Re:Steven Pinker’s case for optimism
by JumpCrisscross on Saturday July 28, 2018 @07:25PM
(#17635585)
> Then what happened? The 75-year great 20th century war from 1914 to 1989
The 20th century was the least violent century in human history on a per capita basis. We know this, in part, thanks to Pinker's research.
So... a baseless assumption that war is cyclic, despite this being disproven with data in Stevens previous works.
The world 200 years ago and the world today is different.. politics are different and out global community is VERY different.
In fact UN has been pointed to as one of the reasons why we have less war..
I think nukes contributed a lot more than the UN. Western Europe would have been invaded by the Soviet Union twice otherwise.
The UN may have contributed in a non-obvious way, as a one-stop-shopping experience for spies. Not knowing your adversaries' capability and intentions can contribute to pre-emptive strikes and invasion. Knowing your adversaries' secrets can lead to "meh, they're not such a threat."
I don't recall the data supporting this, do you have any?
In many ways, being able to say that is also what's cool about Pinkers book. Sure, it doesn't reference all studies ever done, but it does attempt to argue what worked and what didn't.
Re:Steven Pinker’s case for optimism
by DEADBEEFC0FFEE on Sunday July 29, 2018 @05:36AM
(#17637261)
It does however reference all the papers, that he uses.
Then what happened? The 75-year great 20th century war from 1914 to 1989. It had three or four phases: WWI, WWII, the cold war, the wars of southeast Asia.
I would not get too confident again.