News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by gok on Monday July 30, 2018 @05:34PM (#17648261)
> It is increasingly likely that retirees, as well as new workers, will be forced to take deeper benefit cuts.

Boohoo. Public service union members should have thought about that before pursuing a pyramid scheme retirement plan instead of a defined contribution pension like the rest of us.

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by chris_mc on Monday July 30, 2018 @06:13PM (#17648626)
Why in the ever loving fuck are you blaming the _workers_ for this shortsightedness instead of the government organizations who are about to fuck those people over when they're 70?

Maybe the administrators of the pension accounts and financial planners for these organizations should have done better by the people who are busting their (collective) asses to provide services for you, the taxpayer?

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by landryraccoon on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:22PM (#17649120)
> Why in the ever loving fuck are you blaming the _workers_ for this shortsightedness instead of the government organizations who are about to fuck those people over when they're 70?

Well, we are the ones paying those people's pensions, in the form of taxes, so we're the ones fucking ourselves over if they got too sweet of a deal right?

I am personally not going to get 50-100% of my maximum salary as guaranteed compensation for the rest of my life until I retire - are you? I'm not super enthusiastic about paying taxes for someone else to get a better retirement deal than me, either.

I'm fine with paying government employees what they're worth while they're working - hell, I think most of them deserve a raise. But they also should have defined contribution retirement plans, not defined benefit, like everyone else working in private industry.

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by candiodari on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:09PM (#17649437)
> Well, we are the ones paying those people's pensions, in the form of taxes, so we're the ones fucking ourselves over if they got too sweet of a deal right?

And how does this square with this being a democracy ? Or to put it another way: you're also (indirectly, but ...) the ones promising sweet pensions to these people if they would just work. And they worked. Now you want to revoke your part of the bargain ?

Furthermore, if you refuse to pay for their pensions ... do future kids get to refuse to pay for yours ? (either directly, or through devaluing the currency, just in case your answer is that private sector pensions are safe)

But we all know that there's no answer here, so it'll be devaluation. At least that means private and public pensions are equally screwed (I'm leaning socialist, so I like fairness in the sense that people get treated the same).

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by landryraccoon on Monday July 30, 2018 @09:42PM (#17649889)
> And how does this square with this being a democracy ? Or to put it another way: you're also (indirectly, but ...) the ones promising sweet pensions to these people if they would just work. And they worked. Now you want to revoke your part of the bargain ?

So I think this argument actually works against you.

First, nothing can bind future generations. They can always change whatever they want to. In the United States, a future congress can revoke, alter or amend any law passed by a previous congress. So if you want your pensions to be secured, the benefits cannot be guaranteed by faith in future governments!

In this sense, a defined contribution plan is more secure than a defined benefit plan. This is because a defined contribution plan belongs to the recipient as soon as the funds are allocated - even if a future government changes the rules, the money that's already in your 401K is yours!

Consider the alternative - are you saying that future generations are always bound to the decisions of past generations, even though they may not even have been alive or of voting age? If a law is fair and benefits society, that future generation will respect it because it benefits society. If that law is unfair to them they can and absolutely should change that law! How could it be otherwise? As a socialist this should utterly appall you. Do you believe that laws put into place by capitalists and large corporations constitute binding pacts between governments and their citizens, and that any future government that seeks to amend them towards a more equitable balance is now acting unfairly?

If the median income in a nation is $40K, but the median pension given by the state exceeds that income, then who is suffering unfairly if the pension is reduced to be more in line with what the average worker earns? How as a socialist could you justify a pensioner earning more than a productive active worker?

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by aisengard on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:29PM (#17650324)
So think of it this way, how would you feel if a socialist government took over and decided that your 401k is fair game for extra taxation? But it's _your_ money, capitalism promised you! "Boohoo", you should have thought of that before entering into a clearly unsustainable pyramid scheme.

Not so useful or interesting in terms of commentary, is it?

