> A “shutdown” cornerback like Richard Sherman can be a star in the NFL thanks to interceptions, broken up plays and tackles. “Lock down NBA defenders” like Bruce Bowen and Dennis Rodman can prove their worth with steals, blocks and rebounds. Football has goals and assists, that’s it.
Just as in soccer, those "counting stats" are not great measures of defensive ability. The recently retired cornerback Darrelle Revis was regarded as the best defensive player in the NFL from about 2009-2011. Yet he did not rack up interceptions or pass breakups -- in fact, in 2010, he had 0 interceptions and only 9 pass breakups over 13 games. Why? Because the receivers he was covering were never open, so quarterbacks rarely attempted to pass in his direction.
Similarly, steals, blocks, and rebounds are only a vague indicator of defensive ability; it's never a bad thing to get a steal or a block, but if you routinely leave your man to try to poke the ball away from someone else's man, you're likely hurting your team overall. The NBA has been working on developing better stats, including deflections (you get your hand on a pass but don't necessarily come away with the steal) and shots defended (you're within a short distance of a shooter). But Darryl Morey, general manager of the Houston Rockets and a well-known stats nerd, has said in a Reddit AMA that no publicly available defensive statistic is useful.
Part of this is because all three sports in question are team sports, which means a great deal depends on the defensive scheme. You may not block shots, but is it your job to block shots or to stop the ballhandler from getting near the basket? You don't get tackles, but is it your job to get tackles or to funnel the ballcarrier right into the linebackers?
It's extremely difficult for any outsider to determine the defensive effectiveness of a player. The only thing we can offer is guesswork.
Sure, you have people who write a ton of code and implement a lot of features, and fix a lot of bugs, who clearly are contributing a lot. But you also have people who, though other means (code reviews, refactoring and other code-health work, etc) ensure that a project is maintainable and sustainable.
How do you measure the value of 100 bugs that never made it to production because of high quality code-reviews? Or those 5 high-value features which were a snap to implement because somebody took the time to clean up all the cruft from Mr Rockstar Bro who made a gigantic mess?
Of course there's also stuff like GoalImpact which just tries to apply plus minus to football, but all the old arguments about football being a low scoring game apply here.
> Impect disregards all passes that go backwards or don’t beat any defender. It’s a correct assessment, a pass that doesn’t travel forwards, doesn’t help you score. Can’t argue with that.
This is a really odd statement. Plenty of passes don't go forward but absolutely do increase the likelihood of scoring. For example, the final pass here [0] is backwards, might even allow an additional defender time to track back (-1 packing?) but opens up the space required to take a shot and score.
I'd guess that either "Impect disregards all passes that go backwards or don’t beat any defender" would be better phrased as "Impect disregards passes unless they go forward or beat defenders" or the statisticians would defend the original solely in terms of it being a heuristic that makes the problem more tractable.
Additionally, your linked example, with #25 picking up the ball in a danger position after a deflection, is the kind of "penalty box slop" that, naively at least, seems extremely difficult to handle analytically.
Useful backward passes fall into at least two categories. The ones that eventually result in an impect, and the ones that run down the clock at the end of the game.
Yes, that's basically what I'm saying is bad about the statement that backwards passes don't help you score goals.
> Useful backward passes fall into at least two categories. The ones that eventually result in an impect, and the ones that run down the clock at the end of the game.
I think this is almost correct, but I think there is a third category: Backwards passes that immediately result in a shot resulting in a goal. In the example video I posted above, the final pass is backwards and is immediately shot into the net. This doesn't increase impect (ie: Messi dribbles past 4 players, then shoots and scores past 3 more, is only impect +4, according to the article).
This is what the Italians really do well with their "verticalizzazione" (I guess "verticalization" would be the closest English translation, even though I'm not sure that's a word yet), i.e. deep passing when you're (usually) 30 to 50 meters outside the opposing post. For an excellent example see this YT video (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wWr1tTFt7a4) of Sarri's Napoli doing it (Sarri is now Chelsea's coach, that should be interesting).
Packing is the measurement of how many opposition players are beaten by a pass (or dribble or other move).
Impect is the number of deep lying defenders beaten, which is obviously more valuable compared to high pressing strikers.
The key insight is that defenders beaten, particularly deeper-lying defenders are the measurement needed to identify who is expected to win (and therefore assessing the value of passing players, or defenders).
http://bundesligafanatic.com/20160610/impect-packing-the-fut...