News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by jacquesm on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @09:17AM (#1763761)
I'm definitely rooting for Google on this one, they do plenty of weird stuff themselves but Oracle is behaving like a complete bully in this whole saga. Since they acquired SUN it's been going from bad to worse in a hurry, to the point where major Java users are starting to wonder if they made the right decision committing themselves to the platform.

Time will tell on how this will turn out, I don't expect a case of this magnitude to take less than a few years, these are just the opening salvos.

Oracle has a lot to lose here, and that's not just the lawsuit.

The analysis presented here is pretty damning of Oracles behavior, especially the fact that the counter is that they have taken the opposite position before they owned Java through the SUN acquisition.

.NET just might see an upsurge because of all this.

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by bad_user on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @09:29AM (#1763805)
Oracle was probably hoping for an out of court resolution, similarly to how Microsoft was able to do with HTC.

Google instead has to defend it with everything it has, because lately Android phone manufacturers are being under attack by Apple and Microsoft (Nokia could be joining soon).

Regardless of the result ... this whole affair is going to generate a ton of bad press for Oracle, and I hope they learned something from the SCO lawsuit and just back off before it's too late.

And when comparing this lawsuit with SCO versus IBM and Novell, Oracle sells database management software, a field in which Google probably has patents by now. Were they hoping for a cross-licensing deal or something?

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by jacquesm on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @09:42AM (#1763854)
> going to generate a ton of bad press

That's already happening:

http://flexblog.faratasystems.com/2010/08/13/time-for-open-s...

http://www.pcworld.com/businesscenter/article/203336/oracles...

http://www.infoworld.com/t/platforms/computer-user-group-bla...

http://www.infoworld.com/t/languages-and-standards/oracle-th...

Comparisons with SCO are already being made in the kind of publications read by IT management and Oracle is already taking damage from this.

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by tptacek on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @11:44AM (#1764405)
Yes. Now everyone thinks Oracle is a bloodthirsty opportunist that only cares about money. What a blunder.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by js2 on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @12:30PM (#1764610)
You left out the <sarcasm> marker so someone will be confused...
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by lanstein on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @12:50PM (#1764723)
If by someone, you mean 'one person', then you're probably right.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by rbanffy on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @12:23PM (#1764579)
Everybody already considered Oracle a bloodthirsty opportunist that only cares about money. What changed is that now Oracle is a bloodthirsty opportunist that only cares about money and that has leverage over a huge industry.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by barrkel on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @10:55PM (#1766686)
The comments I've heard from executives is that they're really impressed with Oracle's move - practically have a hard-on about it - and contempt for Sun's lack of balls.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by jemfinch on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @11:38AM (#1764375)
> Oracle was probably hoping for an out of court resolution, similarly to how Microsoft was able to do with HTC.

Really? Who has Google settled out of court with on patent litigation?

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by gaius on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @09:42AM (#1763857)
1) Consumers don't care; most of them have never heard of Oracle and 2) Oracle's large corporate customers will cheer them on for defending their patents.

Oh and 3) Google's "do no evil" schtick is a triumph of PR, but that's all it is. They are just a corporation like anyone else, and they will do what's right for them, period.

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by bad_user on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @10:02AM (#1763943)

     Consumers don't care
Customers (the ones paying money) care about doing business with winners, not hypocritical trolls (SCO was one, the jury is still out on Oracle). And starting IP lawsuits instead of delivering products has a desperation stench attached; and you can bet that Oracle's customers care about that.

And speaking of corporate customers, those include companies like Adobe which also have investments on top of Java.

     Oracle's large corporate customers will cheer them on for defending 
     their patents.
This line of reasoning I don't get: are they earning anything from Oracle's lawsuit?

Quite the contrary, unless you have a patent arsenal the size of Microsoft's or IBM's, patents are one of the biggest nightmares you can have, especially since this lawsuit proves that companies like Oracle aren't acquiring patents just for "defensive purposes" and lawsuits are not reserved just to patent trolls.

