Is it normal or even possible for western journalists to let a source/interviewer dictate the final content of an article?
I always assume that journalists can, and should, have freedom to write what they want as long as it’s true and accurate. If I say to a journalist something is “off-limits” I assume it means I’ll end the interview and not engage with them if they cover that topic. Not that I have a right to dictate what’s written in the free press.
I’m honestly asking, I may just be misinformed. Can a source generally put limits on a journalist like this?
> I’m honestly asking, I may just be misinformed. Can a source generally put limits on a journalist like this?
Your impression of the relevant journalistic standard is accurate, but this case has some unusual features that mean evaluation has to go beyond what you point out.
A subject can dictate the terms of an interview, but they don't have say over what the final piece looks like. If journalists made that concession to people they interviewed it would significantly erode the informational value of what they write, so this is a bright line according to journalistic professional ethics (at least in the Anglophone world, which is what I'm familiar with). And this is part of Jeong's defense of Koebler: He wasn't under any obligation to publish an article that Wu would have liked. But.
In this case, the controversial claims about Wu were nonsense motivated by some pretty rank misogyny. In addition, Wu is working in a cultural context where such claims, when publicized, can materially affect her livelihood; worse, the politics of mainland China are such that they can put her in actual danger. (Another part of Jeong's defense of Koebler is that the harm Wu alleges isn't real; there Jeong seems on much weaker ground.)
So it was a terrible judgment call on Vice's part to publish the piece that they did. I actually doubt they had any awareness of the consequences publishing that article could have, but their lack of consideration of that is itself a professional lapse when reporting cross-culturally.
The bottom line is that Vice deserves opprobrium here, but not because they violated an agreement with Wu.
Claims that her husband did her work for her could put her in danger from the Chinese government? I doubt it.
Her livelihood is at more risk from becoming unpopular than being jailed.
I can understand these rumors are embarrassing and she wants to push back against them. Perhaps she feels saying "the government may jail me" as a defense is an effective way to dictate what a journalist writes. It certainly works for China on its population.
But, she's not a dissident discussing Tiananmen Square, and she's not sharing Winnie the Pooh cartoons. She's a highly followed online persona, a 21st century Hollywood star, and is sensitive to anything that could make her look bad. That's much easier to understand than the Chinese government being worried about her marriage or spouse's work.
And I'm sure you're ready to document your years and years of experience with the Chinese government.
And I'm also sure you're ready to document that it's a HUSBAND that Naomi Wu is concerned with.
But ... I won't be holding my breath.
(For reference: her story has already hit Weibo with people calling for her to be arrested. Thought I'd mention that.)
> She's a highly followed online persona...
Highly-followed on WESTERN (and BANNED IN CHINA!) social media you utter berk! That ALONE is grounds for her to be nervous of being noticed.
And talking about things that are conspiracy things on reddit.. yea not very uh.. high integrity? Not to mention they said that it was fine that these things would be off topic.
In my view it’s unreasonable to expect them not to mention them. Unless you have an agreement that they will not be included in the final article. Not just vague wording about them being “off-limits” which I would assume would mean that we wouldn’t discuss them.
Let's restate what the allegations were here.. for others who might not know. Essentially the allegations were that someone like Naomi couldn't possibly be a skilled maker and that she must have someone else making her creations. Nothing more than internet hearsay. Especially when she's willing to do maker stuff in front of anyone who's willing to show up.
I don't think I've ever seen someone say "That guy surely didn't make that, his wife must have"
While I completely agree with the context of your remark, there have been people who suggested that the original author of theory of relativity was in fact Einstein's wife Mileva Maric.
However, if reporters want continued access to interesting sources then they should respect their wishes - particularly when it's for safety reasons. Anything less is scummy
Not possible, but when journalists court the source, they often make promises they know they'd never deliver on (not that they are unique in this, aren't they?) They may promise to leave certain things off-the-record, or omit certain parts, and then decide - or have higher-ups decide, or make it look like higher-ups decided, whatever - that this is too juicy and click-worthy material to hide it, and violate all promises. It is very rare for any negative consequences besides source being pissed off to come from it, and the source is already used up, so who cares?
> Can a source generally put limits on a journalist like this?
Essentially, no, but journalists often make it look like they can.
> Yeah but if you look at my track record, no one that did it to me is going to dare do it to the next girl...that's what counts. That's why you do it, I "lose" every time- reputation takes a real hit. Important to be likable and sweet as a vlogger. But they think twice next time
https://twitter.com/RealSexyCyborg/status/102622332283131494...
She knows she's not going to come out of this ahead. She's doing this on principle to protect the next person they try to bully. Respect.