Re:Show HN: BountyGraph: Crowdfunded Bug Bounties and Securi...
by Thriptic on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @02:36PM
(#17665545)
> One problem with this is that the corporate users who would fund a bounty competitive with the grey market don't really care about the grey market.
Mind elaborating?
> Your demo page shows a funding goal of $50,000... for BountyGraph. Not 1 HackerOne program in 10 is funded even to the tune of $20k, and those people all run actual businesses.
Sure, but in this case you're not relying on one business to fund the whole bounty; theoretically many businesses would be pooling funds. If hundreds of companies pledge small amounts, you are looking at real money being made available.
Re:Show HN: BountyGraph: Crowdfunded Bug Bounties and Securi...
by tptacek on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @03:25PM
(#17666067)
I feel like I did elaborate on the grey market point but if you have more specific questions I'm happy to take a whack at them.
A big reason businesses don't put huge amounts of money into H1 bounties is that the median H1 bounty payout is probably somewhere in the vicinity of $100.
Another issue is that for the vast majority of applications, the bounty pools you seem to be considering are way, way too big. The $3000 Google & friends will pay you through the IBB for serverside bugs is mostly a gift from them. You should read things like the Zerodium payouts as "we might pay AS MUCH AS...", and also know that when they say they'll pay "up to" $10k for RCE on Roundcube, they mean literally: RCE, and has to be Roundcube. They won't pay you for XSS and they won't pay you for an RCE in something _like_ Roundcube.
Your demo page shows a funding goal of $50,000... for BountyGraph. Not 1 HackerOne program in 10 is funded even to the tune of $20k, and those people all run actual businesses.