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by landryraccoon on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:07AM (#17653743)
The standard shouldn't be that government decisions are set in stone forever, period. The standard should be good policy, in both directions. If a previous government sets a bad policy, a future government should not be bound to it. If it sets a good policy, a future government should uphold it. If a future government decides to be "bad" and tear up everything, no piece of paper will stop them.
Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by candiodari on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @08:27AM (#17652577)
> So if you want your pensions to be secured, the benefits cannot be guaranteed by faith in future governments!

It's funny how you see this as a positive ? If people have this attitude, of course the result will be mercantilism, or worse : the hoarding of jobs/companies/markets and the only way to get into a specific jobs is to do whatever "the guild" wants, which I guarantee will include paying pensions.

And if you "go around" the guild, they will either regulate you out of existence or outright physically attack you. Before you say that can't work I'd like to point out that they did this in almost all of Europe for ~1200 years.

And under these conditions, I would understand that way of working.

Such things are the alternative. So, I would very much want people to have faith in government, and that very much means you have to pay up the promises made before.

> Consider the alternative - are you saying that future generations are always bound to the decisions of past generations, even though they may not even have been alive or of voting age? If a law is fair and benefits society, that future generation will respect it because it benefits society.

You mean, paying people for their work what they were promised when they started that work, for example ? Like pensions ?

> How as a socialist could you justify a pensioner earning more than a productive active worker?

I don't understand why this would be a problem for a socialist ?

> Consider the alternative - are you saying that future generations are always bound to the decisions of past generations,

What I don't understand is that as a supposed capitalist alternative you're actually advocating making promises (like pensions), then reneging on them. Your alternative is to lie. Make promises, and exploit people who believe them ...

I guarantee if there is one thing that kills markets faster than anything else it's a loss of trust. You're advocating, unless I'm mistaking, exploiting trust. This is just not going to work.

There's a reason most historical capitalist societies had extreme versions of holding people to their promises. Slavery, debtors' prisons, forced labor, indentured servitude, ... were "solutions" used by past societies to avoid this problem. There was presumably a reason they did this ... do you really want to go back ?

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by landryraccoon on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @11:08AM (#17653765)
If you are a socialist, you ignored my most important argument :

> If the median income in a nation is $40K, but the median pension given by the state exceeds that income, then who is suffering unfairly if the pension is reduced to be more in line with what the average worker earns?

If government pensions pay out more at retirement than the median worker makes while working, would you agree that under socialism this would be considered unfair to the worker, and overly exploitative for the pensioner?

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by candiodari on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @03:52PM (#17656470)
> If government pensions pay out more at retirement than the median worker makes while working, would you agree that under socialism this would be considered unfair to the worker, and overly exploitative for the pensioner?

No, because, firstly, this isn't true. The government simply has started to pay less. From any individual's perspective, I assure you they don't earn more in retirement than when they were working. If you have heard differently, I assure you that's propaganda.

Secondly, I would simply say that current government employees have the right to be paid the same as their predecessors. Lowering pensions ? No way I'd agree to that as a socialist. No way in hell. But you should raise the conditions for government employees.

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by landryraccoon on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @04:48PM (#17656962)
> I assure you they don't earn more in retirement than when they were working. If you have heard differently, I assure you that's propaganda.

They earn more than the average worker overall. In California the average government pensioner earns 26% more than the average non retired, currently working worker.

Source:

https://californiapolicycenter.org/what-is-the-average-pensi...

That's too much. As a socialist, I would find it clearly exploitative that a non worker is making more than an active worker. That's completely unjustifiable under socialism.

The point of a pension is to provide an income so a retiree doesn't live in poverty. Paying a pension that exceeds that of a younger worker who is actively working full time completely goes against that.

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by candiodari on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @07:03PM (#17667858)
> That's too much. As a socialist, I would find it clearly exploitative that a non worker is making more than an active worker. That's completely unjustifiable under socialism.

I don't understand where this is coming from. Personally, I am a socialist and I think it's too little.

If I look at it from a capitalist's perspective, I ... also think it's too little.

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by landryraccoon on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @07:47PM (#17668106)
> Personally, I am a socialist and I think it's too little.

