News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by sandworm101 on Monday July 30, 2018 @06:36PM (#17648795)
Can the robot perform a brake check? Can the robot ensure a load is properly secured? The act of driving the truck is only one of the many jobs a trucker does.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by privacypoller on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:11PM (#17649039)
They're addressed by established process and routine - 2 things machines do better than us. Can a machine monitor braking or perform the current brake check - absolutely. Could we shift the responsibility of check the load tie-down to the freight facility and monitor ongoing status with sensors. I'd hope so.

You should be asking "can a robot drive for 12+ hrs without fatigue?" or "can we eliminate the restrictive, expensive and often gamed system of keeping drivers within their hours?" This is were long-haul transport could be "disrupted"

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by sandworm101 on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:28PM (#17649155)
>> Can a machine monitor braking or perform the current brake check - absolutely.

I'm not sure you understand what a "brake check" means. It isn't checking the brakes for current functionality. It means a visual inspection of all the brake parts to ensure they aren't going to stop working somewhere literally down the road. It is checking for pins, debris, excessive or unusual wear, or leaks. It would require 3d vision backed up by some serious AI to understand what is going on. And you would probably need some sort of robotic actuator to remove any debris blocking inspection areas.

When you see a truck stopped by the road with the driver walking around the trailer, he is probably doing a legally mandated "brake check". It isn't just pumping the brakes to see they are still there.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by dsnuh on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:39PM (#17649245)
It is also checking brakes for functionality before you set out. There is an in-cab procedure too, not just a visual inspection. But I believe that both can be automated. The in-cab brake check is testing for certain pressures in the system under certain circumstances, and could be automated via software-hardware combo. The visual inspection could be done via a series of cameras under a bay the truck rolls over, with software to detect issues with the braking system components visually. Or either of these functions could be performed manually by a human at a waystation before the truck heads out on the (next leg of the) trip.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by marcosdumay on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:15PM (#17649071)
I don't think people are claiming computers can load or unload a truck.

Computers can check if a brake is working or if the cargo is well balanced better than a human. One could do those today with cheap (on the 100's of dollars) electronics and few lines of code. Nobody does this because it's 100's of dollars more than letting the driver do the same.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by dsnuh on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:21PM (#17649115)
I'm saying if you limit the scope to tractor trailers hauling only 20/40 ft ISO shipping containers, then "loading/unloading" can also be done in an automated fashion. I'm saying that if you limit the problem space, and try to approach even just a single use case such as this on a major artery like I-40, I don't see any way you end up in a worse spot than human drivers.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by bobwaycott on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:03PM (#17650231)
> I don't think people are claiming computers can load or unload a truck.

I think truckers would absolutely love it if this was the case. It would save them so much time waiting on loading/unloading, which decreases their pay.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by Drdrdrq on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @02:42AM (#17651040)
I don't think they would be the ones to profit from this invention though.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by dsnuh on Monday July 30, 2018 @06:53PM (#17648928)
I understand that the job encompasses other duties, my father is a retired truck driver. That said, my answer is "yes, I think they could, just as well, or better than any human".

You could have multiple cameras on the load using computer vision to detect movement. You could have weight sensors sending feedback to the system. I'm sure there are many ways to do this, and any of them would beat a human behind the wheel.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by sandworm101 on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:02PM (#17648981)
Then why not deploy such systems now? Prove they can handle all the odd jobs better than the human.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by dsnuh on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:08PM (#17649023)
Huh? I'm not saying they exist, just that it's not impossible for me to imagine these problems being solved or being minimized to a level that is no worse than current human driver would perform.
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by amarka on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:21PM (#17649114)
dsnuh - I haven't seen anyone argue against "[software+hardware] would beat a human behind the wheel", its just that developing the tech to achieve this feat with the same level of accuracy as the top 10-20% of current CDL drives is extremely expensive and caries a lot of risk. Nobody seems to of cracked the nut on it.

You're right in that there are many ways to do this, but none have come even close to beating a decent human behind the wheel.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by dsnuh on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:44PM (#17649282)
I don't see any indication in the article that they are stopping due to technical challenges. They already demonstrated it on the road, so it seems they were well on their way. It appears this project is a victim of politics and legal action.

Why do you think we need to get to the level of top 10%-20% of commercial drivers? How do you come to that cutoff point? If we had automated trucks that could move freight 24/7 with even 5% better than average accident rates (for example) would be a huge win.

Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by CoryG89 on Monday July 30, 2018 @09:03PM (#17649729)
I agree for the most part, but it's not quite as simple as just having better accident rates. That is one thing, but there are other considerations as well. When there are accidents, are they predictable ones, or is it completely random? Did it make a decision that we cannot explain which led to the accident? People aren't going to like completely random accidents, even if there are slightly fewer of them. Can we assign fault in the case of an accident, sometimes, always?
Re:Uber shuts down self-driving trucks unit by dsnuh on Monday July 30, 2018 @10:07PM (#17650004)
I think if you have a predictable accident, that's called negligence, and we have courts to deal with that.