Re:Amazon’s Face Recognition Falsely Matched 28 Members of C...
by mrweasel on Thursday July 26, 2018 @10:02AM
(#17617578)
The problem is that it's only 95% perfect in this case (28 out of 534, being identified as criminals). That a pretty big margin of error when the result is possible arrest. The scope of its use is also in question, sure if you looking a someone who kidnapped a child, 95% is good enough. If you use it for any minor violation you risk harassing a large percentage of the population, who then will need to prove that it wasn't them. Some will flat out deny being the guilty party, and there's a 5% margin of error, so they may very well be right. Then what will you do, drop the charge? In that case what's the point. Or will you spend police time finding evidence that some random person stole $10 worth of good at the super market?
The cost associated with being just 5% wrong is huge, and that's not including the emotional damage done to falsely accused citizens, or the decrease level of trust in law enforcement.
Re:Amazon’s Face Recognition Falsely Matched 28 Members of C...
by sadris on Thursday July 26, 2018 @10:11AM
(#17617647)
They weren't "identified as criminals." They were identified as possibly being criminals. (And as other posters have shown, they were identified with only 80% confidence as being a criminal.) And an officer can review the evidence presented by the report and make a human determination to follow up with a physical arrest.
Re:Amazon’s Face Recognition Falsely Matched 28 Members of C...
by SmellyGeekBoy on Thursday July 26, 2018 @10:16AM
(#17617691)
Perhaps more of an issue in a country where being arrested can involve being murdered by the police.
Re:Amazon’s Face Recognition Falsely Matched 28 Members of C...
by akira2501 on Thursday July 26, 2018 @03:09PM
(#17620055)
> They were identified as possibly being criminals.
And you've highlighted the _exact_ problem here. That is not at all what has happened, they have been identified as "possibly having a similar appearance to one or more particular images of a suspected criminal."
> And an officer can review the evidence presented by the report and make a human determination to follow up with a physical arrest.
Which already presumes that the system will only have false positives. When the system produces false negatives, then this mode of investigation is entirely flawed.
Re:Amazon’s Face Recognition Falsely Matched 28 Members of C...
by alphabettsy on Thursday July 26, 2018 @10:37AM
(#17617819)
I’m pretty certain they take issue with law enforcement using the technology that’s not 100% and without oversight because they have the ability to seriously alter someone’s life.
Bone marrow transplants for cancer treatment used to have a 20% failure rate. I didn't think for a second that we should cease using bone marrow transplants.
And yet why does the ACLU think we should cease using a technology to deliver potential location hits on wanted criminals because its not 100% perfect?