News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by davidw on Thursday October 07, 2010 @07:11AM (#1767458)
> Yes, they've given back nothing in return to the people that have created Java. What did Sun get out of Android? Nothing. Maybe some royalties would have been enough to keep it afloat.

Life's a bitch. Just because you create some product, does not create an obligation for the world to pay you lots of money. Especially programming languages. Most guys who create languages don't really get rich from them.

> The protection was in place EXACTLY so that other corporations couldn't get away with what Google has done.

The "protection" in this case concerns three things:

* Trademark: the Java name. Perhaps they have some kind of case there, but that's not what Oracle is suing over.

* Copyrights: sorry, but Google took nothing from Sun as far as I can tell. They did not use Sun code. No case.

* Patents: ah, software patents. This form of "protection" inhibits anyone from going out, and through their own hard work, creating an implementation that resembles the original. I don't much care for that idea really - because the real work is in the implementation.

> going out of their way to avoid paying Sun anything

Boo hoo. That's their own business if they want to go out of their way to avoid paying someone, as long as that "going out of their own way" was done legally, which it seems likely it was. As a business, the world does not owe you anything. Perhaps if Sun had done a better job with Java ME, they wouldn't have been in this quandary in the first place.

Are you angry at the Apache Software Foundation too, for creating the free code used in the class library?

There are no comments on this comment yet.