News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:XEmacs is Dead! Long Live XEmacs! by jrockway on Monday April 28, 2008 @06:49PM (#176092)
FWIW, Elisp is much nicer than JavaScript. It could stand to gain some features like static scoping and threading, but the "library" is so useful it's easy to ignore the linguistic flaws.

I'm sure an emacs-in-JavaScript would also have a good library, but let's face it... Lisp is very enjoyable to use. There may be more JavaScript programmers than Lisp programmers... but the same could be said for PHP, and I don't think anyone wants a PHPmacs :)

Re:XEmacs is Dead! Long Live XEmacs! by Xichekolas on Monday April 28, 2008 @07:09PM (#176105)
But you said in another comment here that you are an elisp developer... of course you are going to think it's nicer.

I'm not married to the javascript idea, I just suggested that because it's already used for a ton of other things in the browser, so it'd make sense to make the browser-as-editor extensible in javascript.

If we really want to make it from the ground up, it'd be nice if we could replace javascript with something like Scheme[1] (or Arc ;) as the de-facto client-side scripting-language in the browser.

My issue with doing it in elisp is that it's yet another special purpose language to use, and the web already requires three or four of them to get anything done as it is. I'm not scared of learning it, but if I am going to dream of pie-in-the-sky, I might as well dream of a world where one language gets things done on the web.

[1] I would suggest Lisp here, but honestly I got started with Scheme, and for some reason (purely aesthetic), CL just seems so ugly to me.