News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by vinceguidry on Friday July 27, 2018 @01:38PM (#17627662)
I think the conclusions the author makes are way too broad.

What generates consciousness, appears to me to be a function of what the neurons are all 'doing'. The brain has two features that are devoted to linguistic processing, and you have to activate them in order to find words for the things you think.

Thoughts that 'bubble up' all the way to linguistic representation in the mind are definitely conscious, while it's also possible to make some sense out of brain activity that doesn't quite find words. For example, playing ping pong or some other sport would be exceedingly difficult if you had to use the linguistic part of your brain in order to make sense of what you're doing.

If you meditate, you can focus on that 'line' between when thoughts become linguistic and when they don't, and if you do trance work, you can block out the sensory world and so generate experiences using 'only' the mind. From here, you can work out that brain activity becomes conscious at some point.

Also, obviously there is brain activity that does not reach consciousness, the brain for example needs to do things like regulate heartbeat, and certain aspects of our experience we're only dimly conscious of much of the time. Consciousness is a continuum, not a binary.

So our brains can be doing a lot that we're not aware of.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by dlwdlw on Friday July 27, 2018 @02:00PM (#17627806)
In the book “The Elephant in the Brain”, the author makes the argument that our consciousness is entirely the PR department of the brain, making explanations for the “company” but not truly knowing what’s really going on.

That is, all our thoughts are post-event justifications to make us feel good.

There’s this famous experiment where they show two different things to each eye of a brain divided patient. The patient would then follow instructions from 1 eye, but provide a justification based on what the other eye saw. Like a PR rep having to do the job but with email and communication being down.

The PR rep has to interpret things in a way that is in harmony to the external environment. Making the self seem self-less or hardworking or moral, etc...

Where it gets interesting is that the resulting PR effects affect the environment which then trigger new behaviors resulting in new PR spin. The PR rep has a degree of control over the system yet at the core of it, the PR rep is installed by language/culture/society and is somewhat of an outsider. Like an overly idealistic justice warrior sent to whitewash some corrupt company and being frustrated by the job.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by crazygringo on Friday July 27, 2018 @02:12PM (#17627882)
This is similar to the thesis of Antonio Damasio's "Descartes' Error", which argues that all our decisions are ultimately taken by an unconscious emotional part of the brain, and that the conscious reasoning part is merely one of many inputs to the unconscious decision-making part.

Which means we literally can never explain the "why" behind any decision we make, because we never know it -- yet that is our true "self", our free will if you choose to interpret it that way.

It's why we can have every rational reason to not eat the cookie, and zero rational reason to eat it (we're not hungry and we rationally know it's in our best interest to lose weight)... and then we eat it anyways. We can't give any rational explanation for why we ate it... it just comes down to, in the end, I wanted to due to emotional factors I can only hypothesize in hindsight.

It's a pretty powerful thesis.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by projektir on Saturday July 28, 2018 @01:04AM (#17631642)
> It's why we can have every rational reason to not eat the cookie, and zero rational reason to eat it (we're not hungry and we rationally know it's in our best interest to lose weight)... and then we eat it anyways. We can't give any rational explanation for why we ate it... it just comes down to, in the end, I wanted to due to emotional factors I can only hypothesize in hindsight.

I don't really think this is as a convincing example as a lot of people think. It has less to do with people having no control and more with people not understanding what "rational" is.

You eat the cookie because you do not, in reality, think eating the cookie is that much of a problem. The issue is that you likely have 5 other layers sitting trying to convince you that you don't want the cookie, because you're trying to fit in with society or whatever.

If you really didn't want to eat the cookie, you wouldn't.

The problem is that the average reason a person has for not eating a cookie is very unconvincing. It's often something along the lines of "well, people, somewhere, think I shouldn't eat too many cookies". "Cookies are unhealthy" also doesn't register, it's too broad. If someone told you the cookie was poisoned with cyanide, trust me, you wouldn't eat it.

It really doesn't have /that/ much to do with raw emotion, except in so far as emotion is composed from values, and your values don't care about eating cookies that much at the end of the day.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by perl4ever on Friday July 27, 2018 @07:53PM (#17630488)
I think you can and should, make an effort to infer the desires of the non-conscious part of the brain, because it's essential to happiness. It's easy to say people shouldn't deny what they truly want, but I think it's even more important to realize you don't know what you and your subconscious want until you explore possibilities and consequences.

