News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Signaling in tech is some fucked up shit (2016) by panic on Sunday July 29, 2018 @06:01PM (#17640528)
Presumably people are paying you to find good engineers, not just people who match particular profiles. If "rational prejudice" doesn't always find the good engineers, why justify it like this? Wouldn't it be better to take this as evidence that your approach could use improvement?
Re:Signaling in tech is some fucked up shit (2016) by curun1r on Sunday July 29, 2018 @06:42PM (#17640768)
> people are paying you to find good engineers

No, they're paying them to find engineers that will pass the interview process. It's a subtle, but important distinction since prejudices that exist among engineers will naturally develop in recruiters. It's the recruiting equivalent of teaching to the test.

And like it or not, the kind of signaling the article describes is real. When an engineer says they can write clojure, it indicates a curiosity that ability to program JavaScript does not. Almost no one is forced to learn Clojure because of some job, project or even job prospects. It means you likely cared enough to devote your own time to learning for the sake of learning. And a lot of engineers look at this kind of thing as important and screen for it in interviews.

A recruiter operating any differently would be like a machine learning algorithm that ignores its training data.

Re:Signaling in tech is some fucked up shit (2016) by gaius on Tuesday July 31, 2018 @03:56AM (#17651345)
It means you likely cared enough to devote your own time to learning for the sake of learning. And a lot of engineers look at this kind of thing as important and screen for it in interviews.

The curious thing is, I think the number who regard it as important is likely far higher than the number who actually do it. Which is understandable; once you reach a level of seniority you also have many other demands on your time and may not be able to be a hobbyist anymore on top of day job, family commitments and so on. So maybe once you learnt every new language but now you don’t have the opportunity, or you have decided to “go deep” in just a few, established languages. So the power of the signal is highly variable depending both on where the interviewer and interviewee are in their lives.

Also, knowing JS in the late-90s did indicate a curious and ambitious developer. It only went mainstream later...

Re:Signaling in tech is some fucked up shit (2016) by darawk on Sunday July 29, 2018 @06:15PM (#17640612)
No. You have limited resources to sift through people. Heuristics like this are an efficient way to reduce your search space. That is sort of the whole point of statistics.