      Google's "do no evil" schtick is a triumph of PR, but that's all it is
Corporations are recognized by the law to have rights and responsibilities like natural persons. Companies should and are punished for their bad behavior in society.

Regardless of Google's morality, this discussion is not about Google, but about Oracle's lawsuit. Substitute Google with "X" and it would be the same.

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by blub on Thursday October 07, 2010 @03:17AM (#1767094)
This discussion is very much about Google, and how they're trying to look like the good guy.

But the fact is, they screwed Sun over and forked mobile Java without giving them a cent (and not respecting their license in the process).

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by Andrew_Quentin on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @07:22PM (#1766260)
are they earning anything from Oracle's lawsuit?

Well Oracle would probably be granted damages if so the court finds that the patent was infringed.

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by varikin on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @08:10PM (#1766355)
Oracle will earn something through winning the lawsuit, but their customers will not, which is what that line was referring to.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by Mahh on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @10:18AM (#1763988)
Consider who the 'consumers of java are. In particular, I'm thinking of a ton of college students taking computer science are introduced to programming through java. If college's CS departments start hating on java because of Oracle and change their curriculums, Java's foothold as a mainstream language is going to start fading away.

They only have to frustrate a certain group of people to start suffering from repercussions

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by wlievens on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @10:15AM (#1763982)
Oracle consumers have never heard of Oracle? I don't get it. Or are you talking about other (less relevant?) consumers?
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by gaius on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @10:26AM (#1764016)
Consumers who buy Android phones at retail obv.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by Goladus on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @12:34PM (#1764628)
Oracle's corporate customers most definitely care.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by 8ren on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @12:00PM (#1764484)
I've been thinking about Oracle's stewardship of Java, as an intellectual exercise. I'm going to argue for Oracle (because that's the opposite of how I feel.)

(1) Oracle is not a technology company. They don't have an engineering culture; they don't want an engineering culture. So James Gosling left and many others (though oddly, Guy Steele remains: http://labs.oracle.com/people/mybio.php?uid=25706). But maybe this doesn't matter for Java today...

Java has matured (some would say "stagnated") and that doesn't hurt its prospects for business use, but enhances them. And, quite amazingly, Java still has great qualities for today's two largest emerging markets: the Cloud (hey! the network is the computer!) and small embedded systems (like Android.) None too shabby, as-is.

(2) Oracle is a sales company. Sun was terrible at making money from Java. Maybe Java... needs Oracle?

Microsoft has pushed business cases and business applications, and C# and .Net have gained great acceptance, even though they are confined to MS's stack. Even Apple is succeeding with its closed iPhone/iPad "stack". Why can't Oracle do the same in an Enterprise stack? Yes, many Java developers will really hate it. Yet, that confinement hasn't stopped .net developers.

(3) The problem with Oracle is not sales vs. tech, but that they don't seem to be 100% on the ball - which is why Google is able to rip them apart so confidently. While I think the sales-based stewardship I outline above is plausible, it still needs to be well executed.

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by icey on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @12:06PM (#1764507)
.Net may be confined to the Microsoft stack but C# is not, thanks to Mono.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by rbanffy on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @12:27PM (#1764601)
Mono is a patent minefield. Microsoft's covenant only covers what is under the ECMA standard and most of the interesting parts aren't.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by icey on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @12:34PM (#1764629)
http://arstechnica.com/microsoft/news/2009/07/microsoft-issu...

FUD can come from both sides of the argument, I guess.

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by rbanffy on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @02:32PM (#1765183)
So, nothing of Mono falls outside the ECMA 334 and 335 scope, right?
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by tzs on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @12:43PM (#1764683)
You are oversimplifying. See http://www.infoq.com/articles/java-dotnet-patents for more information.
Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by rbanffy on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @02:36PM (#1765202)
A bit. You can work around the patents you know. Still, Microsoft retains the power to sue if any implementation of anything outside the community promise violates whatever patents they have.

