Speed of sound in e.g. wood is 10 times faster than in air. So an electric guitar player with 3.4m cord to the amp can feel a latency of 1ms for low frequencies through the stage and his feet. Humans have more rhythmical precision with said low frequencies. Symphonic orchestras are not known for their tight rhythm.
Superior time perception for lower musical pitch explains why bass-ranged instruments lay down musical rhythms
http://www.pnas.org/content/111/28/10383
Re:How Fast Is a PS/2 Keyboard?
by userbinator on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:45PM
(#17699257)
I get that the rhythmic nature of music enables precision at the scale of a few ms because musicians can anticipate these moments in time (reaction time does not apply).
I think it's more like an "equivalent time sampling" effect, and the perceived 1ms latency is actually a perceived phase shift.
What kind of phase shift are you talking about? Humans cannot hear the phase of a single oscillation. Beats produced by two tones with shifted frequency are audible because the resulting amplitude is a function of time. But this is unrelated to timing and rhythm of music.
Re:How Fast Is a PS/2 Keyboard?
by purerandomness on Monday August 06, 2018 @07:53AM
(#17696849)
The speed of sound is a constant, so I'm sure the brain filters it out.
What you can hear are changes in latency which get added to the constant time the signal travels to the brain.
I get that the rhythmic nature of music enables precision at the scale of a few ms because musicians can anticipate these moments in time (reaction time does not apply). But I'm baffled by claims of sensitivity to delays less than about 10ms because these are near or even over the limits of acoustics. For example, when you do the math, you'll see that it is basically impossible for a large enough orchestra to play perfectly in sync. But a good orchestra can give the impression of a precise performance despite that. This can only mean that the human hearing is less precise than what people claim.