Why should investing upwards of a million dollars or more in a taxi medallion be treated differently than any other large investment with real risks involved? So when were profits from these medallions those were private but now that there's risk it should be socialized?
I realize a reply to this can be that bail outs lead to increased risk taking. I would still argue that it's better to risk the system and help those who can not recover from this kind of loss.
There have been 3 restaurants on my block that have opened and failed inn the last 18 months. Shouldn't we help them too by your logic? Should the city council pass legislation?
>"But should the result of it be their lives ruined because "you lost the game, screw you"?
Yeah that's a false equivalence. Empathy and bailouts are not the same things at all. I can have empathy and be against a bailout and that doesn't amount to me saying "screw you" to anyone.
If the restaurant industry collapsed next year I'd say the same thing for them too. But there is a qualitative difference between ad hoc business failures and a systematic change.
But I agree that bailouts != empathy. Still, bailouts aren't the only option, and as a society it is in our interest to help a sector when it goes under. It may happen to you or me next.
EDIT: I should specify that I'm speaking about owner-operated cabs.
The "industry" is not failing. There are still 13,586 yellow taxis on the streets in NYC[1] picking up and dropping off fares. And there no shortage of New Yorkers on the street raising their right hand and intently scanning for the "on duty" lights of yellow cars.
The "industry" is not the valuation of metal medallions bolted to the hood of the cars. You seem to be conflating the too.
Or how about "when about 18% of taxi drivers nest egg devaluates and their retirement evaporates..."
To claim there is no difference between a restaurant failing and all independent taxi cab drivers in NYC simultaneously taking a giant hit that they did not see coming based on an (admittedly bad) policy of protectionism, is intentionally missing the point and I would say is intellectually dishonest.
Is a bailout the best way to fix this? I have no idea, seems like a relatively low cost way to fix what the city did but these things are complicated. I'm open to that discussion.
Are failure rates of the restaurant industry totally incomparable to this singular situation? Most definitely, and any argument based on this is flawed IMO.
You seem to be missing a bit of history.
It sounds like you are unaware that the original call for regulation of the taxi industry was by the taxi drivers themselves. Yes, the passage of the Haas act in 1937. During the Depression there were far more drivers than there was demand for taxis. This resulted an abundance of "wildcat" cab drivers who were threatening the livelihood of legitimate taxi drivers.[1][2]
>"Now that the market collapsed it's the moral thing to do not only to liberalize the medallion restrictions but repay those who were hurt the most."
Lastly the overwhelming majority of medallions are leased out as part of "fleets." The people that have been "hurt" the most have been the drivers who are required to lease the cab for a 12 hour shift for $130 and are also responsible for paying the insurance and gas on top of it. This is basically a feudal system where medallion owners are lords and the actual taxi driver is a serf.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/1996/05/11/nyregion/medallion-limits...
[2] http://www.nyc.gov/html/media/totweb/taxioftomorrow_history_...
Where was that promise codified?
Perhaps do just a modicum of research before making such false and uninformed assertions:
http://www.nyc.gov/html/media/totweb/taxioftomorrow_history_...
FHA and student loans allowed mortgages and higher education to be accessible to more people. This is not the same thing as propping up the value of my degree and my home's valuation in the market place after I have acquired them. The Middle Class in the US was built by former(and other New Deal policies) not the latter.
Coincidence?
There leverage in the student loan market is much lower for the time being.
Their actions are so transparently market friction and corruption.
I'm tired of the majority career politicians who have no knowledge of reality other than 'sound good' politics.
Companies would be able to build more housing and pay more in wages if they didn't have to grease the government's palms to do anything.
They need to go. All of them.
Bring back empiricism
This is such an upsetting characterization of the situation.
The city government sold a bunch of medallions to investors/"speculators" (depending on your politics). Those medallions declined in value. Who should bear that loss?
The entire situation was created by a government monopoly that never needed to exist in the first place. Now that someone's figured out how to go around it, all the investors in the manufactured, useless regulation are losing their shirts.
It's really hard to feel bad for these guys. They were willing participants in a system designed to line their pockets by fleecing ordinary people, choking supply to ensure their prices were kept artificially high. They're basically the OPEC of transportation. Do we feel bad because electric cars are disrupting OPEC?
Lyft and Uber really aren't the bad guys here, at all.