News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by Tiki on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:42AM (#17645233)
Towards the end of the article was the question I had all along reading it:

"Where was mind when the universe was born? And what sustained the universe for the billions of years before we came to be? He nonetheless bravely offers us a lovely, chilling paradox: At the heart of everything is a question, not an answer. When we peer down into the deepest recesses of matter or at the farthest edge of the universe, we see, finally, our own puzzled face looking back at us."

Can someone explain how his 'answer' is chilling or lovely? It's fine if he wants to offer his own pet theory of reality, but to give a cop out answer to its most fundamental question doesn't go far to support it.

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by s-shellfish on Monday July 30, 2018 @12:26PM (#17645645)
I find it both chilling and lovely. Because on one hand, life, endless adventure, full of surprises, insights, new understandings and experiences, feelings, etc. On the other, absolute, fundamental, loneliness (sophistry?) of our own nature - having an individual sense of self but also feeling related to everything we define as not 'I'.

Why this life, why is this the one I have? Where did all of this come from? How did all of this happen?

Life is a waking dream, because we often completely forget that we really just don't know at all why we are here. But we pretend, we forget, we make up stories, we do anything we can do to run away from that question. Why. How did all of this happen? Why does everything happen the way it does? What does that mean, for what I am, all the way at the core?

It's not really nihilism, but it sort of is. It's just, that's the perpetual question that never gets answered directly.

I've thought of myself before as a monad - a being so fundamentally lonely in their own existence that they split themselves up into infinite pieces, just to forget, there's nothing more than what they are. Maybe some buddhist influences, but, we all have our struggles in life. It's not really intended to be sophistry. It just is a very beautiful, but very chilling awareness. What if I go back into what I was when I die?

You could see this as a mental metaphor my mind has arbitrarily made up for all events I've witnessed and been a part of, some sort of perpetual social ostracism I keep walking myself into. But I still think it's more than just that. I loved science growing up. But I can never answer that question - and I know absolutely, that I never will. What happened before 'I exist'?. For any of us. My father often has had a variant of this question, and in the past, it's rubbed people the wrong way because, only a fraction of it gets expressed. We all wear masks. Sometimes there's just a profoundly deep sadness that no one can see.

Chilling, and lovely. In perpetuity.

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by dwaltrip on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @12:13AM (#17650492)
> Why this life, why is this the one I have?

This one we are beginning to be able to answer. From what I can tell, the question is entirely backwards. One doesn't have a life. A life has a someone.

A self is a messy, changing collection of descriptions of a human, the most extensive of which are those descriptions that are contained within one's own brain and also in one's bodily presence.

The descriptions don't posses the life. The life generates and manifests the descriptions.

------

To be fair, there are many, many useful reasons to frequently ignore this perspective and pretend that we are selves that do indeed possess a life -- the strongest being that we seemingly can't help but do so most of the time, just like we can't help but take the next breath.

However, taking the time to appreciate and meditate on the above can very worthwhile. At least, it has been for me personally.

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by s-shellfish on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @10:19AM (#17653323)
Was watching Sherlock Holmes recently.

'Your life is not your own. Keep your hands off of it.'

- Sir Arthur Conan Doyle

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by zshrdlu on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @06:09AM (#17661130)
There are reductionist answers to these questions, albeit incomplete. We know about evolution, we know about the Big Bang. We are not sure by what exact mechanism consciousness works -- if we can even define it properly enough to begin with, but going by our current model of the universe we know it is the result of the Big Bang, and evolution.

There are intermediate answers to questions like "Why this life, why is this the one I have? Where did all of this come from? How did all of this happen?"

The chain of intermediate questions and answers leads to the ultimate frontiers of science. One has to accept the possibility that our desire for an ultimate, resounding answer to these questions may never be quenched. Perhaps the universe just defies human understanding at some point. Even our language become circular at some point: the definitions of "thing", "entity", and "object" all refer to each other - there is no definition beyond them; without circularity dictionaries would be infinite.

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by s-shellfish on Wednesday August 01, 2018 @08:02AM (#17661681)
The circular thing with dictionaries - that makes sense. I've always seen dictionaries as infinite. Shakespeare invented words. Computational definitions of symbols, mathematics, etc are different.

I don't really see it as circular, more like a spiral. Each layer of computation or math - in 3s. Computer, mind, paper. Or symbol relates to symbol through symbol. Deductive proof techniques, the memory of all existing knowledge filling in the gaps between each sequential step. Layers of definitions stack, those are computer programs.

https://youtu.be/Ad4T-j_bOVc

The internet makes so much of life weird. Memories, words. Everything a reminder, automatic.

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by rellui on Monday July 30, 2018 @01:41PM (#17646350)
Whenever anyone asks me: why do you live? Where do we come from? I just ask back: why do you care?
Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by crooked-v on Monday July 30, 2018 @07:42PM (#17649266)
> The history of every major galactic civilisation tends to pass through three distinct and recognisable phases, those of Survival, Enquiry and Sophistication, otherwise known as the How, Why and Where phases.

