News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by bad_user on Thursday October 07, 2010 @01:43AM (#1766952)

     Dalvik only links to those libraries and linking is explicitly allowed by the 
     Apache license agreement, and does not constitute a 'derivative work.' But 
     that only applies to those parts of Harmony which were created by 
     Apache.
Harmony is a clean-room implementation of Java. No parts from Java SE were copied, so licensing terms of Java SE don't apply. There could be licensing terms for Harmony, but that's for the usage of the "Java" trademark, but AFAIK Sun hasn't provided a TCK to Harmony yet.

You also can't copyright API interfaces, so the point that Dalvik works with classes named "java" and "javax" doesn't really hold.

Also note that this lawsuit is about patents + unidentified copyright violations (on which Oracle just got bitch-slapped because they haven't identified them, as required by law), it is not about a breach of license / contract.

EDIT

And you know, Android applications are first developed and compiled using Sun's JDK. Only after that a compiler translates JVM bytecode to Dalvik. THAT's WHAT COMPILERS DO.

Are you going to suggest that compilers are illegal now?

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by cletus on Thursday October 07, 2010 @06:54AM (#1767427)
Sun provided a patent license to OpenJDK/Harmony. That's important. Whether or not any code was used affects copyright violations, not patent issues.

Copy someone's code and you violate copyright.

Two people can independently come up with the exact same algorithm, one of them patents it and the other is in violation. That's just how crazy the patent system is.

Sun's license to OpenJDK was contingent on that JDK not being modified. Oracle's argument is that Google has violated that license so is outside the royalty-free patent license for the OpenJDK, which I hate to admit, is actually a reasonable argument.

That'll be enough to get a trial if Oracle wants one. When I first heard about the lawsuit I considered it an incompetent shakedown to justify the purchase price for Sun. I say "incompetent" because they picked the wrong target thinking Google of all companies would simply roll over and cut Oracle into the Android action.

I hate to admit that because I think Oracle's actions are shortsighted and, well, moronic as Google has done more to further the Java platform than anyone (including Sun) and I'm opposed to software patents anyway.

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by bad_user on Thursday October 07, 2010 @07:46AM (#1767505)
The patent grant doesn't extend to Harmony because it hasn't passed the TCK (because it contains a fields of use restriction).

You also can't violate a license, if you haven't agreed to one in the first place. This is also important!

Violating a license is different than unknowingly infringing on a patent.

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by cletus on Thursday October 07, 2010 @10:31AM (#1767935)
> You also can't violate a license, if you haven't agreed to one in the first place.

Perhaps I chose a misleading word by saying "violating" as it implies only the problems for license holders. The nature of patents however is that if someone has a patent affecting your software you are potentially in violation if you either don't have a license or you do have a license and are in violation of it (which tends to devolve into a contractual dispute).

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by anigbrowl on Thursday October 07, 2010 @03:36AM (#1767124)
My reading (which like I say, could be wrong) is that Google would like to shift it away from being a breach of license but as written, the SCSL terminates if the Java technology is ported to a different platform without the TCK protocol being satisfied. I think Oracle's answer to the question of what bits of Android violate Sun copyright will be 'all of it.'

I suggest rereading the SCSL, and consider why Harmony couldn't legally proceed without a TCK.

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by mzl on Thursday October 07, 2010 @04:21AM (#1767189)
Remember, copyright-issues by definition do not apply to clean-room implementations. For there to be a breach of copyright, one has to show that the copyrightable material (i.e., the source code) actually derives from the corresponding copyrightable material that Oracle owns. If it truly is a clean-room implementation, then the engineers responsible must never have looked at the original source code, making the claim moot.

Patents are a whole different ball-game though.