News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by swombat on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @03:38PM (#1765519)
Alternative explanation:

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1765420

"Violet Blue is an adult site".

Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by kaerast on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @05:47PM (#1765992)
Yes, and that's the reason given for this domain name being reclaimed. Drinking alcohol and women showing bare arms are both illegal under Sharia law, and the front page showed Violet Blue drinking beer and showing bare arms. It's difficult for many foreigners to know exactly what is and isn't legal under Sharia law, so it's difficult to know if a domain would be ok or not.

However nic.ly are now also warning they don't allow ownership of short .ly domains by foreigners, only Libyan nationals. This sounds to me like they want more money or an excuse to take down domains they simply don't like, but is a real problem if they ever decided they want in on the bit.ly action.

The vb.ly site owners keep claiming that the content may be adult but that the domain name isn't. This is a weak argument in my mind, and I believe there's a precedent of domain names registered exclusively for the act of malware propagation being taken down.

Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by jonhendry on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @05:56PM (#1766025)
Sharia law doesn't necessarily enter into it.

You can't sell dildos and vibrators in Texas, and it's not because of Sharia law.

Hindu activists in India made death threats and stormed theaters because of a film about a lesbian relationship.

Sharia law is not the only reason for repressive attitudes toward sex.

I mean, really. They're, what, 30-40 years behind the cultural norms of the US, in this case? You don't really need to pin that on Sharia, when it's far more likely that it's just cultural.

It wasn't that long ago in the US that nothing was open on Sundays.

Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by alanh on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @07:27PM (#1766267)
> You don't really need to pin that on Sharia, when it's far more likely that it's just cultural. (emph. added)

Because cultural reasons are completely separate from religion? Religion is the only reason people like to tell others what they can and can’t do in private, especially in a democracy like Texas, where it shouldn’t be considered Constitutional to outlaw "dildos and vibrators."

Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by jonhendry on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @09:09PM (#1766480)
A agree, but there's a tendency among some these days to tout the boogeyman of sharia law. And there's an implication that there's something alien about Libya, that being restrictive of sexual matter is somehow unique to sharia law, that without sharia law Libya would be just like the US, and that Christians wouldn't do anything similar.

Which is just nonsense. Conservatives are conservative. Libya did this thing, and John Ashcroft covered up a statue's tit.

Bringing sharia into it is just buying into the latest thing pants-wetting wingnuts are using to scare themselves.

Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by alanh on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @09:12PM (#1766485)
Maybe I’m foolish, but I think that denying the involvement of sharia law buys us nothing, but recognizing similarities with other conservative censorship tendencies (e.g. in Christendom) — as you have — can be a enlightening.
Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by jacquesm on Friday October 08, 2010 @12:37PM (#1772221)
> They're, what, 30-40 years behind the cultural norms of the US, in this case?

And the us is another 10 to 20 years behind some other parts of the world in this respect.

Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by quant18 on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @10:32PM (#1766639)
More relevantly than Sharia, here's the actual text of Libya's anti-pornography/prostitution law (in Arabic), Law No. 56 of 1970 "On the Protection of Public Morals": http://www.aladel.gov.ly/main/modules/sections/item.php?item...

Nothing in there about the Intertubes, of course, and it's quite vague about exactly what constitutes pornography, but basically, you need a license from the Ministry of the Interior or the Ministry of Local Government, and if you violate it they can throw you in jail for three to six years and fine you.

Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by dotBen on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @06:54PM (#1766185)
"Violet Blue is an adult site".

Well 'Violet Blue' is my girlfriend, she's not a website :P

Do you mean "vb.ly"? It certainly was not an adult site - it was a url shortener. Have you not seen the grabs of the site floating around in media?

Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by 1va on Thursday October 07, 2010 @02:20PM (#1768851)
> Well 'Violet Blue' is my girlfriend,

I guess that may have been a little predictable from TFA, but I'm regularly surprised by the folks who crop up at HN. I've been reading both your and VB's work for years, it is a funny coincidence to discover there is an relationship between you.

Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by swombat on Thursday October 07, 2010 @01:40AM (#1766948)
Well, your girlfriend is obviously an adult! Case closed! ;-)

More seriously, she does seem to be rather, er, focused on the topic of sex... Which is great, but I can see why they would object, if sex-related things are banned in Lybia.

Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by dotBen on Thursday October 07, 2010 @02:44AM (#1767053)
(lol, yes she is an adult!)

to your main point: Well that's kind the issue isn't it? Yes Violet is 'focused on the topic of sex' she's a leading author in the field (30+ books on Amazon), appears on Oprah show about the topic, lectures at universities, etc.

But if you are right, isn't that too far if a domain authority removes someone's domain because the line of work and academic research they are in? Like I said, the site itself was hardly adult, even if Violet's own life, work and research is against their laws (somehow, perhaps).

Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by rms on Thursday October 07, 2010 @08:05AM (#1767537)
>even if Violet's own life, work and research is against their laws (somehow, perhaps).

Under crazy interpretations of Sharia law, Violet probably would have been stoned by now.

Re:The .ly domain space to be considered unsafe by semanticist on Thursday October 07, 2010 @06:29AM (#1767390)
It would definitely be too far in the UK or the US. Apparently it's not in Libya.

A screenshot I saw of the main vb.ly page had a picture with enough flesh that it itself was probably illegal under Libya law.