Because brains are jury-rigged by evolution and not a clean integrated design by an intelligent engineer, I think it's natural that there should be a lot of co-dependent modules and redundant cruft that leads to conflicts.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by NihilumExNil on Friday July 27, 2018 @05:56PM (#17629754)
No, I don't believe this. Rather, as you note inhibition, you rationalize an excuse before hand, here that you have no control over your actions, and as that has so far always worked out, as far as immediate gratification is concerned whereas detriment is harder to grasp, the inhibition is inhibited. The mind is complex and for every prohibitive experience you have an inhibition to find an excuse to justify your actions. Of course, in habitual actions these processes are pretty deeply ingrained, quick, and hence not very conscious compared to much more complex problems that might even compete for attention. Still though, the rationalization of what was done can only come after wards. That is correct.
Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by jasonkostempski on Saturday July 28, 2018 @07:43AM (#17632726)
"Because it taste good" isn't a rational reason?
Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by vinceguidry on Friday July 27, 2018 @02:34PM (#17628079)
I don't buy this argument. I often marvel at just how rapid recognition is. Occasionally you get a slow-dawning realization, but most of the time, things are perceived instantly. It didn't make sense to me until I read somewhere that brain activity denotes 'confusion' while when you finally get a realization, all goes quiet. So recognition happens at speed of light leaving a room.

Sure, if you're purposefully trying to confuse the brain, it's going to be confused. You're actively subverting normal brain function. I bet if they kept performing the same trick, the brain would eventually realize what's going wrong and get quicker at making the realizations.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by somebodynew on Friday July 27, 2018 @05:42PM (#17629657)
If consciousness is merely an observation of decisions already made in the brain with no actual impact, how do we come to be discussing the concept of consciousness? If the decisions -> consciousness pipeline was only one way, how would the brain come to a state where it's producing a written description of the experience of consciousness?

This is why I've always found the notion of a "philosophical zombie" to be odd - if it accurately reproduces human behavior, then it would be able to have a conversation with you describing its own consciousness, even if it "doesn't have one".

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by AgentME on Saturday July 28, 2018 @12:19AM (#17631507)
I figure that consciousness is one of the inputs into the rest of the brain. It can convince other parts (but it's not the default mode, at least in many contexts). Sometimes companies do follow suggestions from the PR department.
Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by Drakim on Friday July 27, 2018 @06:45PM (#17630066)
Are you saying that it's impossible to discuss and reflect upon a falsehood?
Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by somebodynew on Friday July 27, 2018 @07:37PM (#17630388)
No, but if consciousness is just a side effect of the decisions made independently by the brain I would like to know why most humans' behavior can reflect the perception of consciousness. It seems like a pretty large coincidence that I'm experiencing consciousness and everyone else can explain the experience of consciousness in a way I can relate to, if consciousness is not perceptible by the brain.

I think that anyone claiming consciousness is just a rationalization of previous decisions needs an explanation of why the brain is apparently aware of and able to make decisions (like writing about consciousness) that depend on the ability of consciousness to change it's behavior.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by beagle3 on Saturday July 28, 2018 @05:15AM (#17632348)
I am not in the camp of "consciousness is just a side effect" - I do think it's one of the relatively minor inputs to decision making. But that camp IS consistent.

> I think that anyone claiming consciousness is just a rationalization of previous decisions needs an explanation of why the brain is apparently aware of and able to make decisions (like writing about consciousness) that depend on the ability of consciousness to change it's behavior.

A different analogy might help: The consciosness is a computer screen that usually displays a simplified image of (parts of) what's going on inside the CPU and memory, or lies, or something totally unrelated. It is possible to take a screenshot, dump it to memory, process it with the CPU, etc.

The notion that "conscious thought" would change that screenshot is equivalent to the message "Whatever is written here affects the CPU" appearing on the screen. It just means that the message was displayed, not that it came from a source other than everything else did.

