Having cookies be opt-in by default would just punish anyone using cookies for benign purposes.
[0] http://www.rkeene.org/viewer/tmp/wwwftp_cgi.c.htm#line182
At a crude estimate, >90% of the sites that show me cookie warnings do everything I actually want them to statelessly. And I have some backup for that, because when I block cookies by default very few sites actually seem to get worse.
Are there clever user-aiding tricks with cookies that I don't realize I'm losing? Or is the average site with cookies purely for tracking and advertising?
(This is all a separate question from "should cookies be blocked by default"; I know a few uses really do suffer badly.)
But I probably sign into <5% of sites I visit, and even many of those are actively user-hostile, like Quora. I understand why Quora wants me to sign in, but from my end of things it's no more worthwhile than being asked to sign into Wikipedia just to read articles.
Broadly, I guess this is a gripe about how my web-use experience has become fundamentally adversarial. Cookies are one of many perfectly reasonable features which I cripple or disable even on respectable top-100 sites because they're used almost exclusively against my interests, but I'm not sure there's a good tech-level fix to that for users in general.
* Go to your Cookies And Site Data preferences
* Select "Block Cookies And Site Data"
* Click on "Exceptions"
* Add the address of the website you opt-into
* Click "Allow For Session" or "Allow" as you choose.
If this view were more widely adopted, it would maybe pressure browser vendors into being more transparent with users on cookie management and proactively ask them how they want to handle them.