News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by dotancohen on Thursday August 02, 2018 @06:31AM (#17670435)
I've done A/B/C testing to see how likely someone is to install Telegram when they get surprised that I don't have Whatsapp. Those to whom I explain in a straight-faced manner that Whatsapp is intrusive, almost never install it. Those to whom I whine that I don't like the intrusiveness are very likely to install it. The third group, to whom I whine that I just don't like Whatsapp, are also likely to install it.

In short, don't give someone a reason to do something. Just whine.

Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by throwawaymath on Thursday August 02, 2018 @09:11AM (#17671119)
I found this to be the case when I was telling people I’d like to communicate via Signal. For the most part my explanation of why was not compelling for them, so I compromised and use Signal for a subset of friends and iMessage for everyone else.

My experience does not bring me to the same conclusion as the article or your comment. I don’t think it’s about whining or an emotional appeal. Rather, I think it’s a matter of not giving the other party anything to argue with. If I enumerate the many reasons which have convinced me to not use Whatsapp, the other person has a lot of...”rhetorical surface” with which to attack. They may or may not be successful, but they can probably launch a decently cogent rebuttal.

On the other hand if I simply say, “I don’t like it”, and follow up with, “I don’t know, I just don’t”, there isn’t enough substance with which to find a logical flaw. Your friends might judge you for it but, in my experience, it won’t stick out enough in their memory for them to really focus on it one way or the other. They are sort of forced to concede because your reasons are inscrutable. Disengaging can be its own form of victory, because it forces a draw (so to speak).

Obviously that isn‘t persuasive; it’s defensive. Likewise, I used to compete in Speech & Debate tournaments at the national level. In that context you have to engage, by design. My team (and rivaling teams) had a philosophy that we’d impart to all new recruits: when you’re formulating your point, deliver it forthrightly and concisely. Support your position with the minimum that will suffice and provide further support as needed, to parry the rhetorical attacks you encounter. This gives your opponent less material to refute, which means each individual point you deliver is harder to detract. When you’re trying to persuade someone (especially if you have an audience) a reasonable point delivered confidently, and with one or two strong reasons or citations, is far more privileged than many “passing” reasons which can made the focus of a rebuttal.

Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by lx3459683 on Thursday August 02, 2018 @07:28AM (#17670654)
On a related note, I noticed that it's a bit socially looked down upon to be privacy conscious. This is pretty much a 180 from what the public perception was 20 years ago.
Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by Ntrails on Thursday August 02, 2018 @07:49AM (#17670741)
Everyone is fine with you being privacy conscious to some degree. It's when you start telling them that they should be too that it tends to get a negative response.

I'd argue that this is why the GP succeeds in their B/C tests - because they made it about their own choices. In A it's trying to convince the other party of a position on privacy instead which is, unsurprisingly, a lot harder

Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by maze-le on Thursday August 02, 2018 @07:39AM (#17670701)
>> I noticed that it's a bit socially looked down upon to be privacy conscious

Where I live, the exact opposite seems true. If you are an ardent user of social media, you are more likeley than not to be under a bit of scrutiny.

Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by darpa_escapee on Thursday August 02, 2018 @10:16AM (#17671522)
I've found this is entirely dependent on your audience's biases.

An appeal with facts, reasonable viewpoints and what not is effective if your audience is already heavily biased towards your viewpoint.

Appeals based on emotion and whining are likely to be called out by an audience that's inherently skeptical or believes very specific ideals surrounding the nature of discussion (the "debate to reach a higher truth, not to win" crowd).

Unfortunately, I've found what you said to be true with audiences who remain on the fence or don't really care about whatever issue is at hand.

Many posters here fall into the camp to whom discussion is an attempt to reach the truth so they fail to see the rhetorical forest for the trees.

That's not to say we don't have our blind-spots when it comes to emotional appeals, however. That's just human nature.

Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by magic_beans on Thursday August 02, 2018 @07:38AM (#17670695)
Is whining not something we all learn in childhood, but the great majority of us grow out of?
Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by pbhjpbhj on Thursday August 02, 2018 @08:12AM (#17670835)
By "grow out of" do you mean "adapt to be more subtle and insidious".
Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by magic_beans on Friday August 03, 2018 @06:16AM (#17678618)
Perhaps, yes :)
Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by lawnchair_larry on Thursday August 02, 2018 @09:48AM (#17671315)
But if you care about privacy, using telegram is far worse. Use Signal.
Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by tempodox on Thursday August 02, 2018 @07:03AM (#17670554)
That recipe may only work with a specific target audience. I know a few grown-ups who are highly allergic to whining. With them, you'll achieve the opposite effect.
Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by Theodores on Thursday August 02, 2018 @07:47AM (#17670735)
Some but not all of them might just do it to appease/shut up the whining one. So there is still a higher conversion rate from taking the whining approach.

So why don't we all whine?

This I have asked of shouting. Normally I politely ask people to do things with a friendly tone of voice. However there have been moments, e.g. on-coming car catastrophe, where I have shouted at people and been surprised at how quickly people move or do as they are told. Shocked at being heard and being 'obeyed' I have wondered why I don't do it more often. I dismiss the idea as it is not me and contradicts many aspects of my upbringing. But you can see how it is that some people get what they want in the world by shouting/whining or being a general narcissist.

Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by darpa_escapee on Thursday August 02, 2018 @10:26AM (#17671606)
I believe that's because we reserve shouting as a signal during dire situations. It's kind of like the color red, where we give it an inherent dangerous meaning naturally, but see it enough everyday and your heart will no longer instinctually flutter when exposed to it.

Having lived with a person who is hearing impaired, the effects of shouting on reflexive action will dissipate after the first week.

Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by bena on Thursday August 02, 2018 @09:02AM (#17671066)
I think it just triggers something in us. Both whining and shouting. They suggest some form of distress and that waffling may not be a good idea. Just like we're kind of hard-wired to think babies are cute.
Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by magic_beans on Thursday August 02, 2018 @07:39AM (#17670700)
Allergic to.
Re:To Persuade Someone, Look Emotional by tempodox on Thursday August 02, 2018 @07:46AM (#17670730)
Thanks, fixed.