I'm fine with it, download or not it doesn't change my view of them. Any company that has that kind of information at its disposal is to be treated with caution.
A disingenuous response is usually designed as a full stop, rather than way to carry on a conversation.
If they're truly into the idea of promoting user-ownership of data, there will be more done to allow it (i.e. this will be first step).
EDIT: maybe I didn't understand what you mean ;)
However, I'd argue that a single act is really just a grand gesture. To expect to silence critics with such a gesture is unrealistic - and doesn't do anything to positively resolve the issues involved with any cause worth fighting for.
The privacy issues that Facebook might need to address are deep and wide ranging. Facebook instigates cultural change - it's the nature of that change which should be up for debate.