Re:London’s Super-Recognizer Police Force (2016)
by gus_massa on Sunday July 29, 2018 @09:10AM
(#17637947)
From http://hnrankings.info/ it looks like the #2 submission was "Detecting the use of "curl | bash" server-side" (324 points, 10 hours ago, 105 comments)
Now your comments has 35 minutes and the OP has 56 minutes. So with some approximations, lets say that at the time you wrote this the OP has an age of 0.5 hour and the #2 post has 9.5 hours.
Roughly the order of the HN post is: upvotes/age^1.5 * lot-of-penalites
[There are many post that discuss the details of the order in HN that are more accurate, I don't remember if the gravity factor is 1.5 or 1.6 or whatever, and it may change from time to time. It's part of the secret sauce, but let's use this version as an approximation.]
The weight of the articles half a hour ago was:
This post -> 9/(.5)^1.5 = 25
Curl/bash post -> 324/(9.5)^1.5 = 11
So it's expected that this post was in front of the curl/bash post. Not surprising.
As far as I know, the post don't get a better position because they have comments. [It's part of the secret sauce, ...] I personally prefer post with few comments.
There are many penalties, some are automatic, some are added by the mods and some are caused by the flags of the users. [It's part of the secret sauce, ...] One penalty that is surprising for many users is the "flamewar" detector, that applies a penalty when an article has too much comments (something like "comments > upvotes + 40"???) So too many comments is usually bad for the article.
In this case, I think that neither of the articles has activated the "flamewar" detector or other penalty. I think the problem is that if you don't have a rough idea of the order algorithm it is sometimes surprising.
Now your comments has 35 minutes and the OP has 56 minutes. So with some approximations, lets say that at the time you wrote this the OP has an age of 0.5 hour and the #2 post has 9.5 hours.
Roughly the order of the HN post is: upvotes/age^1.5 * lot-of-penalites
[There are many post that discuss the details of the order in HN that are more accurate, I don't remember if the gravity factor is 1.5 or 1.6 or whatever, and it may change from time to time. It's part of the secret sauce, but let's use this version as an approximation.]
The weight of the articles half a hour ago was:
This post -> 9/(.5)^1.5 = 25
Curl/bash post -> 324/(9.5)^1.5 = 11
So it's expected that this post was in front of the curl/bash post. Not surprising.
As far as I know, the post don't get a better position because they have comments. [It's part of the secret sauce, ...] I personally prefer post with few comments.
There are many penalties, some are automatic, some are added by the mods and some are caused by the flags of the users. [It's part of the secret sauce, ...] One penalty that is surprising for many users is the "flamewar" detector, that applies a penalty when an article has too much comments (something like "comments > upvotes + 40"???) So too many comments is usually bad for the article.
In this case, I think that neither of the articles has activated the "flamewar" detector or other penalty. I think the problem is that if you don't have a rough idea of the order algorithm it is sometimes surprising.