1) Downloading a KISS album from BitTorrent:
A little bit not-OK
2) Prosecuting some kid who downloads a KISS album from BitTorrent, costing him or his family tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars:
Extremely not-OK
Let's put it this way: why should "stealing" a 99c song be any different than shoplifting a 99c candy bar?
As much as the ads say "own the cd now" or "own the blu ray now" you own nothing. You are just paying for a license and some otherwise useless physical media.
Having said that, I still don't get why paying 99 cents for a song is so egregious if you've got a job.
Interestingly enough, I suspect that if Big Media hadn't sought such absurdly punitive damages in the early days, (destroying what little credibility and moral high ground they had), most average people would have sided with them and aided in social enforcement. Something like, say, the cost of the infringing material plus a $100 fine would go a lot further to aid their cause than $100k lawsuits.
The judgments that I immediately recall are:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RIAA_v._Tenenbaum
Or have all the cases been people who were also uploading (and hence potentially costing far more than one sale)?
No one's talking about murder or stealing, though, they're talking about copyright infringement.
When you download a song/album, you have a copy of it. It doesn't deprive the original owner/artist from continuing to sell it.
Piracy is not the only way to sample content, nor is it the only way to acquire DRM-free music online.
EDIT: Interesting that some folks are acting like they are not advocating privacy, only revolt over how stringent the fines are.
1) That's clearly not what the consensus is. Most of the top comments to this forum are ad hominem attacks on KISS over the quality of their music, or their somehow "not getting" how piracy HELPS them (which is hilarious).
2) The expected value of your fine is reasonable. It's the probability of you getting caught times the fine. That in essence is your calculus when you decide to download an album for free instead of paying for it, that your expected loss is still less than the cost per CD. Seen in this light the fine is set appropriately.