One could expect Sun to be ethical. One can count on Microsoft doing the exact opposite.

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by kjksf on Wednesday October 06, 2010 @07:59PM (#1766331)
Thanks to Oracle Java is a minefield that Google stepped on and a bomb went off.

.NET (potential of being sued) is better than the alternative (Java, where someone has actually been sued).

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by rbanffy on Thursday October 07, 2010 @08:09AM (#1767544)
I'll take my chances with Oracle.

Oracle is in the business for money. Microsoft's in it for blood - because if they don't kill free and open-source software, they'll have no money.

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by Nelson69 on Thursday October 07, 2010 @09:18AM (#1767690)
Have a listen to the Java Posse this last week, #325. The new platform architect seems to think Java is in better hands, for the greater community too.

How do you simply dismiss Oracle as having a culture of engineering? Are the products bad? Is it simply that the corporation wants to profit? Is it the lack of hacker's names and faces on products? Is it the cost of the products or that they don't do something that they claim or should do?

I'd assert that they might be so good at engineering that it's no longer sexy to talk about it with them and they've matured so far beyond hacking that the names and faces aren't important.

Have you ever used any Sun hardware and then maybe a similar vintage IBM or HP piece of hardware?

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by 8ren on Thursday October 07, 2010 @11:57AM (#1768265)
It's well-known that Oracle isn't a technology company, but one that uses technology. It's not that their engineers are bad in any way, it's just that that's not a focus of the company as an organization. Instead, technology becomes a background issue (or a hygiene factor, as some economists call it.) It has to work, it has to be good; but it's not what makes the company go - they don't depend on Research and Development to produce a stream of new products. Any new tech they get is bought, via acquisition; and it is followed up only if it is of immediate value to their existing customers. They aren't creating new markets either (though recently they've bought some life sciences companies, which is a big branch out, and might shake up the health care sector in interesting ways.)

Of course, once upon a time, they created the very first commercial relational database, before even IBM (where Codd invented it.) But in the following decades, Oracle didn't keep on developing entirely new technologies.

Sun, IBM and HP all have or had strong engineering traditions (in particular HP used to, though not so much today.) Other examples with strong engineering are Sony, Nintendo, Adobe, TI, Intel and Apple. Another business company, like Oracle, is SAP. It's not intended as an insult, just a description of a company's approach. IBM has certainly moved much closer to that these days, it's almost a consulting company (like the big accounting firms), and its R&D has become very directed towards their client's immediate needs - at least, that's what they said at a presentation a few years ago.

I've read of Mark Reinhold's comments about what's happening with Java now (but not listened to that specific podcast.) He made an interesting point about the JRockit tech (acquired from BEA.) Let me ask you: is it realistic to imagine the new platform architect not saying positive things on this point, given his job and employer? If he thought otherwise, would he be given the job, with its significant Public Relations component (which is what that podcast is, from Oracle's perspective)?

In my view, I'm just stating well-known and accepted facts that I think Oracle itself would agree with. Can you tell me why you don't agree, please? You seem a little angry about it, too. I think it's possible you have misinterpreted me.

Re:Google responds aggressively to Oracle Java suit by 8ren on Friday October 08, 2010 @01:31AM (#1770746)
High technology is a little like some pacific islands, that are formed from magma swelling up from the depths of the earth. At first, they are desolate and empty, but life quickly colonizes them. You can live in paradise, eating the fruit, and riding the huge waves, serene and zen-like or yelling righteous! righteous!

As others come, some set themselves up as kings, living in grand huts, riding the people and telling them what to do.

Until one day, the earth opens up again and molten rock flows out, destroying the works of man, destroying whole islands and creating others.

I want to be absolutely clear on this next point: engineers in no way control or direct this wave of lava. They surf it.