Re:Bail reform could give justice to poor, minorities
by dragonwriter on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @01:14PM
(#17654990)
> For example, without the threat of forfeiture how do you ensure people actually show up to court?
You do it the way Washington D.C. does, and has for a couple decades.
> Without bail bondsmen how do you fund the extra police/marshals/sheriffs to find and arrest those who do not show up for court?
With general taxes, rather than taxes on the criminally accused.
> Without the ability to set bond amounts based upon offense characteristics and individual financial circumstances and criminal history, how do you prevent especially violent offenders with a likelihood of committing more violent acts while on pretrial release from committing new violent offenses?
Money bail doesn't prevent that; pretrial supervision or outright bail denial can, and so that's how you do it, choosing the least invasive level of supervision that provides adequate security in the circumstances.
> If you want to go the other direction and eliminate money bail, do you really want to police/prosecution to able to indefinitely incarcerate people until trial?
Before trial isn't indefinitely except at the choice of the accused, because of the right to a speedy and public trial.
> Do you want to seriously jack up the criminal penalties for failure to appear in lieu of money forfeiture?
Yes, I want to punish the actually guilty in preference to punishing the merely accused. Do you seriously prefer the other way around?
You do it the way Washington D.C. does, and has for a couple decades.
> Without bail bondsmen how do you fund the extra police/marshals/sheriffs to find and arrest those who do not show up for court?
With general taxes, rather than taxes on the criminally accused.
> Without the ability to set bond amounts based upon offense characteristics and individual financial circumstances and criminal history, how do you prevent especially violent offenders with a likelihood of committing more violent acts while on pretrial release from committing new violent offenses?
Money bail doesn't prevent that; pretrial supervision or outright bail denial can, and so that's how you do it, choosing the least invasive level of supervision that provides adequate security in the circumstances.
> If you want to go the other direction and eliminate money bail, do you really want to police/prosecution to able to indefinitely incarcerate people until trial?
Before trial isn't indefinitely except at the choice of the accused, because of the right to a speedy and public trial.
> Do you want to seriously jack up the criminal penalties for failure to appear in lieu of money forfeiture?
Yes, I want to punish the actually guilty in preference to punishing the merely accused. Do you seriously prefer the other way around?