News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by nonbel on Monday August 06, 2018 @11:39AM (#17698560)
"War against" ("War on") seems to mean it is a never-ending boondoggle that, at best, wastes a bunch of resources. Is there any example of these "wars" being a success? The three that come to mind are:

  War on drugs:   fail
  War on cancer:  fail
  War on poverty: fail
Why is the economist trying to link climate change to this?
Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by steego on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:04PM (#17698808)
I can't help but think that picking apart a magazine's headline is a huge distraction from an important issue, but I also can't help myself in pointing out how off the mark you with such a superficial observation.

As far as global poverty is concerned, between 1990-2013 more than a billion people were lifted out of poverty according to the World Bank. I'm sure you can point to local and anecdotal evidence that does not correlate, but to say efforts to reduce poverty have failed are just flat wrong.

Cancer is an intractably complex disease, but to dismiss all efforts and advancements is also off the mark. Life expectancy for many types of cancers has improved significantly. Oncolytic viruses have been shown to treat some very advanced forms of cancer with profound results.

I wish I could be more optimistic about the war on drugs, so I'll concede that one to you.

If you think the branding of the effort is that terrible and counter productive, I'd love to hear your ideas on how we should brand the effort.

Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by nonbel on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:18PM (#17698969)
>"As far as global poverty is concerned, between 1990-2013 more than a billion people were lifted out of poverty according to the World Bank. I'm sure you can point to local and anecdotal evidence that does not correlate, but to say efforts to reduce poverty have failed are just flat wrong."

Those "war on" phrases refer to specific projects in the US. For that one I wasn't too familiar but quickly looked it up and didn't see anyone claiming success: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_on_Poverty

Regarding cancer, I responded here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17698877

Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by steego on Monday August 06, 2018 @06:03PM (#17702174)
> For that one I wasn't too familiar but quickly looked it up and didn't see anyone claiming success: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/War_on_Poverty

Think about it. The "War on Poverty" was Lyndon Johnson's campaign to expand Roosevelt's New Deal. Does that sound like something that would prosper under the Nixon, Reagan, Bush, Clinton (consider the congress), and Bush Jr administrations? Unlike the "War on Drugs", which was actually a never-ending boondoggle that received ample bi-partisan and financial support, Johnson's programs were in the political cross-hairs since day one.

In other words, these two programs were failures for very different reasons. The comparison of the "War on Drugs" to the "War on Poverty" is incredibly superficial insofar as the only real thing they have in common are their names.

Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by nonbel on Monday August 06, 2018 @06:37PM (#17702390)
>"the only real thing they have in common are their names."

They are names for efforts by the US government to achieve some goal that it never achieves. I don't see what difference the detailed reasons for failure are, I am sure there are many.

Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by steego on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @04:03PM (#17710161)
So what you're telling me is the reason for failure really isn't important. The fact that one program was championed for 40-50 years while the other one defunded and dismanteled is of no consequence.

The real takeaway here is they were doomed to failure because the US government chose similar bad names.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by tripplethrendo on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:32PM (#17699109)
A billion people consuming more is surely bad for climate change though, no?

Millions of people pouring into 1st world countries and consuming more is surely bad for climate change.

Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by steego on Monday August 06, 2018 @02:37PM (#17700275)
> A billion people consuming more is surely bad for climate change though, no?

Let me ask you a question: How do you incorporate the concept of efficiency when you talk about wealth? Is wealth and not being impoverished defined by how much you can consume?

I'd argue that the history of technology shows us that we tend to value things that provide more value using fewer resources over a the long term. Most wealth is derived from extracting more value from the same resources and not simple resource consumption.

Let's take light for example. There was an article written by Tim Harford discussed the economic history of producing light and how price per lumen has dropped by a factor of 500,000. https://www.bbc.com/news/business-38650976

Obviously, not all consumables can enjoy those tremendous gains in efficiencies, but there are technologies today whose price/performance is improving at a rate far faster than inflation. That's what we should invest in and accelerate.

In my lifetime, I've watched the cell phone and laptop replace the need to buy dozens of other things, not just in the home, but in the office too. Cheap/viable/comfortable augmented reality will only push this trend further.

A billion people consuming more natural resources, non-renewable resources and carbon emitting resources at the levels we consume them would be bad for our environment.

A billion people having access to cheap/free sources of energy, a quality education, an inexpensive digital infrastructure and devices, and knowing how to use their land efficiently is magnitudes better than a billion people simply living in poverty. Poverty isn't cheap, nor is it good for the environment, especially if it leads to wars destroying wealth and raping natural resources.

My hope is the markets in developing countries will be a huge opportunity for producers of efficient technology, providing those technologies a space where they can incubate until their quality begins to match their less-than-efficient competition. In some circumstances, this is true today.

Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by bmarkovic on Tuesday August 07, 2018 @02:41AM (#17704312)
So you're arguing that the third world doesn't deserve washing machines and clean water, so that you can have one person per SUV in the states?
Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by JamesBarney on Monday August 06, 2018 @01:49PM (#17699875)
The war on poverty is arguably effective. The poverty rate is lower than it would be if we stopped all transfers.
Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by SamUK96 on Monday August 06, 2018 @11:48AM (#17698660)
War on cancer has been...not completely a fail? Certainly made harder by profiteering, but, y'know.

Also, I find "War on poverty" hilarious. Like a country saying it's "making crime illegal".

Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by nonbel on Monday August 06, 2018 @11:51AM (#17698690)
The war on cancer is a total fail in my book. They surrendered when they started calling it "many diseases", meaning there will never be a "cure for cancer" by definition.
Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by jandrese on Monday August 06, 2018 @11:56AM (#17698724)
Huh? You consider it a fail because we learned that there are many different kinds of Cancers? Yes a "one magic pill" option will probably never exist, but we can chip away at all forms of Cancer until they all have a cure.

But realistically, this is not a war I think we can win in my lifetime. It's much bigger than people may have originally thought.

Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by nonbel on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:10PM (#17698877)
Its just an excuse, you are talking about a field with 10% replication rate, and when they tried to start doing more replications it was too expensive to even figure out what generated the data so they had to drop 25% of the studies before even beginning. One guy even calling the literature "augean stables":

https://www.nature.com/news/cancer-reproducibility-project-s...

Every disease can be arbitrarily split or combined into multiple categories. It doesnt mean anything. Here is a cure for cancer:

1) Detect aneuploid cells that fail to show the initial steps of the response to extracellular apoptosis signals, and have been dividing more often than usual for that tissue/environment (eg you have to take into account wound healing, etc).

2) Kill those cells.

This is technological problem, not a "cancer is many diseases" problem. Every problem can manifest in many ways and have multiple solutions.

EDIT:

Ref for "10% replication rate":

>"scientific findings were confirmed in only 6 (11%) cases." https://www.nature.com/articles/483531a

More info in this (short) thread from a few years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10687879

Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by jmcgough on Monday August 06, 2018 @01:17PM (#17699583)
I know a lot of smart people who've devoted their lives to solving this problem. It's very easy for you to dismiss it as easy or say that researchers are incompetent when you haven't spent years working on cancer research in a wet lab.
Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by nonbel on Monday August 06, 2018 @01:37PM (#17699783)
I have worked in a "wet lab" for years, but not cancer research. The first 3 were largely (of course there is always learning going on) a waste because I didn't understand what statistical significance really meant. I can't really blame myself since neither did anyone else in my committee, department, or seemingly the entire area of research. But anyway this meant the whole project was misdesigned from the start (the design was standard).

The next two were spent attempting to save the project by working 18 hour days almost constantly. In the end, despite what they claimed about doing it the usual way because "its so complicated, no one can come up with mathematical/computational models or actual predictions to test, no one can describe this or that in so much detail, etc", the actual truth was that it wasnt "too hard". It was that no one really cared about that. Instead they just wanted to know whether there were statistically significant differences anyway...

From what I've read of the cancer literature it looks exactly the same, probably worse. And guess what, there's been no real progress made for decades on the topic I was studying either.

Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by nonbel on Monday August 06, 2018 @06:26PM (#17702316)
I see now that they had to scale down again to only 36% of the original results:

>"A large effort to reproduce high-impact cancer research has scaled down the number of studies it plans to replicate from 50 to 18, Science reported yesterday (July 31).

[...]

Hurdles to replicating experiments included a lack of detailed protocols and easily obtainable reagents. “Communication and sharing are low-hanging fruit that we can work on to improve,” Elizabeth Iorns, the president of Science Exchange, tells Science." https://www.the-scientist.com/news-opinion/effort-to-reprodu...

Yup, the entire system is set up for an environment of no replication. How do you expect to cure cancer without making reproducibility a priority? I'd expect people who don't do that will end up thinking everything is "so complicated" due to all the conflicting results they generate, eg "one disease" becomes "many diseases".

Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by mohaine on Monday August 06, 2018 @11:58AM (#17698736)
Well, I don't think they just started calling it that for no reason. The fact that they they now know more means they are marking progress, even if it makes it harder to declare victory.

The way I read it is that they were so far from a cure that they didn't even know what they were trying to achieve.

Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by nonbel on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:11PM (#17698888)
Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by heyitsguay on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:01PM (#17698773)
Cancer is many diseases, that all happen to be characterized by uncontrolled cell growth. A "cure for cancer" is like a "cure for fever".
Re:The world is losing the war against climate change by nonbel on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:11PM (#17698884)