You make a very good point. I really wasn't looking at it from the perspective of money, but rather the adventure and challenge. (It's probably a coping mechanism, because if I looked at my startup as trying to make zillions I would be constantly depressed.)
Working at a normal company, doing a more or less normal job is more along the bell curve - you can make pretty good money as a top software guy somewhere, but (options aside), you're never going to get that lucky break and make zillions. On the other hand, you might well make more than the startup guy, if he spends a year working on his own thing, 'for free', and then fails.
(See: The Black Swan)