Gradients are tacky in print because they were expensive to execute on paper. ("Tacky" here used to mean counter to the Modernist dogma of purity, precision, truth, and generally "going with the grain" of a medium that dominated a large part of the late 20th century. YMMV.)
On a screen, gradients are not only beautiful, but useful in creating the perky faux-physics that have come to dominate almost all of consumer UI design. Part of this may be rooted in the measurable "effectiveness" of illusionistic UIs, but I have the sense that it's also about wanting desktop computers to be a cute little robots.
Also: grade.tumblr.com
Gradients are occasionally beautiful, when subtle, but the sooner the whole "perky faux-physics" dies (especially the tiresome "everything has a glass bubble" look) the better.
How accepted are gradients among designers?
Asking because I am starting to hate some aspects of modern web design. Today I had this thought that maybe I just don't like it if a web site design lies to me. That is, a web site is a flat thing, it shouldn't pretend to be 3d with fake shadows and stuff like that.
I see the need for making buttons clickable ("afford pushing " was the term one design book used, I think).