News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by ergothus on Monday July 30, 2018 @06:44PM (#17648861)
I'm generally pro-self-driving vehicles, and while I don't want to underestimate the difficulties, given how far related tech has gone in recent years I think it'd be a mistake to assume any of this is "never" going to happen.

Despite this, I've been very nervously watching how truck driving and self-driving interact. I feel like city-to-city long haul driving will have a very rapid turnover once a certain tech threshold is hit. That threshold might be 5 years out or 20 years out or even further, but once it is reached a lot of jobs cease to be as profitable very quickly.

Trucking is a major source of strong employment for those without a college degree. It is a significant source of employment all across the US, and there are related effects - entire small towns and certainly many small businesses rely on the income from truckers. (Everything here is about the US because I know too little about non-US to have even these vague reactions)

Miners have become a synonym for workers displaced by technology - yet mining was always 1-2 orders of magnitude smaller than modern trucking and took multiple generations to decline. Trucking could lose a big chunk of the industry in the course of a decade or less, to the tune of a million drivers or more. Having a million or more drivers that are suddenly unemployed or under employed would have a huge impact on the economy and public faith in the economy. Having this occur is predictable even if we can't predict when. Yet how many have given serious discussion on how to handle the reaction once this starts coming to pass?

Could be confirmation bias on my part, but I see cases like this - where the effort proved to be more complicated than expected - to falsely create the narrative that this is not a real problem to consider, which just makes the eventual impact worse.

EDIT: Please stop thinking I want to "protect" trucking or "stop" self-driving technology. I want neither - I just want us (society) to take advantage of the time when we know a change is coming but isn't here yet rather than deny it as "not yet real" and then wring our hands in despair over the consequences once it IS real.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by charmides on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:13PM (#17649056)
This attitude is nothing new. But I don't think people are seeing the big picture. Self-driving cars may cause a temporary spike in unemployment, but the economy and human workers benefits in the long term from the elimination of tedious work.

See how the length of the average working week has been decreasing in the USA:

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-8A9_5tIWVQY/U5XkaRfB8bI/AAAAAAAAM8...

(Source: Univ of Gröningen and Univ of California, Davis)

This is due to technologal innovations.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by munificent on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:29PM (#17649167)
> human workers benefits in the long term from the elimination of tedious work.

Given how many humans currently work at tedious jobs, the conclusion to come to is that they prefer that over no income at all. So simply eliminating that job isn't doing them any favors unless there's some solution for how they will still be able to pay their bills.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by chrischen on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @03:43AM (#17651285)
By eliminating tedious work, their bills would become smaller. That's the idea with progress, anyways.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by charmides on Monday July 30, 2018 @09:41PM (#17649883)
I don't think you are looking at the big picture either. New technology is constantly creating new jobs at the cost of old ones. Just like self-driving cars may displace truck drivers, so did new machines displace 19th century factory workers. However, this is such a small problem because the long-term economic benefits are enormous.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by chrischen on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @03:45AM (#17651294)
I think people fail to see what "economic benefits" actually means for them. It means that you start spending less time fighting off tuberculosis, dying from an infection, dying from childbirth complications, lowering the cost of living, etc. These things ultimately make it easier for any given person to sustain themselves, if it benefits society.

Take GMOs. They increase crop yields, making it cheaper to buy food. Sure it may have eliminated some jobs along the way, but then those guys ended up getting cheaper food at the cost of a having to find a new job.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by SolarNet on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:58PM (#17649366)
And while productivity has increased constantly, wages have stagnated. Companies need to start paying their much more productive workers a lot more money, or the benefits from the increased productivity will never be realized as growth (because that money won't go back into the middle class who are the most effective economic engines of growth per dollar earned).

https://thumbor.forbes.com/thumbor/960x0/https%3A%2F%2Fblogs...

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by zachwood on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:11PM (#17649455)
At what point do we give up on the dream of companies voluntarily paying workers more?

Forced redistribution from capital to labor should have started long ago, yet we appear to be moving in the opposite direction.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by ergothus on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:20PM (#17649104)
I don't think the reaction should be "Let's not do this, it could hurt jobs!". I also don't think the reaction should be "This is nothing to worry about, the jobs thing will work out over time".

Right now we have the option to anticipate and act to reduce any painful shocks. later we will not have the benefit of preparation.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by j88439h84 on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:53PM (#17649337)
That says "by persons engaged". I wouldn't be surprised if that's totally driven by people going from 0 work to some work, driving the average downward.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by Kalium on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:28PM (#17649153)
You're absolutely right! Trucking is a major sector of employment.

It's also a major source of life-shortening occupational health problems. The life expectancy of a trucker is 16 years shorter than the norm. Why are you so eager to protect jobs that are measurably killing the people who work them? Do you value these jobs so much that you're willing to pay for them in human lives?

For my own part, I'd rather have a million former truckers who need retraining and new skillsets than a million dead truckers. But that's me, and I'm known to be weird.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by SolarNet on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:57PM (#17649356)
Great redirect, but you failed to answer the actual question. But first a rebuttable.

