Re:I made my own WireGuard VPN server
by tptacek on Monday August 06, 2018 @03:36AM
(#17695790)
This isn't an answer to the question I asked, it's just huffing.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:I made my own WireGuard VPN server
by tialaramex on Monday August 06, 2018 @07:18AM
(#17696678)
You didn't ask a question. You did ask me to "help you" see into the future and I informed you that my crystal ball is cloudy.
That's a weird way to say "ok, I was wrong about it being possible to recapitulate DROWN using WireGuard v1 and any hypothetical WireGuard v2".
Re:I made my own WireGuard VPN server
by tialaramex on Monday August 06, 2018 @12:11PM
(#17698886)
An ability to recognise that "I don't know a successful attack" isn't the same as "it's impossible to attack" is why I don't share your (as yet unjustified) confidence in zero agility. It's a microcosm of this thread.
I'm sorry, but you're being slippery, and I'm not going to pretend that's a valid argument. It is not my claim that nobody will find vulnerabilities in WireGuard. I hope they do! Generalizing and weaponizing crypto exploits is something I work on professionally and I'm a cheerleader for team breaker.
My claim is that a cross-protocol attack like DROWN will not work on WireGuard, and I explained why.
Rather than acknowledge that explanation, you either (a) rattle off irrelevant details or (b) retreat to abstractions. But there's no abstraction to retreat to. DROWN isn't an unknowable attack. You can just read the paper to see how it works. After you do that, I suggest you read the WireGuard white paper, which is short and straightforward (the cryptographic details make up only about a third of it). You've said several things on this thread that lead me to believe you haven't yet read it, and I think you'll find it enlightening.