Ah yes, the old "we are bombing them for their own good" argument.
To answer your question directly, yes it would be more peaceful (it was more peaceful in both cases before we invaded and i expect things would settle down pretty soon after we left). More importantly, the blood would not be on our hands.
And (I'll say it again) if we waged peace by providing food, medicine, education, etc we could save a lot of lives, instead of stoking the cycle of violence.
Now that we're trying to get out of these countries, further US troops are basically trading their lives for some multiple of that number in civilians lives that would be lost if we just let the countries collaspe.
Take your pick, it seems to me that Obama (and Bush at the end) was choosing to lose US lives to prevent the anarchy and loss of foreign civilian lives that would result of an irresponsible exit.
Arguing that we shouldn't have gone in the first place (which I think is the case) doesn't change the fact that today we are already there.