First of all the life expectancy between college education and highschool education is 12 years. So that's only a 4 year shorter gap. (Perhaps universal medical care would fix this problem)

Second, do you seriously think the US has the capacity to handle 2 million unemployed truck drivers in the course of a couple years? That's a 10% increase overnight, and I have news for you, schools are already overburdened. (Perhaps free college education would provide the money to improve capacity, and fix two problems with one stone)

Third, the real problem is the jobs. What job are they going to do once they get their degree. Millennials are already one of the most highly trained yes underpaid generations yet, and they have the advantage of youth. The jobs aren't coming back from these sorts of events. (Perhaps a universal basic income would fix this problem)

And finally the real question was: What are we going to do about it. It was a request to have a conversation about the solution. Not to stop it from happening. I've provided my solutions, in the spirit of conversation I would be curious to see what you identify as problems, and your proposed solutions.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by CydeWeys on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:28PM (#17649540)
Comparing college vs high school graduate life expectancies isn't valid because truckers aren't a subset of one or the other; they have a good proportion from both groups. Taking off 12 years is the maximum effect assuming there isn't a single trucker that has a college degree, which of course isn't true.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by ergothus on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:27PM (#17649538)
> Why are you so eager to protect jobs that are measurably killing the people who work them?

uh...I'm not. Don't know where you got the idea that I was. Rather, I'd like to spend this lead up time before that industry is heavily hit to try and make sure the hit isn't so negative. Skill training programs, driver involvement in determining how the (future) devices would best work, etc. Make this a semi-planned obsolescence instead of a long-expected "surprise".

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by a3n on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:28PM (#17649544)
> For my own part, I'd rather have a million former truckers who need retraining and new skillsets than a million dead truckers.

I think figuring out how to deal with displaced categories of workers is a tougher problem than automated vehicles.

In any discussion like this, when I hear "retraining," I think of some county workforce office teaching you how to use Microsoft Word and Excel, giving you a certificate, giving you access to their jobs database, and forgetting about you.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by alexgmcm on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @06:11AM (#17651897)
Well there was the GI Bill that helped veterans retrain after WW2 in proper careers at real universities etc.

But that's a lot more expensive (although maybe less expensive in the long run than having a load of unproductive citizens)

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by j88439h84 on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:52PM (#17649323)
> The life expectancy of a trucker is 16 years shorter than the norm.

Source? What's "the norm"?

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by dsfyu404ed on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:56PM (#17649702)
Exactly. Does the norm include women? Truckers are mostly male and women live longer.

Take the typical male life expectancy and knock off a few years as a result of sitting in a chair all aday the kind of diet you wind up having from always being on the road and "16yr less than the norm" seems perfectly reasonable

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by shawn on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:11PM (#17649457)
It's offensive to claim that you know what's better for someone than the person living the life.

Humans Need Not Apply is an interesting perspective on some of these issues. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Pq-S557XQU

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by astebbin on Monday July 30, 2018 @10:03PM (#17649984)
It’s also life-shortening to suddenly and unexpectedly lost your job, especially when you’re over 40 and “retraining” isn’t really an option, or when all the other jobs have been automated away.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by dntrkv on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:12PM (#17649458)
> The life expectancy of a trucker is 16 years shorter than the norm

Where did you get this figure? Searching it for it turns up sources that discredit the claim.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by imtringued on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @05:52AM (#17651820)
>Do you value these jobs so much that you're willing to pay for them in human lives?

I don't really get what you're trying to say. Every hour I'm working at any job reduces my lifespan by one hour. The entire idea of work is that I'm paying with my own human life to obtain something else.

If the truck drivers get a new job they will still have to pay with their own life.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by Eridrus on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @12:36AM (#17650574)
I think it's basically impossible to prepare for. Finding jobs for these folks can't be done effectively in a top down manner. Retraining programs haven't been found to be very effective. We might extend additional unemployment benefits to people, but that will be a purely political issue when it comes around, not something that really requires planning/infrastructure. And making any transitional moves for truckers is going to be hard because there is currently a shortage of truckers already.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by ergothus on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @02:45PM (#17655861)
It doesn't have to be a top-down manner. Truckers (and those that rely on truckers) aren't stupid. If you were to go to them as a group and say "hey, we expect 50% of you to lose your jobs, or at least too many working hours, over the next 20 years. How do you want this to play out?" I suspect you'd get a lot of denials, but you'd also get some interest in having a say over the future. The drivers would know where the jobs are harder, they'd be in a good place to nurture the transition. If they were doing so IN FURTHERANCE of their (evolved) job rather than just destroying it, I bet you'd find some folks with ideas. Others would want to transition to a related-but-new job. Or retire early. Or pick up skills for an UNRELATED job. All of which is easier to bring about over the course of years with people who aren't worried about how to pay their rent/mortgage/food/medical bills.

In no way is this _easy_ - the number of issues to solve is huge and complex. But since we know the problem is going to happen I'd rather TRY to work on it, be that ruling from top or empowering the bottom or any other strategy other than "Wait until it's an emergency".