Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful
by dojor on Saturday August 04, 2018 @05:57PM
(#17688598)
Not that much human progress honestly. Most of the people who push the progress ball forward, do so not just because of access to information. They need to be in the right labs, receiving the right training, surrounded by the right mentors etc.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful
by TheSpiceIsLife on Saturday August 04, 2018 @06:32PM
(#17688748)
I suspect your being downvoted because labs, training, and mentors are knowledge.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful
by projektir on Saturday August 04, 2018 @07:05PM
(#17688864)
To be fair, they're not equivalent knowledge. Labs often imply equipment that cannot be gotten by normal means. Training and mentors know which knowledge is important, and sometimes possess knowledge that is hard to find because it's too specific and/or deep.
Research papers are a more obvious problem that is also easier to fix, but labs is nonetheless also a problem. Especially in fields where physical experiments are required, such as biology and chemistry, it's really hard to get anywhere without a lab, and running your own may be prohibitive and at times even illegal.
Re:Sci-Hub Proves That Piracy Can Be Dangerously Useful
by akqu on Saturday August 04, 2018 @07:18PM
(#17688903)
I do think you have a good point. What I have been telling people who wants to learn things for a few years now is to make sure they have a pipeline to test their ideas. To many people are perpetually learning, tinkering and building fantasies in their head without having the opportunity to make something out of it. I would say "to each their own" if it wasn't for the fact that it usually becomes sort of destructive. So while I do support more generous access to information it is also important that it doesn't just become "window shopping".