Wu told VICE that for the interview, all questions regarding relationship, etc. are off limits.
VICE went ahead and made it a topic. Wu refused to answer. In the article, VICE retold the 4chan claims, making Wu's refusal to answer a new nugget for the 4chaners to claim her guilty.
Jeong offhandedly dismissed Wu's troubles and acted as expert on the issue purely on being of Asian descent, which has nothing to do with living in PRC.
Jeong, who is unjustly the target of another ridiculous and purely vile 4chan harassment campaign, decided to not stand up for Wu, when she was the target. Instead she dismissed her struggle and sided with the white male VICE editor.
I'm assuming this is about more than them claiming her boyfriend builds her projects, any insight you can shed ?
The campaign against Jeong is some bs about old tweets where she mimicked the racism she gets back, recast as racism against white people.
Wu and all her followers would happily stand with Jeong against this bs (the same racist and sexist garbage Wu has to fight) - if she wouldn't have sided with the attackers when the same thing happened to Wu.
Having read all of Sarah Jeong’s tweets as they pertain to this controversy, I find it hard to believe that many were intended as satire. She has a clear pattern of unprompted tweets that make sweeping negative generalizations about white people, particularly old white men. I’m white, and I don’t like being singled out and put down on the basis of my skin color. It is alienating, it is dehumanizing, and it provokes an immediate instinctual (and generally unproductive) defensive emotional reaction.
I don’t buy the excuse of, “they started it.” Sarah’s obviously faced tons of online harassment, but since when have two wrongs ever made a right? The Golden Rule doesn’t say, “Treat others as you would like to be treated, except white people.” I would expect better from someone in Sarah’s position.
Having said that, a few racially-bigoted tweets don’t justify a 4chan harassment campaign. I also understand how it becomes difficult to discuss such an issue when an online hate mob is so clearly invested in one side of it.
Spot on. Once you start excusing things with "they started it", you're no longer on a slippery slope, you're in free fall (and her tweets make is seem like she's enjoying the ride).
This I saw just recently, my opinon here differ from yours though, had these been direct responses to racist comments then I would have found the explanation plausible, but they're not, and coupled with the sheer volume of them I can't see them as anything but her racist opinions.
As for 4chan 'campaigns', does this site has any sway whatsoever ? Back when I went there ages ago it seemed like anonymous people was just trying to be edgy and do 'shitposting'. I thought reddit was 'the place' these days ?
I just learned that VICE had her patron taken down and her Youtube channel demonetized due to her doxxing someone at VICE as a direct result of this article (which is not an excuse for doxxing, but something that would not have happened had not VICE ignored their agreement).
VOX does a better job at summarising than I could: https://www.vox.com/2018/8/3/17644704/sarah-jeong-new-york-t...
I am not part of any 'online mob', nor am I misogynist or alt-right.
...but the linked article, and the NYT's statement, already said as much in rather easy-to-understand terms. Which makes me suspect that their further explanation of "bad faith" might also be relevant here.
This argument makes no sense, I have not written misogynist statements at all, let alone a whole twitter feed full of them.
>but the linked article, and the NYT's statement, already said as much in rather easy-to-understand terms.
I found the excuse in the statement unplausible, these were not responses to any hostile tweets, at best they were racist comments made for shits and giggles rather than being her actual views.
The alt-right was on the verge of defusing the "racist" accusation as an effective weapon in the culture wars.
The NYT's Sarah Jeong stunt effortlessly made alt-right types literally crawl over each other to be first to accuse the NYT of "racism", in the process affirming the supreme moral severity of the accusation to themselves.
Very smart play on the part of the NYT.
I dont think anyone would care had she been transparent.
Not quite, she wrote that she asked a woman from the PRC (but I think now living in America).
Still, not much better.
If someone says that X is important and to please not do it, and you do X anyway, that's crappy behavior.
edit: found a Twitter thread on Chinese political dynamics. It looks like you can be arrested for simply being a vocal feminist: https://twitter.com/jackiehluo/status/982087205907607552
Yikes.
"so now we're back at the vice article. apart from the sexism/racism, what would have been so bad about rebutting the conspiracy theory that she's the "face" of a white man who's really responsible for everything she does?"
"i can think of a few potential issues that could tip the scales when it comes to safety concerns. for one, rebutting the conspiracy theory and framing it as a feminist issue may require or imply a more overtly political stance on feminism, which we've seen can be dangerous."
I was confused by the timeline. My impression is that Vice emailed her wanting to ask about the personal accusations. Wu saw this as breaking the agreement and went public before the article was published. The mention of her relationship in the subsequently published article refers only to this dispute between Wu and Vice, and AFAIK it’s not mentioned elsewhere in the article.
It still seems like she said, I don't want to discuss X, Vice said, let's discuss X anyway. Even though that happened prior to publishing the piece, the meta-discussion of X shouldn't have made it into the final piece. If someone says a topic is off-limits, and you continue bring it up anyway, that's kinda douchey. I'm not going to defend attacking Vice on Twitter before the article got published, but the final product is definitely still douchey.
I don't quite buy that. The subject of an article can dictate the terms of an interview (in this case, what subjects they're willing to discuss), but it's not part of journalistic practice to allow a subject to dictate what goes into the article itself. A journalist who allows themselves to bound that way isn't doing something in principle different than PR for their subjects.
And Koebler never agreed to keep the 4chan/reddit rumors out of the piece. He agreed not to ask Wu about it in their interview, and he broke the spirit of that agreement if not its letter by only bringing the topic up in a subsequent email exchange instead of the interview itself, so he doesn't come out of this looking great. But he wasn't under an obligation to avoid writing about the controversy (which I think is pretty clearly ginned up nonsense) in the final article.
It should be when such information can have serious repercussions for the subject of the article, and these facts are mentioned and agreed upon before the interview takes place. It's ridiculous to hide behind journalistic standards to justify unethical behavior.
Motherboard and Vice as a whole have in the past published stories that I'm directly or tangentially involved in and gotten the facts completely backwards on multiple occasions. Always in a way that tells a more sensational story.
I wouldn't be involved with that publication -- full stop.
They've even doubled down on the Sugar Weasel story 5 years later, after it being pointed out to them repeatedly that it was factually incorrect.
She asked them not to mention it, and they still did. Putting her at risk for no good reasons.
[1] https://twitter.com/jackiehluo/status/982087205907607552
The CCP will act, like the recent temp SSH ban, when it feels it has to/has gone out of control.
The author suggests that Vice misled her in early talks, gathered information about her that should've been off limits for the story but shared it anyway despite her pleas for them not to. My first read of this was that she's gay and was concerned how that would look to a Chinese audience and Vice exploited that for attention.
I skimmed the Vice article too - https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/3kjqdb/naomi-wu-s... and that didn't really seem to be it. I have to confess I couldn't understand what she objected to in the Vice article. However, as the author writes about the Vice editors, I'm not in any position to understand what is or isn't concerning to share for a Chinese woman with a large social media following living in China.
Without really understanding what the disagreement is I have to withhold my judgment. However, if I'm ever in a position where Vice would want to interview me I'd probably turn them down after reading this purely out of caution.
The complaint about Sarah Jeong seems a bit more clear - Jeong dismissed the author's concerns claiming to be able to evaluate them fairly because they were both Asian women. Jeong's perspective though is as an ethnic Korean who has lived in the US pretty much her entire life (moved to the US at age 3) which is clearly a very different perspective than the author who is a Chinese citizen.
Given what else we know about Jeong I don't think it's that surprising that she's insensitive about race.