You probably didn't notice, but you are actually arguing for "freedom of choice", which is its own philosophical can of worms, and is not really compatible with our understanding of physics or biology.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by red75prime on Saturday July 28, 2018 @02:42AM (#17631939)
> The patient would then follow instructions from 1 eye, but provide a justification based on what the other eye saw.

Well, you shouldn't expect broken system to work flawlessly. Splitting the brain makes survived parts of self-model inadequate. It's not reasonable to think that the self-model will not break, but automagically begin to reflect new hardware configuration of the brain. It will take time for parts it broke into to adapt.

As for this PR analogy, I find AlphaZero analogy more correct. One part of AlphaZero does all the heavy lifting, finding good looking moves for the current situation. Other part (Monte-Carlo tree search) selects the best moves (I think about it as conscious attention) and plays them to see where the game will go. The first part then uses the result of this to improve its own good moves heuristics.

Both parts are important, the part which generates allowances and the part which analyze, filter and selects what to really do.

Sequential nature of conscious attention make it impossible to control everything, but it doesn't mean that PR department just makes things up. It generates plausible descriptions of what you might be thinking, if you stopped and really though what to do instead of doing it without conscious control.

Those explanations aren't perfect, but PR department is just that, department. You are more than that, you can, if the need arises, reanalyze those descriptions focusing your attention and resources of all the departments on that task. You can change what you are doing and PR department will in time learn your new modus operandi to give better explanations.

I think you give too much credit to the PR department. Not all thoughts are after the fact justifications. I would say thoughts are invaluable tool to focus and coordinate all the brain subsystems, which by themselves lack vision of the whole situation and tend to produce fast and shallow automatic responses.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by hitekker on Saturday July 28, 2018 @02:47AM (#17631957)
The construct your describing is similar to and maybe roughly the same as https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narrative_identity, which is supported by a "strong empirical basis", a.k.a., evidence, not ivory tower, wishful thinking.

The most radical summation that I've heard is that human beings are, for large parts of our lives, just animals pretending to be people.

A scary thought.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by Symmetry on Friday July 27, 2018 @02:46PM (#17628193)
It's a lot more than that. For instance you can't remember things more than a second except to the extent that you become consciously aware of them.
Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by wahern on Friday July 27, 2018 @03:20PM (#17628493)
A second is way too short. Sometimes someone will say something and it'll be minutes before I consciously hear what they said. Auditory (and verbal) processing centers have circular buffers that can hold things for quite awhile. Visual not so much--people only imagine they can hold a picture in their mind.

But, yeah, in terms of long-term semantic and episodic memory you can't retain it unless you were conscious of it. People who claim so-called photographic memory in fact only consistently recall details that they consciously noticed. People with hyperthymesia also only remember stuff that they were consciously aware of.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by Symmetry on Friday July 27, 2018 @04:09PM (#17628908)
You heard that they said something though, right? Yes, you might not resolve the sound into words until after working at it but whether the brain promotes the stimulus to conscious awareness and saves it or if the activations fade should be entirely resolved within a few hundred milliseconds. The stimulus has to go superliminal to get into those circular buffers you're talking about, there aren't any buffers that big in subliminal processing.
Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by wahern on Monday July 30, 2018 @05:41PM (#17648330)
You're probably right. I shouldn't draw too many conclusions from my perceived experiences. And consciousness is complex enough that I might not appreciate my awareness of the sounds, not to mention my awareness of the elapsed time.

Plus, it's hard to argue against what the research suggests about echoic memory: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echoic_memory. Minutes is at least at least an order of magnitude greater than what's been shown.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by drb91 on Friday July 27, 2018 @01:41PM (#17627681)
> Thoughts that 'bubble up' all the way to linguistic representation in the mind are definitely conscious, while it's also possible to make some sense out of brain activity that doesn't quite find words. For example, playing ping pong or some other sport would be exceedingly difficult if you had to use the linguistic part of your brain in order to make sense of what you're doing.

Conscious brain activity always struck me as the primary meaning of "thought". The idea of conflating "thought" with unconscious brain activity just seems to devalue the word itself rather than bring some utility or added understanding to the table.

