Knowing how GIT works uder the hood is less important than staying in the flow, at least for me as a developer. People responsible for repository maintenance may have other priorities.
That sounds like limiting the functionality of the whole computer to what the text editor can do. That doesn't make sense. Next, you'll want to browse the web from the editor because you don't want to leave it (just because emacs does it doesn't mean it isn't absurd).
Anyway, I think it's better to configure the system so using multiple programs is as quick and effortless as possible. For your example, I use i3, a tiling window manager, and have the screen split with a terminal window on the left and my editor on the right. If I wanted to check `git status`, I just type `<super+h>git s<enter>`. To go back to the editor, `<super+l>`. There's really not much difference with a single character shortcut.
Well, you're clearly replying to an emacs user. He/she will not find that statement the least hyperbolic.
And there are middle ground people like me who want editor integration when it makes me more efficient (like invoking frequent VC commands right from the editor), but I do mail and browsing and stuff with external tools.
Not really. It's about putting the most frequent features into your editor, so they can be accessed effortlessly. If you have to do something which is less frequent and the editor does not support it then you still have the terminal.
> If I wanted to check `git status`, I just type `<super+h>git s<enter>`. To go back to the editor, `<super+l>`. There's really not much difference with a single character shortcut.
It's efficient compared to switching to the terminal with alt-tab or something, though by single shortcut I meant that you can use it right in your editor buffer, so it's really just pressing one or two keys vs. `<super+h>git s<enter>`
Version control functions should be available right in your editor (e.g. magit) and you can't really beat one character hotkeys for version control stuff. It doesn't get more convenient than that.