News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by TaupeRanger on Sunday August 05, 2018 @05:05PM (#17693523)
It's not that exciting and it's very easy to beat humans at games when your reaction times are far faster and you have access to more information at a single moment in time. It's like being impressed by a calculator.
Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by pedrosorio on Sunday August 05, 2018 @05:17PM (#17693575)
"We’ve increased the reaction time of OpenAI Five from 80ms to 200ms. This reaction time is much closer to human level, though we haven’t seen evidence of changes in gameplay as OpenAI Five’s strength comes more from teamwork and coordination than reflexes."
Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by minimaxir on Sunday August 05, 2018 @05:29PM (#17693639)
Notably a lot of the clutch plays in Game #1 by OpenAI were due to very well timed skills.
Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by Arxiss on Sunday August 05, 2018 @06:14PM (#17693846)
Dota 2 player here, they "timed" it well because human players were in the vision. Humans can also do that by precasting a spell.
Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by hackandtrip on Sunday August 05, 2018 @05:20PM (#17693593)
Reaction times are limited to 200ms; it's all about the meta and the group tactics, and bot are apparently really good at it.
Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by skgoa on Monday August 06, 2018 @04:34AM (#17695986)
The bots have perfect information (when the enemy is in vision) and perfect micromanagement through the API. A huge part of the challenge in dota is processing the viuals and audio cues from the game quickly and acting the limited information you have precisely. The bots get to take a shortcut around all of that.
Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by eerikkivistik on Sunday August 05, 2018 @05:14PM (#17693564)
Well yes and no. Sure, micro is a large part of Dota, but planning and coordination is worth as much. So reaction time gives you an advantage in one spectrum, but I think the real benchmark will be macro scale planning and coordination. Same applies to the Starcraft AI competition, where the bots still lose due to macro planning.
Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by kenning on Sunday August 05, 2018 @05:15PM (#17693568)
dota 2 is not as extreme about this as, say, starcraft. in starcraft, most "strategies" are heavily scripted build orders that almost never deviate from a handful of openings (similar to opening moves in chess) and a large amount of winning comes from the ability to quickly give orders to your troops ("micro"). This is an example of a strategy that is not viable without superhuman reactions: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IKVFZ28ybQs if you directly attack 20 siege tanks with 100 zerglings you will only kill about two siege tanks, but an AI can kill all the siege tanks with some zerglings left over.

There's some of this in dota, but there's a cap on the skill level for most playable characters that pros generally get "close enough" to, and beyond that the strategic depth comes from area control decisionmaking. Theres over 100 heroes and many of them have really weird abilities, like the possibility of creating a temporary wall (earthshaker) or the ability to teleport anywhere on the map every 20 seconds (furion). I could be wrong though, maybe the AI is winning games by playing heroes with long range and perfectly microing them to harass and prevent the other team from ever getting gold/xp.

Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by halflings on Sunday August 05, 2018 @05:40PM (#17693697)
> in starcraft, most "strategies" are heavily scripted build orders that almost never deviate from a handful of openings (similar to opening moves in chess) and a large amount of winning comes from the ability to quickly give orders to your troops ("micro")

As somebody who plays StarCraft casually (gold/low plat in ladder), this is not true. It's even less true for pro players. The level of strategy in StarCraft is impressive, it's really hard to guess in which direction games will go when two very good players are playing against each other.

Sure, perfect execution when it comes to one strategy (say, mech-heavy Terran) will give you the largest advantage against your opponent, but failing to scout appropriately and guess what your opponent is up to means your strategy is dead. You also have to decide when to attack, how much you're willing to sacrifice to damage somebody's economy, when you want to focus one economy vs building units, ...

The video you sent with zerglings is a gimmick made for fun (it's a hard-coded AI using the siege tank's aim logic to divert zerglings from that). That would not win you a game. (because most likely a pro Terran would have destroyed your base before that)

Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by fizx on Sunday August 05, 2018 @09:43PM (#17694617)
I wonder how far you'd get with a bot that macros perfectly but also A-moves 2-3 groups.
Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by halflings on Monday August 06, 2018 @03:50AM (#17695842)
What does "macro perfectly" mean? If it does the same strategy over and over, you just scout, find its strategy, and go for the counter. Its macro will be useless if it has the wrong type of unit.

In a way, the built-in AIs "macro perfectly", but they are terrible at strategy and fighting (because even fights are not just a matter of gimmicks, you need to split units in a special way, send diversions, attack at the same time from multiple fronts, etc.)

Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by eerikkivistik on Sunday August 05, 2018 @05:16PM (#17693572)
I think we made the same point at the same time :D
Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by pixelbash on Sunday August 05, 2018 @05:17PM (#17693574)
What information do they have access to?

I do think a simulated reaction time or limited actions per second might be more fair, if they don’t have that already..

Re:OpenAI bots competing against Humans right now by dx87 on Sunday August 05, 2018 @05:34PM (#17693665)
They have an artificial restriction of 200ms for their reaction time, and their actions per second is similar to human players. The main information the bots have that players don't is exact coordinates of everything they can see, and the amount of damage attacks and spells do. The bots know with 100 percent certainty that a spell or attack is in range before they use it, whereas the human players would have to base it off visuals, or press another button to bring up their spell's range indicators. Having the damage of attacks memorized allows the bots to know if an incoming projectile will kill them, that allows them to not waste healing resources if they know they'll survive. The bots also move based on coordinates, so misclicking and mouse travel time aren't an issue for them.