I'm sorry, just to be clear, are you saying that as a socialist, you think a young worker who is actively working and only making $40K a year should pay more to support someone who is making $50K a year but isn't working at all, because $50K is too little?

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by candiodari on Thursday August 02, 2018 @04:53AM (#17670110)
I think they should both be paid more. In case you don't remember, socialism is about the state just taking control of the means of production, so where the money comes from is quite obvious.
Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by jefurii on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @07:55PM (#17658412)
> Well, we are the ones paying those people's pensions,

My dad (retired) was a career public employee. He paid into his pension every month of his entire career. He earned every damn penny he's getting right now.

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by zzleeper on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @07:10PM (#17667892)
Statistically speaking, he didn't. What he paid was way lower than the expected vsñue of what he'll get. That's the entire idea of a pyramid pension scheme.
Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by gok on Monday July 30, 2018 @06:53PM (#17648926)
The flip-side of collective bargaining is collective responsibility, I'm afraid.

The federal government saw this coming 30 years ago, moved to a hybrid, mostly-defined-contribution system and (surprise!) is doing fine. Most state and municipal unions fought to keep their defined-benefit plans and now are going to suffer for it.

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by wahern on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:28PM (#17649160)
Huh? As of 2012 "[t]he vast majority of full-time civilian federal workers receive roughly half of their retirement compensation through their defined-benefit pension plans (the rest comes from Social Security)." (https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/private-vs-public-defi...)

That National Review hit piece notwithstanding, in truth defined benefit plans are, technically speaking, the most efficient form of deferred compensation. Lowest overhead with maximum value received by the [average] retiree, which theoretically permits employers to minimize total amount of compensation.

The rub is that the employer needs to fully fund the liabilities as they accrue. Government and unions, however, have been content for state employers to "pay as you go"--use today's contributions to pay yesterday's liabilities. That's a recipe for disaster.

It sucks that we've thrown the baby out with the bath water--swapped pensions for 401(k)s. Defined benefit plans are annuities, and most economists agree that the most efficient retirement savings plan is an annuity. How we pay for that annuity is a different matter altogether. We know that people aren't rational enough to choose to put their retirement savings into an annuity, so it's obvious the employer should do this for them. The only real question is how to structure the premium payments so employers can't cheat (and employees can't be complicit in the cheating).

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by lotsofpulp on Monday July 30, 2018 @09:33PM (#17649852)
Reality shows annuities aren’t the most efficient retirement savings plans, otherwise this conversation about underfunded pensions wouldn’t be happening.

No insurance company would sell an annuity for as little as what governments claim they cost. And anytime you get a big pot of money, there will be corruption and cheating.

The most efficient retirement plan is having multiple successful children who are raised to take care of their parents.

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by dunpeal on Monday July 30, 2018 @06:23PM (#17648697)
Read sykhic's comments below. These unsustainable sweetheart deals were negotiated by the government employees and their unions.
Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by dv_dt on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:16PM (#17649076)
Isn't there equal responsibility for politicians & gov'ts who agreed to the negotiated contracts? Were they not agreeing in good faith?
Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by hn_throwaway_99 on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:04PM (#17649407)
Corporate management and worker unions have what I'd call a "healthy" adversarial relationship. Corporations want to pay workers as little as possible, unions want workers to make as much as possible, so hopefully you get a decent compromise.

With public sector unions, especially in smaller cities and states, the relationship is more incestuous and oftentimes the settlements aren't really made in good faith. The politicians desire the political support of the unions they are negotiating with, and figure by the time the pension bomb explodes it will be some other poor sucker's problem. Taxpayers are the ones that get screwed.

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by dunpeal on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:38PM (#17649600)
Exactly. Not to mention that by the time it gets to the elected official's desk for signature, it's been negotiated between government employees and their senior managers, who are also government employees...

It's basically a deal negotiated by government employees among themselves, and approved by a politician who often needs to maintain favor among these employees.

Add to that the fact that these agreements only lead to a crisis long after the politician is retired (or dead), and it's no wonder these unsustainable deals get approved as a matter of course.

