That said, any lay definition of supercomputer would seem to require actual performance (e.g. high FLOPS rate), which trivally supports the initial assertion.
One can call something like the Folding@Home project a distributed supercomputer, but it's not that interesting, especially to build such a system, for anything embarrassingly parallel.
Obviously if you have a special purpose system you can made different trades-off.
It should be obvious, but the post I was reacting to was claiming that it cannot be 'real HPC' without high-speed interconnects. It depends on what you are a cluster/HPC facilities for. Typically institutions (such as universities) have different facilities with different trade-offs.
> the post I was reacting to was claiming that it cannot be 'real HPC' without high-speed interconnects
That was me, and that's still my point. The perception of users that have the embarassingly parallel workload isn't particularly meaningful. We already had the pretty generic terms "grid computing", "distributed computing" and "cluster".
What's the point of nomenclature like "HPC" if it describes something that's indistinguishable from that single workstation merely multiplied by some large number, somehow attached over the Internet?
If it's not "real HPC", then what is a better term of art to describe the sort of computing that can deliver high performance to workloads that include ones that are not embarrassingly parallel?