Lets say you have a boxing match and your opponent's boxing gloves are slightly better than yours. The next boxing match, your opponent gives you his boxing gloves and he uses brass knuckles. You're currently better off compared to your previous self since you have better boxing gloves. But the distance between your current self and your opponent ( brass knuckles ) has increased significantly. So are you really better off?
It's like two groups going to battle. In the first battle, group A fights with wiffle bats and group B fights with baseball bats. For the next battle, group A wises up and brings baseball bats. But group B brings machine guns.
Technically, in battle 2, group A is better off with baseball bats rather than wiffle bats. But the "distance" between them and their opponent has increased significantly so you'd be hard pressed to say they are better off in battle 2.
This is the same trick economists use. Just because things improve in absolute terms over time doesn't mean that things are better off comparatively within societies.
With regards to progress only being relative, I think most people who get amazing medical treatments, will disagree with you.
Because power relations between groups is a zero sum game.
> With regards to progress only being relative, I think most people who get amazing medical treatments, will disagree with you.
I didn't say progress was relative. I didn't even mention relative. I specifically mention the wealth gap and the growing disparity between the rich and the rest and the uneven power disparity. Hence my examples of battle.
I was sure someone would bring up "zero-sum" but not the way you brought it up by misunderstanding my comment. The garden variety "zero-sum" response would justify the wealthy getting the lion share of wealth and everyone getting crumbs because everyone is still better off. And normally, I'd respond that if the wealthy got crumbs and the rest got the lion share, everyone would still be better off. You replaced one straw man with another.
I think you would be very interested to read the book, given the understanding you've demonstrated here.