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by ericmcer on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:16PM (#17650280)
No one busts their ass like government workers! Government jobs are well known for high job security and very few performance based incentives. Not exactly a recipe for hard work.
Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by betterunix2 on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:55PM (#17649348)
Like it or not these pensions are already legal obligations of state and local governments. Yell about or at the unions all you want, but if these obligations are not met, get ready for lawsuits and negative consequences for municipal credit ratings. Would you rather pay somewhat higher taxes now to cover pension obligations, or significantly higher taxes later because of the higher muni bond rates your state will have to deal with when the problem worsens (or your state is forced into bankruptcy)?

This is not just a problem of public employees or their unions. You are on the hook for these payments and will remain on the hook even if starting today everyone had a defined-contribution plan. Yes, this is your problem too.

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by ghein on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:09PM (#17649436)
The guarantees - constitutional in some states - are what will cause the problem to be bigger.

When you can't resolve unsustainable debt without bankruptcy, then you will go bankrupt and credit rating be damned.

Detroit, Chicago, Illinois are just warm ups for the big battles over the next few decades.

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by betterunix2 on Monday July 30, 2018 @09:43PM (#17649893)
I am not convinced that things are hopeless. If we continue to avoid the problem then eventually it will become unsolvable, but we still have a chance to fix this. Step 1 is finding leaders who "tell it like it is" (not the idiotic version that our president practices, but the version where you give people a clear and honest assessment of the situation they face) and are prepared to make hard decisions that might risk their political aspirations. We might also take a moment to reexamine the seemingly religious devotion some politicians have to cutting taxes and accept the fact that sometimes higher taxes are necessary to prevent even costlier outcomes (in NJ we pay more to repair the damage potholes do to our cars than we would pay in higher taxes to properly maintain our roads -- somehow people have trouble connecting the dots).
Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by randysavage on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:02PM (#17649391)
Good luck keeping the highest end of you tax base around to cover the shortfalls.
Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by betterunix2 on Monday July 30, 2018 @09:35PM (#17649858)
Maybe so, but wealthy people seem to like living in high-tax areas like NYC and SF, and I am pretty sure they also like having paved roads, functioning transit systems, and all the other things they would lose if the state had to find a way to meet its obligations without raising taxes. Things are not yet hopeless and if we had politicians who did their jobs and demonstrated competent leadership we could sort out this mess.
Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by randysavage on Monday July 30, 2018 @09:58PM (#17649961)
> if we had politicians who did their jobs and demonstrated competent leadership we could sort out this mess.

This feels like the crux of the problem, but we've got the politicians we voted for. I'm starting to wonder if its even possible for the average person to vote in the long-term interests of their community against their own short-term interest. Some will... but the majority?

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by felix_nagaand on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @02:48AM (#17651054)
The majority won't because they haven't the luxury of time to understand the consequences of the politicians being voted into office. Your average person doesn't actually understand the differences between a Republican and a Democrat. They assume the label that works for them socially and run with their herd. Both of which are aimed off the cliff by the inane policy makers elected on popularity over policy. This system works and the average person is too short sighted to see the cliff, at no fault of their own.

For the most part the average citizens do everything they should and a bit more. Sadly resources are mismanaged and citizens carry the burden because our system is collectively failing to stop bad actors at every stop.

Every good solution ive heard comes at the expense of higher taxes especially on rent seekers and high income/ wealthy individuals and families. Ignoring the political suicide of going after those classes, the entire proposal is a catch 22. How can these victims be expected to trust a politician when they've been taken advantage of by politicians their whole lives?

Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by rdlecler1 on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @07:53AM (#17652407)
And all that money they saved increased demand for real estate, so not only does the younger generation get stuck with the bill for everyone who found a free lunch, but the younger generation now has to pay more for real estate because there’s less supply.
Re:The Pension Hole for U.S. Cities and States Is the Size o... by nerbert on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @02:21AM (#17650964)
As opposed to the people who are responsible for managing it, who must be the victims I assume?