Re:Angst Swells as Australian Population Nears 25M
by e12e on Friday August 03, 2018 @11:13AM
(#17680535)
Indeed, reminds me of this lecture series:
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL76483D7434812A0D
At some point there's a (not entirely) rethorical question about what's a "good" growth rate for a town, and a politician indicate 5% is good. 1.05^15 ~ 2. So that's a doubling in the period between someone enters kindergarten and leaves high school.
Re:Angst Swells as Australian Population Nears 25M
by ulfw on Friday August 03, 2018 @06:33AM
(#17678682)
What a really odd logic.
So then let's bring immigration down to 0%. Woohoo!
Now you still got to "replace 2% of infrastructure every year" with 0% more revenue. How's that working out for you?
You argue 0 immigration -> 2% infra costs You argue 1% immigration -> 3% infra costs but also 1% more revenue to use for infra costs
I fail to see your issue
The basic problem is that if infrastructure last 50 years, you have to replace 2% of it every year. Now, for every 1% of population growth, you also have to (on average) also build 1% more infrastructure, so you need to build 3% in total, or 50% more than if you had no population growth. But you only have 1% more revenue to build it with, so inevitably only a fraction of what you need gets built, hence the problems. And the higher the population growth, the worse the problems.