News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gear Review: Wahoo Elemnt Bolt by michaelt on Monday August 06, 2018 @07:24AM (#17696710)

  License holders should start setting the standard of
  enforcing the terms of the license they chose.
As I understand things, the prize if you're successful in enforcement is... a copy of the GPL appears in some sub-menu somewhere, and you get a dump of the GPL-derived source code. This dump might not compile, might not be possible to flash onto the device, and might not provide all functions.

I can understand why a philanthropist with the money to pay for such a legal battle might spend it on other things instead.

Re:Gear Review: Wahoo Elemnt Bolt by slededit on Monday August 06, 2018 @10:32AM (#17697888)
In the case of these SoCs the drivers and kernel modifications are kept hidden and under NDA. Ironically these same details are "leaked" in Chinese engineering circles because nobody there will put up with it.

If release of this code was forced smaller companies would be able to make use of these SoCs. It would greatly expand access to cheap computing.

The GPL and derivatives also anticipated people playing tricks wrt to compiling and forces you to release everything needed to build it.

Re:Gear Review: Wahoo Elemnt Bolt by jcelerier on Monday August 06, 2018 @08:10AM (#17696923)
> This dump might not compile, might not be possible to flash onto the device, and might not provide all functions.

no, since there are some LGPLv3 parts they would break the license if there was no easy way to go from their dump to a device with modified code.

Re:Gear Review: Wahoo Elemnt Bolt by stefan_ on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:36PM (#17699155)
Wow, you have to be crazy to just blatantly ignore LGPLv3. Coming into compliance with the kernel style GPL is easy enough, but v3 is a whole other ball game.

If I was Garmin, I'd fund one of the guys they stole from to fund an injunction. Wahoo is a US company, it's easy enough.