> For instance, the first phase is characterised by the question "How can we eat?", the second by the question "Why do we eat?", and the third by the question "Where shall we have lunch?"

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by sametmax on Monday July 30, 2018 @02:43PM (#17646885)
And now we got 3 "I don't know".
Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by bpchaps on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:23PM (#17649513)
Because it's interesting, dammit!
Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by katzgrau on Monday July 30, 2018 @09:10PM (#17649754)
Really well articulated.

Im not sure the question of what happened before "I" is so puzzling though. If your're making up the events that you're witnessing today, why would the "time" prior to you be any different?

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by s-shellfish on Monday July 30, 2018 @09:37PM (#17649868)
Thank you.

Time is something I'm learning to both be able to see as something to keep in mind from a practical perspective, but also, something I can seem to let go of. It's very challenging, sometimes - but it seems essential to grasp 'flow'. Thank you for that.

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by Bromskloss on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:09PM (#17649438)
> loneliness (sophistry?)

Solipsism?

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by s-shellfish on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:22PM (#17649505)
That's the one I intended, thank you!
Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by noiv on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:55AM (#17645364)
You may want to exclude language from reality. The dichotomy of questions and answers might not happen in the latter. Or the other way round: As long you have questions you're not there yet. I present you one piece of the puzzle: The Physics and Philosophy of Time - with Carlo Rovelli on Youtube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-6rWqJhDv7M

In a way he supposes minds as entropy inducing entities.

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by opportune on Monday July 30, 2018 @01:32PM (#17646269)
I agree, it’s not profound except at face value. Just strikes me as extremely vague and hand-wavy metaphysics

This is the reason that a lot of people don’t like philosophy - because people hide behind verbal tricks which have little meaning beyond sounding “deep”. Green ideas sleep furiously

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by tylerjwilk00 on Monday July 30, 2018 @10:01PM (#17649976)
Some ideas are so subtle that words fail to describe. In the same way lay explanations of physics lack understanding that pure equations deliver.

The trick of the philosopher is an attempt at conveying meaning with a blunt instrument.

"To cross a river you need a boat. But when you reach the other side you don’t pick up the boat and carry it." ~ Alan Watts

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by s-shellfish on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @04:15PM (#17656681)
My former PhD advisor said something along the lines of 'the incompleteness of natural language', this being one of the hardest problems he's been aware of.

This is him:

https://www.cs.stevens.edu/~naumann/publications/publication...

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by gowld on Monday July 30, 2018 @08:24PM (#17649514)
Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by TeMPOraL on Monday July 30, 2018 @02:51PM (#17646947)
I agree. If you immediately know the candle light is fire, then the meal was cooked a long time ago.
Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by s-shellfish on Monday July 30, 2018 @05:51PM (#17648434)
Can't there be room for both awarenesses in a single mind?
Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by empath75 on Monday July 30, 2018 @12:42PM (#17645781)
> Where was mind when the universe was born? And what sustained the universe for the billions of years before we came to be?

The past was created when people started probing it, in the same sense that the present is.

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by optimuspaul on Monday July 30, 2018 @03:24PM (#17647208)
That is what I was thinking as well... made me wonder, did my mind create your comment 2 hours in the past when I had the thought? Are you even real?
Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by drb91 on Monday July 30, 2018 @04:55PM (#17647928)
One might have emotional attachment to an explainable universe; in such a scenario you might find the concept of an ultimate unanswerable question chilling. Or alternatively if you’re a skeptic, you might find it lovely.
Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by sridca on Monday July 30, 2018 @10:50PM (#17650173)
> Where was mind when the universe was born?

This is an answer in the guise of a question, and the answer (belief) being that the universe is finite. Let me offer a better question: is the universe finite or infinite?

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by wu-ikkyu on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:16PM (#17650283)
>Let me offer a better question: is the universe finite or infinite?

What is the concept of infinity but the outer limit of our mind's ability to conceptualize?

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by drdeca on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @10:29AM (#17653413)
"Infinite" can be understood as "not finite" or "without limit", or "equinumerous with a strict subset of itself".

(I don't know why you switched from "infinite" to "infinity". I am opting to answer for the word "infinite".)

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by RobertoG on Monday July 30, 2018 @11:52AM (#17645322)
Well, I suppose the answer is the same that for the game of the '20 questions in its “surprise” version' that the article mention.

Where was the word before the first question is asked?

Re:Do Our Questions Create the World? by sbjs on Monday July 30, 2018 @03:58PM (#17647470)
"Where was mind when the universe was born? And what sustained the universe for the billions of years before we came to be?"

I'm sorry but this is just dumb. Things existed before the author was born, and the author doesn't question that. Are philosophers really so far detached from reality that they can't imagine that maybe the simple answers to things are the right ones? I think xkcd's squirt gun is a genuine solution for an existential crisis like this. Reality is what's around you, and getting lost in deep and complicated thoughts doesn't change what's actually real outside your mind.