News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What is more reliable, a DVD or an Hard drive? by brudgers on Saturday July 28, 2018 @11:50AM (#17633646)
[for personal data]

The unreliable part of a backup system is the human. Maybe DVD media is more reliable. Maybe it isn't. Probably it doesn't matter. If all your data fits on one DVD, then it is practical. If all your data doesn't fit on one DVD, then it's not...at least for most people[1] -- I think.

For me, I use hard disks. Not really as a explicit strategy [2], but because I have them laying around. I have them laying around from upgrading to SSD's and replacing laptops and installing new OS's...new disks are a time efficient way to upgrade an OS on an existing system. Compared to DVD's storing 100GB of data on an old 250GB hard disk is easy...or two old 250GB disks. Most of the time, I don't need old personal data. If I need it, it's ok to have a few (or many) copies...it's probably better. Short of storing video, HDD far outstrip most people's personal data needs. As I mentioned, that's still a common case for DVD's. It's just that DVD's require explicit backup and HDD's don't.

[1]: Anyone who is actually willing in practice to swap DVD's will almost certainly have already committed to a backup strategy.

[2]: Well ok, I have motherboard RAID mirroring on the tower ...I'd kind of forgotten about it because the tower is 10 years old and shipped with it.

There are no comments on this comment yet.