The difference is that AdGuard works like a watered down little snitcher — letting you control specific network connections that your phone makes. And the filtering works within and without Safari.
I use it for monitoring the servers that various apps reach out to. Unlike Charles Proxy AdGuard does not allow any insight into contents.
It’s sad how far backward things have gone that we aren’t allowed even that modicum of control of a device we purportedly own. (Absent use of homemade VPN proxy or pi hole.)
This about face for Apple is the first time I’ve seriously considered going to back to Android. Google’s walled garden is much more porous, but it’s really a fool’s errand to look for a smartphone that treats its user with any respect.
> [...] it is advertised nowhere that it can [use a VPN profile or root certificate]
Seems to be the issue isn't "blocking ads" but "you can't do it in $THIS way" with Apple misunderstanding that the app doesn't do $THIS, it actually does $THAT (using NEPacketTunnelProvider.)
Apples policy may be burdensome and unwelcome, but I'm not sure a product called "Adguard Pro" can't be said to advertise ad blocking functionality...