News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by gruez on Friday August 03, 2018 @10:36AM (#17680187)
We wouldn't be having this discussion if cookies were opt-in rather than opt-out. I don't sign into 90% of websites I visit, but why are all of them allowed to track me? If cookies were opt-in, then the legal issue of "consent" would be cleanly resolved, and the interface can be handled by the user agent rather than through obtrusive modals.
Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by krapp on Friday August 03, 2018 @11:00AM (#17680409)
The problem is, the purpose of cookies isn't tracking, they're a hack to maintain state between requests for what's supposed to be a stateless protocol (and until HTML5 came along with session storage and local storage, they were the only way to do that in the browser.) So cookies are useful (and often used) for purposes besides tracking and advertising.

Having cookies be opt-in by default would just punish anyone using cookies for benign purposes.

Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by rkeene2 on Friday August 03, 2018 @11:34AM (#17680708)
Cookies were never the only way to do this. Before cookies became popular having the ability to create a session was still possible. The primary method of doing this was similar to cookies, have a sessionId parameter to your query. There were also passive ways of profiling a user's client to isolate it based on what it looked like (IP, User Agent, user agent Accept and Accept Charset, etc see [0]).

[0] http://www.rkeene.org/viewer/tmp/wwwftp_cgi.c.htm#line182

Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by Bartweiss on Friday August 03, 2018 @11:06AM (#17680465)
I'd be interested to know what percentage of sites would actually lose functionality.

At a crude estimate, >90% of the sites that show me cookie warnings do everything I actually want them to statelessly. And I have some backup for that, because when I block cookies by default very few sites actually seem to get worse.

Are there clever user-aiding tricks with cookies that I don't realize I'm losing? Or is the average site with cookies purely for tracking and advertising?

(This is all a separate question from "should cookies be blocked by default"; I know a few uses really do suffer badly.)

Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by davidcbc on Friday August 03, 2018 @11:13AM (#17680539)
Pretty much any site with a login is using cookies to do it
Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by Bartweiss on Friday August 03, 2018 @02:35PM (#17682372)
True, and logins (along with browser games) leap to mind as the most widespread issue with general cookie-blocking.

But I probably sign into <5% of sites I visit, and even many of those are actively user-hostile, like Quora. I understand why Quora wants me to sign in, but from my end of things it's no more worthwhile than being asked to sign into Wikipedia just to read articles.

Broadly, I guess this is a gripe about how my web-use experience has become fundamentally adversarial. Cookies are one of many perfectly reasonable features which I cripple or disable even on respectable top-100 sites because they're used almost exclusively against my interests, but I'm not sure there's a good tech-level fix to that for users in general.

Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by PeterisP on Friday August 03, 2018 @11:36AM (#17680724)
Sure, but I do not log in to the vast majority of the websites that I visit, and cookies aren't required for them to function properly unless I choose ('opt in') to log in.
Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by kikoreis on Friday August 03, 2018 @11:16AM (#17680562)
Sure but to create a login there is a transaction of consent.
Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by finaliteration on Friday August 03, 2018 @11:30AM (#17680664)
Exactly. No one -has- to add a cookie that tracks you across sites they don’t even own. They can easily be used for authentication and session management without scraping a bunch of personal information from every visitor, logged in or not
Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by iKevinShah on Friday August 03, 2018 @11:34AM (#17680710)
Just to add to this, if you disable cookies, localStorage also goes so not only cookies, any site using storage would also be impacted.
Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by closeparen on Friday August 03, 2018 @12:10PM (#17681006)
Cookies rely on the cooperation of the user-agent. From the website's perspective, they are opt-in.
Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by SyneRyder on Friday August 03, 2018 @10:52AM (#17680330)
You can already do this. In Firefox:

* Go to your Cookies And Site Data preferences

* Select "Block Cookies And Site Data"

* Click on "Exceptions"

* Add the address of the website you opt-into

* Click "Allow For Session" or "Allow" as you choose.

Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by sib on Friday August 03, 2018 @10:55AM (#17680361)
You visited them and you didn't turn off your browser's cookie requests; therefore you decided to accept the files that the site offer to your browser.
Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by ballenf on Friday August 03, 2018 @11:30AM (#17680663)
You make a fair point -- it's popular to take the same tack with web servers and ad blocking (a server makes content publicly available -- users can decide which parts to view). Not a stretch to apply the same logic both ways -- just because a server offers a file to you, doesn't mean you are forced to store and give the file back on demand.

If this view were more widely adopted, it would maybe pressure browser vendors into being more transparent with users on cookie management and proactively ask them how they want to handle them.

Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by z_open on Friday August 03, 2018 @04:14PM (#17683240)
Cookies are opt-in. Install umatrix and be done with it.
Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by iKevinShah on Friday August 03, 2018 @11:33AM (#17680697)
As a workaround, we can disable them on the whole and enable on per site basis (the 10% of websites you sign into). Its a hassle but yeah ...
Re:Cookie policy notifications have ruined user experience o... by gruez on Friday August 03, 2018 @02:53PM (#17682557)
that's sort of what I do with cookie auto-delete, which keeps cookies until you close the tab. otherwise some sites dont play nice when you disable cookies entirely.