Re:How to tell the difference between persuasion and manipul...
by hyperpape on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @09:24PM
(#17668574)
This is only true if you assume that System 2 is always better. But if someone has rationalized great cruelty, it is perfectly appropriate to appeal to their emotions if it will get them to stop (this is essentially equivalent to a point the author of the original piece makes).
Re:How to tell the difference between persuasion and manipul...
by AstralStorm on Thursday August 02, 2018 @03:55AM
(#17669900)
Rationalizing is very different from actually making a rational decision, and is part of System 1 thinking.
Post hoc, ergo propter hoc.
A rational decision starts with defining the epistemic system in which it is made. Is it bayesian, frequentist, higher order fuzzy logic? How the weighting, if any, works? What is the data/proposition acquisition algorithm? Which heuristics are to be used to simplify decision and why?
Re:How to tell the difference between persuasion and manipul...
by hyperpape on Thursday August 02, 2018 @08:24AM
(#17670897)
Rationalization can mean rationalizing a system 1 decision. It can also just mean justifying a bad decision using explicit reasons, which is the sense in which I mean it.
Re:How to tell the difference between persuasion and manipul...
by RangerScience on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @06:13PM
(#17667560)
Good point! I'd adjust it a bit tho - I'd say that that's one way to manipulate, but not all of them. In my [uneducated on this topic] opinion.
It's not a perfect distinction (there probably are cases where appealing to System 2 might look a lot like manipulation), but it's succinct, ends-neutral and not too subjective to be useful in practice.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_process_theory#Dual-proce...