I think music and journalists (designers being grouped with journalists) are vastly different situations because of copyright law, yes. The law allowed a huge industry to grow around information asymmetry, hype, and price inflation. Journalism and graphic design seek (and work) very hard to produce things of value far greater than bloggers/crowdsource usually aspire to.
That said, blogging/crowdsource have and will continue to put a great deal of pressure on those performing at the highest levels in those fields. It's simply my hope that the top performers there will justify themselves while producing perhaps a new era of relevant work. Increased competition doesn't always involve complete steamrolling, just evolution.
(In fact, one evolution I could see happening is a design firm outsourcing some percentage of their own mock work to crowdsource sites. Prototypes are about instantiating the field of possibilities so you can learn about them and talk about them. I wouldn't be surprised if it doesn't hurt them too much to not personally generate each and every one. The real value thus becomes their professional finishing touches, the market research, etc.)
I don't think it's surprising that many people dislike the idea.
I don't think it's surprising that that one person dislikes the idea.
Crowdsourcing doesn't give many people an 'opportunity' to try something new - it provides the client with cheap design.
There's a very clear motivation behind providing design in this way, and the designer is always going to lose out.
I bought a design on 99designs. Had a great experience with the designer, who I recommended to my friends, and now she is getting loads of work.
I'd say that's truly meritocratic <- a good thing.
Why would you think a novice on the web with Photoshop will automatically do better than a professional with experience and who is looking beyond making a cool design?
Logos aren't just pieces of art — they also brand a company. Crowdsourcing will never match a professional brand designer.
I sincerely hope that the entire Internet is being trolled by The Gap on this one, given that the alternative is entirely depressing.
Either that or this logo is legit, meant to last, will work on consumers, and in turn will reduce designer's hourly rates around the world. :)
The rhetoric involved is an extension of the line "I can't pay you for this, but you could use it in your portfolio".
The whole process reeks of exploitation. It's bullshit, imo.
The problem is, so many people are still put in a situation where they end up with no payment.
I'd still like to know where the remaining participants will gain exposure.
* Top2 get paid directly
* Top5 get points to be ranked in a monthly leaderboard, they'll eventually get paid depending on their ranking in that leaderboard.
* Winning/ranking good will help you get a position in a review board to review other submissions and then get paid.
* You still can participate in bugraces, which generally doesn't take too much time (hours or even minutes) and get paid accordingly.
This is just a small portion of how you can make money. Granted, it is not easy, but if you're good, well, you are good.
Gain exposure? Working with big clients, AOL, ferguson, lendingTree, and a lot more - Plus, If you have a job interview, you still can get a recommendation from TopCoder with a list of your winnings/projects (it's visible in your profile anyway)
I'm speaking from experience here, It's so wrong on many levels to put all crowd sourcing websites in the same basket.
You have 99 people enter a crowdsourcing 'contest'. One design gets picked - and that person is paid.
98 people have worked on the project for nothing; which wouldn't be the case if the winner was hired in the first place.
I'm sorry, but they should just suck it up and change. Like the world around them is.
PS: I don't remember the last time that people rewarded me or anybody else just for trying. Perhaps kindergarten, but I have no clear recollections of the daily scrums in there.
I'm suggesting that the model put forth by crowdsourcing is ill-thought out and unfair.
"[..] they should just suck it up and change. Like the world around them is."
I completely disagree. People who exploit others for their own personal gain should always be challenged.
Or are you suggesting gap crowdsourced their identity requirements .. ?
Well, I suppose this is a reasonable strategy.
CP+B have done similar things, and tried to explore how crowdsourcing can create buzz (e.g. with Brammo) .. I think at one stage they even decided to ebay the services of their designers to create a sense of the agency's openness to 'new'.
It does seem that aesthetics aren't the main driver behind branding decisions any more. It's impossible to stand out by having the nicest looking identity.
Taking an approach like this makes sense on lots of levels, especially when marketing budgets have been reduced; create a couple of reasonably strong memes, which last long enough to seep into the public consciousness before they die .. and gain phenomenal exposure without spending too much. Gap get to create the hallowed 'relationship' with the customer by involving them their own brand 'journey'.
I did make myself slightly sick after reading back over that last sentence, but to an extent I think it's true. We all build up relationships with brands over time, and the course these relationships take can be manipulated.
For a comparison, check out this post from an old/ex-pro cover band rocker. Title of the thread was "Who is responsible for bands making peanuts?"
http://acapella.harmony-central.com/showpost.php?p=40701817&...
Crowdsourcing isn't democratising design - it's reducing the importance of good design .. in much the same way that bad acting increases our tolerance for poor quality soap operas.
Good design is clear thinking, made visual. Good design solves problems and it follows conventions which take time to understand.
The problem with gap is they went away from who they are and they're trying to sell an untrue story. Using a minimalist font like American Apparel as an attempt to be "hip" is clearly bullshit to everyone. But again it has nothing to do with the tool, rather its about the concept and thought behind the graphic and that is where Gap has slipped.
i've got a venture-backed business opportunity. we're looking for a strong application developer, and have heard good things about you, but not sure you can take on this task. we'll send along the technical and functional requirements, and it looks pretty easy. it shouldn't take more than a week of your time. after you sign our nda, we'll take a look at the application you built. if it's good, we'll pay you around a thousand dollars, maybe up to $10k.
unfortunately, we're not looking for any more founders, and don't need any support beyond the first production release. this will be a one time engagement, and we'll part ways after.
sound fair?
(read: how spec work would translate to the developer world. to me, it doesn't seem fair or reasonable -- especially if you're looking for a professional deliverable.)
People play the lottery - but I wouldn't argue it's in their best interests to do so.
And, as far as I can tell, the purpose of a logo is to provide a unique and memorable identity to the business/brand. Gap's PR/Social strategy here has reinforced their identity in ways that a professional re-redesign never could.
Gap's brand was tired, and quickly becoming forgotten after its late 90s peak... Suddenly people are talking about Gap again. You might view their response as innovative, manipulative, or your run-of-the-mill corporate spin, but there's no denying that it is a gracious response. And grand acts of public graciousness tend to reinforce rather positive feelings for a brand.
With internet and social media, companies can interact with designers much more effectively and fewer designers are needed to do the same amount of work.
So the supply side from designers is high, while the demand side is low. So the consumers can pay arbitrarily low rates. Once the not so good designers and designers who do other things just as well (high opportunity cost) move to other streams. The supply side would start having a higher say.
This seems like classic game theory. While it's in the design industry's collective best interest to never work on spec like this, it might be in an individual designer's best interest to design Gap's logo for free. And even if it's not, if most of them think it is, you've still lost. Believe me, I understand that Gap's move here is a slap in the face, but many designers out there will do it anyway, just for the chance to say they designed Gap's logo.