Personally, I don't think of breathing as a thought at all, or my heart beating, even though it's evidently controlled by the brain, evidently also the source of thoughts. I only really ever have evidence of thoughts as distinct from other brain functions because I experience them consciously.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by Retric on Friday July 27, 2018 @01:55PM (#17627781)
I regularly have non linguistic thoughts. Picture trying to pack a suitcase into the nearly full list trunk of your car and it's all objects not words.

Chess is a great example you picture a 'move' as a new layout. Practicing physical activities falls under the same kind of thing where I can focus on where to place my foot or when to breathe etc even when not doing the activity.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by vinceguidry on Friday July 27, 2018 @02:42PM (#17628154)
Personally, I believe it's the same part of your brain that forms words that also thinks conceptually. Words are never that far from human cognition.

If you want to get a sense for what non-linguistic thought would be, think more like your dog. The two language areas are the only functional difference between us and the animals. Once you start getting into the realm of things that dogs or other animals can't do, you're thinking linguistically.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by btmorex on Friday July 27, 2018 @05:06PM (#17629402)
Please explain https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aphasia then

My own personal anecdotal experience is that thinking in words is far, far slower than skipping them and sticking to concepts and connections.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by taneq on Saturday July 28, 2018 @02:39AM (#17631928)
> My own personal anecdotal experience is that thinking in words is far, far slower than skipping them and sticking to concepts and connections.

I find this as well. I've often caught myself waiting for my inner monologue to finish narrating a thought while simultaneously being fully aware that I've finished the reasoning part and already know the answer. When this happens I actively try to let go of the narration and just take the results and run with them. It's difficult but sometimes doable, and (for me at least) there's about an order of magnitude speedup.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by vinceguidry on Friday July 27, 2018 @07:58PM (#17630517)
What's there to explain? There's two parts of the brain involved in speech generation, damage one of them and you suddenly lose the ability to work with words. Depending on the extent of the damage, you will lose various comprehension abilities.

Like I stated earlier, I don't think all cognition is linguistic in nature, but I think you'll definitely lose 'something' if you break your language part.

My argument is that without language, we'll be present-focused and unable to appreciate conceptual subtleties, due to the inability to name and remix thoughts. Like other nonverbal mammals.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by perl4ever on Friday July 27, 2018 @08:00PM (#17630532)
I find words are my most effective path to concepts and connections. It might be related to how early you learn to read or innate brain wiring.
Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by Retric on Friday July 27, 2018 @02:43PM (#17628166)
This is the kind of thing you can look at using MRI scans and not all thoughts involve the linguistic centers of the brain.
Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by vinceguidry on Friday July 27, 2018 @04:35PM (#17629127)
I'm not disputing that and I left my MRI machine in my other pants, so we'll have to go on intuition until someone with an MRI decides to investigate.
Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by dingo_bat on Saturday July 28, 2018 @12:06AM (#17631455)
> Words are never that far from human cognition.

If true, I wonder how humans thought before language had evolved. Sounds like hell.

Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by perl4ever on Friday July 27, 2018 @07:58PM (#17630520)
I think verbal vs. spatial or other kinds of thought play different roles with different people. I find converting a problem to words helps even if it's an abstract programming problem that's no more inherently verbal than packing your car. Other people might prefer visual or mathematical approaches. I find written input to be an extremely good method of converting information to thoughts, but spoken words are far less effective for me.
Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by drb91 on Sunday July 29, 2018 @12:20AM (#17636494)
Sure, I can accept that. I think plenty of thoughts are non-linguistic.
Re:There Is No Such Thing as Unconscious Thought by perl4ever on Friday July 27, 2018 @07:42PM (#17630421)
Surely nobody who is reasonably high-functioning operates with a "single-threaded" consciousness.

Isn't it a common experience to work out problems in your sleep or while doing other tasks? If there's no thought going on beyond the surface of your awareness, where do these solutions come from?

I find analyzing a problem is facilitated by using words to describe it out loud or in writing, but there is clearly something that operates simultaneously apart from the target of my focus, because the description is not the analysis.

Also, I find your description of meditating not really in line with my experience - what I think of as meditating is focusing on a mantra in order to suppress conscious thought, gently pushing it away every time it resurfaces. "Generating experiences" would be the opposite of meditating to me.