'm just stating my opinion. I disagree with your original premise that all these people making Facebook games would (or even could) be solving the world's problems in completely unrelated sectors if market forces were aligned differently. This is the long standing hubris of the programmer, and you see it all the time on blogs and online forums, dating way back to the USENET era. If only I didn't have to do my boring job, I'd be a brain surgeon and a rock star, invent organic gasoline, do angelina jolie and natalie portman at the same time, and maybe even reconcile quantum physics with newtonian mechanics as a side hobby.

This mindset has recently expanded into the popular consciousness, with opinion pieces by every jowly conservatively liberal political columnist, and even stated by the president of the united states, who publicly lamented the fact that all these engineers are engineering themselves more money in the stock market instead of engineering up some new fuel sources. (The messed up part about that, is all those talking heads have degrees in journalism and law. Fuck you and get back to me after you pass freshman physics...) I just don't believe the notion that any somewhat smart person can be successful at anything to be true. People tend to self-select into careers they think they'll be sort of good at. I've worked in both science and e-commerce, and most of the e-commerce people would be bad at science, and most of the scientists would be bad at e-commerce. I just happened to be able to work in both fields because they both need big databases. I honestly don't believe we've lost any great scientists or nobel peace prize winners to Zygna.

The notion that skills are fungible at such a high level is like saying that if only Americans cared about soccer, the members of the Yankees would be winning the world cup instead of wasting their time playing baseball. It's ridiculous.

I don't really get your example, though. A decade ago, the people who are coding social networks today were 12. I don't think they had a lot of financial angst driving them away from their 6th grade research careers.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by JabavuAdams on Friday October 08, 2010 @09:22AM (#1771540)
when the best and the brightest technological minds are chasing the instant riches of social networks

Why do we always assume that techies are "the best and the brightest"? A lot of tech problems are just not that hard.

It's like the finance articles where they assume the best and the brightest are all going into finance. Everyone wants to think their peer group is the smartest.

I started University 3 years early. Okay. There were kids in elementary school who consistently did better on Math contests. They became doctors and lawyers.

If you want to feel dumb (and learn a lot), hang out on some rocketry or other hard-engineering mailing lists. Again, a lot of programming is not that hard. It's easy for a lone wolf to start a project that eventually becomes extremely complex.

This need to prove that we're the smartest kids in the class is juvenile.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by gaius on Friday October 08, 2010 @02:48AM (#1770872)
100% agree. I look around my office sometimes and wonder, what are we doing?! The skill of juggling terabytes of data then slicing and dicing it to order is massively transferrable to almost any problem domain. As is the skill of getting thousands of processors to work together. And we are using for something that is ultimately frivolous.

Like you I am a hypocrite in that I know this and I do what I do anyway. But it's only partly for the money; the other part is there just aren't the jobs to do this out there. A lab or whatever would rather have a grad student hack something up on the side than hire professional developers (and fair play to them, they've discovered a way to get smart people to work for peanuts, but with the best will in the world, someone who got into this to be a biologist is going to see administering a database or whatever as a chore that gets in the way of their real work, and they're not going to do a fraction as well as a professional).

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by stcredzero on Friday October 08, 2010 @03:11AM (#1770911)
someone who got into this to be a biologist is going to see administering a database or whatever as a chore that gets in the way of their real work, and they're not going to do a fraction as well as a professional

What about techies doing pro-bono work. I interviewed with a group associated with the human genome thing, and one of the biologists was bragging about using a stack -- as if that was some sort of hyper-uber-esoteric data structure.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by gaius on Friday October 08, 2010 @03:19AM (#1770923)
Do you remember that recent scandal at the CRU, when people wanted to verify their dubious findings and they'd "lost" the data? Now maybe they did delete it to cover up falsifying their conclusions, I don't know. Or maybe they just didn't have a clue about IT and no-one was paying attention to the backups.
Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by rythie on Friday October 08, 2010 @04:37AM (#1771028)
There are plenty of super bright people who've got their PHDs and are working for organizations doing the above things.

It's just that people don't typically do startups in those areas, because you need massive investment to even get started, let alone succeed. Tesla for example has had $783 million in investment http://www.crunchbase.com/company/tesla-motors

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by jayliew on Friday October 08, 2010 @03:53AM (#1770963)
People who are smart enough to be writing social networks are more than smart enough to be doing pharmaceutical research or inventing solar cookers for the third world

Although I have a CS degree and I absolutely love CS, I did "just ok" in my life science courses and viewed it as necessary evil to graduate. Life science is just not my thing. Just because I can write software doesn't mean I want to be in pharmacy :/

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by prodigal_erik on Friday October 08, 2010 @01:56AM (#1770781)
Economic incentive is how we allocate resources. Expecting big brains to defy what the market currently wants is not only a huge personal sacrifice but it may even prevent them from succeeding. Organizations (mostly governments) that want betterment of the world should be paying the market more to efficiently deliver it.
Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by gaius on Friday October 08, 2010 @05:10AM (#1771074)
Well, yes and no. In theory it sounds like it ought, but look at fusion research: for the last 50 years it's always been 30 years away, which by sheer coincidence is about the length of a post-doc career. And look at the old Soviet Empire or China today: their central planning ought to have made it possible to attract talent to "grand challenge" projects, but it just isn't happening.
Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by Retric on Friday October 08, 2010 @09:59AM (#1771647)
Fast track fusion is about 15 years away. DEMO is supposed to deliver a useful about of net power. Granted ITER has been delayed ~15 years and the best reactor in the world was built in the 80's, but that's more about funding than research.
Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by markkat on Friday October 08, 2010 @10:11AM (#1771686)
Ha! I am in cancer research and am trying to get into this wacky social-network-hoo-hah business. -I guess I am going to hell. :)

Funny thing is, what you are saying has a lot of truth to it. Funding for basic research is low, very competitive, and thus, dominated by nepotism and politics within the scientific community. Although politicians love to say that we need more scientists, as a scientist, I disagree. Until we decide to better fund the scientists we have, please please, no more!

But yes, economic forces, as it were...

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by yayitswei on Friday October 08, 2010 @04:06PM (#1773147)
My girlfriend and I work quite a bit with the homeless and I've noticed that even the most brilliant social work has its limitations. Most homeless people benefit from those social workers, educators, volunteers, etc., but it takes an inordinate amount of energy to reach out to the fringe that seem to lack the motivation to better their own lives.

I think non-profit and for-profit ventures have this in common: they help those that wish to help themselves, help themselves even more.

Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by inafewwords on Friday October 08, 2010 @09:38PM (#1774090)
We'd have a cure for baldness.
Re:Bread and Circuses: The State of Web App Startups by marshallp on Friday October 08, 2010 @01:55AM (#1770780)
Tech is the major part of the solution to every problem.

For example, homelessness can be solved to a large extend by the ROR hacker. For a start, a webapp for the health practitioners, volunteers etc. to better organize would make it all more efficient - let's say by 20%. Webapps that create greater efficiencies in the housing market add another 20%. Add in a webapp to organize homeless advocates to lobby politicians, and you've gone a pretty large way.

Software creators don't realize just how much of an impact they can actually have on the world.