News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Plan to replicate 50 high-impact cancer papers shrinks to... by esrauch on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @03:37AM (#17704518)
I think you too his question too literally: I think he meant "what does it even mean pragmatically and why do you expect funding to go to less novel but more easily reproducible results instead of more novel and harder to reproduce papers?"
Re:Plan to replicate 50 high-impact cancer papers shrinks to... by drb91 on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @11:19AM (#17707382)
Well, reproduced research is inherently more valuable than novel but unsupported research. Otherwise why fund research at all? Just hire alchemists or poets, at least you’ll be entertained.
Re:Plan to replicate 50 high-impact cancer papers shrinks to... by esrauch on Wednesday August 08, 2018 @02:40AM (#17713665)
The current state of research seems to reflect that there is a balance: almost none of the most cited papers go really far out of theirs way to be trivially reproducible, even in computing where doing so is unusually much easier.

If a paper is very novel and impactful but difficult to reproduce, it doesn't seem to matter much for citation counts as long as people just believe it to be true.

And yet there's no revolution among funding sources to send money away from those and instead towards researchers who spend more time on it.

Re:Plan to replicate 50 high-impact cancer papers shrinks to... by thecatspaw on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @05:03AM (#17704883)
funding should go to more reproducible studies because those are the ones that are usefull. What use is a study saying that X will cure cancer Y if noone can reproduce that and verify?